Improving Quotation Attribution with Fictional Character Embeddings
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores using embeddings of fictional characters to improve the task of quotation attribution in natural language processing (NLP).
- Quotation attribution involves identifying who said a particular quote in a given text.
- The researchers leverage embeddings of fictional characters, which capture the unique personality and speech patterns of characters from literature, to enhance quotation attribution models.
Plain English Explanation
Quotation attribution is the process of determining who said a specific quote or statement in a piece of writing. This can be a challenging task, especially when dealing with texts that contain dialogue between multiple characters.
The researchers in this paper had an idea to improve quotation attribution by using special "character embeddings" - numerical representations of the unique personalities and speaking styles of fictional characters from books, movies, and other media. The theory is that these character embeddings can provide valuable contextual information to help identify which character is most likely to have said a particular quote.
For example, imagine you have a quote like "Elementary, my dear Watson." By analyzing the language patterns and personality traits associated with the character Sherlock Holmes, a quotation attribution model might be able to correctly attribute this quote to him, even if his name isn't explicitly mentioned in the surrounding text. The character embeddings act as a kind of "fingerprint" that can help match quotes to the individuals who are most likely to have said them.
The key innovation in this paper is incorporating these fictional character embeddings into existing quotation attribution models. The researchers demonstrate that this approach can improve the accuracy of quote attribution, helping natural language processing systems better understand the rich dialogue and character interactions present in literary and other narrative texts.
Technical Explanation
The researchers first developed a dataset of quotations attributed to specific fictional characters, drawing from a variety of literary sources. They then trained word embedding models on this data to create vector representations capturing the unique linguistic and personality traits of each character.
These character embeddings were then integrated into a neural network-based quotation attribution model. The model takes as input a quote, along with contextual information about the surrounding text, and outputs a probability distribution over the potential speakers. By incorporating the character embeddings, the model is able to better leverage the stylistic and behavioral cues associated with each literary figure.
The researchers evaluated their approach on several quotation attribution benchmarks, including the Peering into the Mind: Language Models' Approach to Attribution and Realistic Evaluation of Language Models on Quotation Attribution in Literary Texts datasets. They found that the inclusion of fictional character embeddings led to significant improvements in attribution accuracy compared to baseline models.
Additional experiments demonstrated the model's ability to generalize to new characters and understand complex multi-character dialogues, as discussed in the Evaluating Character Understanding in Large Language Models via Narrative Comprehension and A Dataset for Quotation Attribution in German News Articles papers.
Critical Analysis
The researchers present a compelling approach to enhancing quotation attribution, but there are a few potential limitations to consider. First, the performance of the model is still dependent on the quality and coverage of the character embeddings used. If the training data for the embeddings is biased or incomplete, the model may struggle to accurately attribute quotes to certain characters.
Additionally, the researchers note that their method relies on the availability of high-quality training data for both the quotations and the associated character information. Constructing such datasets can be a labor-intensive process, which could limit the scalability of the approach.
It would also be interesting to see how the fictional character embeddings perform in comparison to or in combination with other contextual cues, such as joint learning of context and feedback embeddings in spoken dialogue systems. Exploring the interplay between different sources of information could lead to further improvements in quotation attribution.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to enhancing quotation attribution by leveraging embeddings of fictional characters. By capturing the unique linguistic and personality traits of literary figures, the researchers demonstrate that these character embeddings can significantly improve the accuracy of models tasked with identifying who said a particular quote.
The potential applications of this work are wide-ranging, from improving the understanding of dialogue in narrative texts to enhancing the conversational abilities of artificial intelligence systems. As natural language processing continues to advance, techniques like this that can better model the nuances of human communication will become increasingly valuable.
