An Incremental MaxSAT-based Model to Learn Interpretable and Balanced Classification Rules
2403.16418
0
0
📈
Abstract
The increasing advancements in the field of machine learning have led to the development of numerous applications that effectively address a wide range of problems with accurate predictions. However, in certain cases, accuracy alone may not be sufficient. Many real-world problems also demand explanations and interpretability behind the predictions. One of the most popular interpretable models that are classification rules. This work aims to propose an incremental model for learning interpretable and balanced rules based on MaxSAT, called IMLIB. This new model was based on two other approaches, one based on SAT and the other on MaxSAT. The one based on SAT limits the size of each generated rule, making it possible to balance them. We suggest that such a set of rules seem more natural to be understood compared to a mixture of large and small rules. The approach based on MaxSAT, called IMLI, presents a technique to increase performance that involves learning a set of rules by incrementally applying the model in a dataset. Finally, IMLIB and IMLI are compared using diverse databases. IMLIB obtained results comparable to IMLI in terms of accuracy, generating more balanced rules with smaller sizes.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Proposes an incremental MaxSAT-based model to learn interpretable and balanced classification rules
- Aims to generate transparent and fair machine learning models
- Leverages the Maximum Satisfiability (MaxSAT) optimization problem to learn classification rules
Plain English Explanation
This research paper presents an approach to [evolving-interpretable-visual-classifiers-large-language-models] that can learn [towards-logically-consistent-language-models-via-probabilistic] and [center-based-relaxed-learning-against-membership-inference] classification rules in an [effective-decision-boundary-learning-class-incremental-learning] manner. The key idea is to formulate the rule learning task as a [large-language-models-can-learn-rules] optimization problem, which can be solved efficiently using existing MaxSAT solvers.
The proposed model incrementally learns a set of interpretable classification rules that aim to achieve a balance between accuracy and fairness. By framing the problem in this way, the authors are able to generate transparent and fair machine learning models that can be more easily understood and trusted by end-users.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by formally defining the problem of learning interpretable and balanced classification rules. The authors then present an incremental MaxSAT-based model to solve this problem. The core idea is to encode the rule learning task as a series of MaxSAT problems, where the objective is to find a set of rules that maximize classification accuracy while satisfying fairness constraints.
The proposed approach works as follows:
- Initialize with a small set of candidate rules.
- Solve a MaxSAT problem to find the optimal set of rules that maximizes accuracy and satisfies fairness constraints.
- Incrementally expand the set of candidate rules and repeat step 2 until convergence.
The authors evaluate their approach on several benchmark datasets and show that it can learn accurate and fair classification rules that are more interpretable than traditional black-box models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and interesting approach to learning interpretable and balanced classification rules. The use of MaxSAT optimization to solve this problem is a clever idea, and the authors demonstrate its effectiveness through empirical evaluation.
However, the paper could be strengthened by a more thorough discussion of the limitations and potential issues with the proposed approach. For example, the authors do not address the scalability of the MaxSAT solver as the number of candidate rules grows, which could be a significant concern for large-scale real-world problems.
Additionally, the paper would benefit from a more in-depth comparison to other [evolving-interpretable-visual-classifiers-large-language-models] and [towards-logically-consistent-language-models-via-probabilistic] techniques, such as decision trees, rule lists, or global surrogate models. This could help better situate the proposed approach within the broader context of interpretable machine learning.
Conclusion
Overall, this paper presents a novel and promising approach to learning interpretable and balanced classification rules using an incremental MaxSAT-based model. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmark datasets, and the research has the potential to contribute to the growing field of [center-based-relaxed-learning-against-membership-inference] and [effective-decision-boundary-learning-class-incremental-learning] machine learning.
The use of [large-language-models-can-learn-rules] optimization to solve this problem is a clever and innovative idea, and the authors' focus on generating transparent and fair models is highly relevant and important for the widespread adoption of AI systems. Further research and refinement of this approach could lead to significant advancements in the field of interpretable and trustworthy machine learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛸
Rule Generation for Classification: Scalability, Interpretability, and Fairness
Tabea E. Rober, Adia C. Lumadjeng, M. Hakan Akyuz, c{S}. .Ilker Birbil
0
0
We introduce a new rule-based optimization method for classification with constraints. The proposed method leverages column generation for linear programming, and hence, is scalable to large datasets. The resulting pricing subproblem is shown to be NP-Hard. We recourse to a decision tree-based heuristic and solve a proxy pricing subproblem for acceleration. The method returns a set of rules along with their optimal weights indicating the importance of each rule for learning. We address interpretability and fairness by assigning cost coefficients to the rules and introducing additional constraints. In particular, we focus on local interpretability and generalize separation criterion in fairness to multiple sensitive attributes and classes. We test the performance of the proposed methodology on a collection of datasets and present a case study to elaborate on its different aspects. The proposed rule-based learning method exhibits a good compromise between local interpretability and fairness on the one side, and accuracy on the other side.
5/14/2024
SLIM: a Scalable Light-weight Root Cause Analysis for Imbalanced Data in Microservice
Rui Ren, Jingbang Yang, Linxiao Yang, Xinyue Gu, Liang Sun
0
0
The newly deployed service -- one kind of change service, could lead to a new type of minority fault. Existing state-of-the-art methods for fault localization rarely consider the imbalanced fault classification in change service. This paper proposes a novel method that utilizes decision rule sets to deal with highly imbalanced data by optimizing the F1 score subject to cardinality constraints. The proposed method greedily generates the rule with maximal marginal gain and uses an efficient minorize-maximization (MM) approach to select rules iteratively, maximizing a non-monotone submodular lower bound. Compared with existing fault localization algorithms, our algorithm can adapt to the imbalanced fault scenario of change service, and provide interpretable fault causes which are easy to understand and verify. Our method can also be deployed in the online training setting, with only about 15% training overhead compared to the current SOTA methods. Empirical studies showcase that our algorithm outperforms existing fault localization algorithms in both accuracy and model interpretability.
6/3/2024
Self-supervised Interpretable Concept-based Models for Text Classification
Francesco De Santis, Philippe Bich, Gabriele Ciravegna, Pietro Barbiero, Danilo Giordano, Tania Cerquitelli
0
0
Despite their success, Large-Language Models (LLMs) still face criticism as their lack of interpretability limits their controllability and reliability. Traditional post-hoc interpretation methods, based on attention and gradient-based analysis, offer limited insight into the model's decision-making processes. In the image field, Concept-based models have emerged as explainable-by-design architectures, employing human-interpretable features as intermediate representations. However, these methods have not been yet adapted to textual data, mainly because they require expensive concept annotations, which are impractical for real-world text data. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a self-supervised Interpretable Concept Embedding Models (ICEMs). We leverage the generalization abilities of LLMs to predict the concepts labels in a self-supervised way, while we deliver the final predictions with an interpretable function. The results of our experiments show that ICEMs can be trained in a self-supervised way achieving similar performance to fully supervised concept-based models and end-to-end black-box ones. Additionally, we show that our models are (i) interpretable, offering meaningful logical explanations for their predictions; (ii) interactable, allowing humans to modify intermediate predictions through concept interventions; and (iii) controllable, guiding the LLMs' decoding process to follow a required decision-making path.
6/21/2024
Scalable Rule Lists Learning with Sampling
Leonardo Pellegrina, Fabio Vandin
0
0
Learning interpretable models has become a major focus of machine learning research, given the increasing prominence of machine learning in socially important decision-making. Among interpretable models, rule lists are among the best-known and easily interpretable ones. However, finding optimal rule lists is computationally challenging, and current approaches are impractical for large datasets. We present a novel and scalable approach to learn nearly optimal rule lists from large datasets. Our algorithm uses sampling to efficiently obtain an approximation of the optimal rule list with rigorous guarantees on the quality of the approximation. In particular, our algorithm guarantees to find a rule list with accuracy very close to the optimal rule list when a rule list with high accuracy exists. Our algorithm builds on the VC-dimension of rule lists, for which we prove novel upper and lower bounds. Our experimental evaluation on large datasets shows that our algorithm identifies nearly optimal rule lists with a speed-up up to two orders of magnitude over state-of-the-art exact approaches. Moreover, our algorithm is as fast as, and sometimes faster than, recent heuristic approaches, while reporting higher quality rule lists. In addition, the rules reported by our algorithm are more similar to the rules in the optimal rule list than the rules from heuristic approaches.
6/19/2024