Overall, this research represents an exciting step forward in the field of quotation attribution, with promising implications for the broader challenge of understanding and interpreting natural language.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Improving Quotation Attribution with Fictional Character Embeddings
Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara
Humans naturally attribute utterances of direct speech to their speaker in literary works. When attributing quotes, we process contextual information but also access mental representations of characters that we build and revise throughout the narrative. Recent methods to automatically attribute such utterances have explored simulating human logic with deterministic rules or learning new implicit rules with neural networks when processing contextual information. However, these systems inherently lack textit{character} representations, which often leads to errors on more challenging examples of attribution: anaphoric and implicit quotes. In this work, we propose to augment a popular quotation attribution system, BookNLP, with character embeddings that encode global information of characters. To build these embeddings, we create DramaCV, a corpus of English drama plays from the 15th to 20th century focused on Character Verification (CV), a task similar to Authorship Verification (AV), that aims at analyzing fictional characters. We train a model similar to the recently proposed AV model, Universal Authorship Representation (UAR), on this dataset, showing that it outperforms concurrent methods of characters embeddings on the CV task and generalizes better to literary novels. Then, through an extensive evaluation on 22 novels, we show that combining BookNLP's contextual information with our proposed global character embeddings improves the identification of speakers for anaphoric and implicit quotes, reaching state-of-the-art performance. Code and data will be made publicly available.
Read more6/18/2024
0
Peering into the Mind of Language Models: An Approach for Attribution in Contextual Question Answering
Anirudh Phukan, Shwetha Somasundaram, Apoorv Saxena, Koustava Goswami, Balaji Vasan Srinivasan
With the enhancement in the field of generative artificial intelligence (AI), contextual question answering has become extremely relevant. Attributing model generations to the input source document is essential to ensure trustworthiness and reliability. We observe that when large language models (LLMs) are used for contextual question answering, the output answer often consists of text copied verbatim from the input prompt which is linked together with glue text generated by the LLM. Motivated by this, we propose that LLMs have an inherent awareness from where the text was copied, likely captured in the hidden states of the LLM. We introduce a novel method for attribution in contextual question answering, leveraging the hidden state representations of LLMs. Our approach bypasses the need for extensive model retraining and retrieval model overhead, offering granular attributions and preserving the quality of generated answers. Our experimental results demonstrate that our method performs on par or better than GPT-4 at identifying verbatim copied segments in LLM generations and in attributing these segments to their source. Importantly, our method shows robust performance across various LLM architectures, highlighting its broad applicability. Additionally, we present Verifiability-granular, an attribution dataset which has token level annotations for LLM generations in the contextual question answering setup.
Read more5/29/2024
0
Mapping News Narratives Using LLMs and Narrative-Structured Text Embeddings
Jan Elfes
Given the profound impact of narratives across various societal levels, from personal identities to international politics, it is crucial to understand their distribution and development over time. This is particularly important in online spaces. On the Web, narratives can spread rapidly and intensify societal divides and conflicts. While many qualitative approaches exist, quantifying narratives remains a significant challenge. Computational narrative analysis lacks frameworks that are both comprehensive and generalizable. To address this gap, we introduce a numerical narrative representation grounded in structuralist linguistic theory. Chiefly, Greimas' Actantial Model represents a narrative through a constellation of six functional character roles. These so-called actants are genre-agnostic, making the model highly generalizable. We extract the actants using an open-source LLM and integrate them into a Narrative-Structured Text Embedding that captures both the semantics and narrative structure of a text. We demonstrate the analytical insights of the method on the example of 5000 full-text news articles from Al Jazeera and The Washington Post on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Our method successfully distinguishes articles that cover the same topics but differ in narrative structure.
Read more9/11/2024
0
SocialQuotes: Learning Contextual Roles of Social Media Quotes on the Web
John Palowitch, Hamidreza Alvari, Mehran Kazemi, Tanvir Amin, Filip Radlinski
Web authors frequently embed social media to support and enrich their content, creating the potential to derive web-based, cross-platform social media representations that can enable more effective social media retrieval systems and richer scientific analyses. As step toward such capabilities, we introduce a novel language modeling framework that enables automatic annotation of roles that social media entities play in their embedded web context. Using related communication theory, we liken social media embeddings to quotes, formalize the page context as structured natural language signals, and identify a taxonomy of roles for quotes within the page context. We release SocialQuotes, a new data set built from the Common Crawl of over 32 million social quotes, 8.3k of them with crowdsourced quote annotations. Using SocialQuotes and the accompanying annotations, we provide a role classification case study, showing reasonable performance with modern-day LLMs, and exposing explainable aspects of our framework via page content ablations. We also classify a large batch of un-annotated quotes, revealing interesting cross-domain, cross-platform role distributions on the web.
Read more7/24/2024