Innovative Speech-Based Deep Learning Approaches for Parkinson's Disease Classification: A Systematic Review

Read original: arXiv:2407.17844 - Published 9/9/2024 by Lisanne van Gelderen, Cristian Tejedor-Garc'ia

🤿

Overview

Parkinson's disease (PD) is the second most common neurodegenerative disorder worldwide.
Early-stage PD often presents with speech impairments.
Advancements in deep learning (DL) have enhanced PD diagnosis using speech data.
Limited availability of public speech-based PD datasets is a key challenge.

Plain English Explanation

Parkinson's disease is a very common neurological condition that affects how the brain controls movement. One of the early signs of Parkinson's is problems with speech, like speaking more quietly or having a hoarse voice. Recent progress in artificial intelligence, especially a technique called deep learning, has helped doctors get better at diagnosing Parkinson's by analyzing a person's speech.

However, a big challenge is that there isn't much publicly available data on the speech patterns of people with Parkinson's. Researchers often can't access speech recordings due to privacy and ethical concerns. This makes it harder for them to develop and test new AI systems for detecting Parkinson's from speech.

Technical Explanation

This review examines the latest deep learning approaches for classifying Parkinson's disease using speech data. It covers 33 scientific studies published between 2020 and 2024. The deep learning methods are categorized into three main types:

End-to-end (E2E) learning: These systems take raw speech signals as input and directly output a Parkinson's disease classification. Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) are commonly used, though transformer models are gaining popularity. E2E approaches face challenges like limited training data and computational resources, especially for transformer models.
Transfer learning (TL): These methods leverage pre-trained models to provide more robust Parkinson's diagnosis and better generalization across different languages.
Deep acoustic feature (DAF) extraction: These approaches aim to improve the explainability and interpretability of results by examining how specific deep features affect the performance of both deep learning and traditional machine learning methods. However, DAF methods often underperform compared to E2E and TL.

Critical Analysis

The review highlights several unresolved issues in this research area, including:

Bias and lack of diversity in the available datasets
Limited explainability and interpretability of the deep learning models
Concerns around privacy and ethical use of speech data for Parkinson's diagnosis

These challenges point to the need for further research to address these limitations and develop more robust, trustworthy, and equitable AI systems for Parkinson's disease detection.

Conclusion

This review summarizes the latest progress in using deep learning to diagnose Parkinson's disease from speech data. While the advancements are promising, significant challenges remain around data availability, model interpretability, and ethical considerations. Addressing these issues will be crucial for translating this research into real-world clinical applications that can benefit patients with Parkinson's disease.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤿

Innovative Speech-Based Deep Learning Approaches for Parkinson's Disease Classification: A Systematic Review

Lisanne van Gelderen, Cristian Tejedor-Garc'ia

Parkinson's disease (PD), the second most prevalent neurodegenerative disorder worldwide, frequently presents with early-stage speech impairments. Recent advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI), particularly deep learning (DL), have significantly enhanced PD diagnosis through the analysis of speech data. Nevertheless, the progress of research is restricted by the limited availability of publicly accessible speech-based PD datasets, primarily due to privacy concerns. The goal of this systematic review is to explore the current landscape of speech-based DL approaches for PD classification, based on 33 scientific works published between January 2020 and March 2024. We discuss their available resources, capabilities, and potential limitations, and issues related to bias, explainability, and privacy. Furthermore, this review provides an overview of publicly accessible speech-based datasets and open-source material for PD. The DL approaches identified are categorized into end-to-end (E2E) learning, transfer learning (TL), and deep acoustic feature extraction (DAFE). Among E2E approaches, Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) are prevalent, though Transformers are increasingly popular. E2E approaches face challenges such as limited data and computational resources, especially with Transformers. TL addresses these issues by providing more robust PD diagnosis and better generalizability across languages. DAFE aims to improve the explainability and interpretability of results by examining the specific effects of deep features on both other DL approaches and more traditional machine learning (ML) methods. However, it often underperforms compared to E2E and TL approaches.

9/9/2024

Early Recognition of Parkinson's Disease Through Acoustic Analysis and Machine Learning

Niloofar Fadavi, Nazanin Fadavi

Parkinson's Disease (PD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder that significantly impacts both motor and non-motor functions, including speech. Early and accurate recognition of PD through speech analysis can greatly enhance patient outcomes by enabling timely intervention. This paper provides a comprehensive review of methods for PD recognition using speech data, highlighting advances in machine learning and data-driven approaches. We discuss the process of data wrangling, including data collection, cleaning, transformation, and exploratory data analysis, to prepare the dataset for machine learning applications. Various classification algorithms are explored, including logistic regression, SVM, and neural networks, with and without feature selection. Each method is evaluated based on accuracy, precision, and training time. Our findings indicate that specific acoustic features and advanced machine-learning techniques can effectively differentiate between individuals with PD and healthy controls. The study concludes with a comparison of the different models, identifying the most effective approaches for PD recognition, and suggesting potential directions for future research.

7/24/2024

🔎

A Novel Fusion Architecture for PD Detection Using Semi-Supervised Speech Embeddings

Tariq Adnan, Abdelrahman Abdelkader, Zipei Liu, Ekram Hossain, Sooyong Park, MD Saiful Islam, Ehsan Hoque

We present a framework to recognize Parkinson's disease (PD) through an English pangram utterance speech collected using a web application from diverse recording settings and environments, including participants' homes. Our dataset includes a global cohort of 1306 participants, including 392 diagnosed with PD. Leveraging the diversity of the dataset, spanning various demographic properties (such as age, sex, and ethnicity), we used deep learning embeddings derived from semi-supervised models such as Wav2Vec 2.0, WavLM, and ImageBind representing the speech dynamics associated with PD. Our novel fusion model for PD classification, which aligns different speech embeddings into a cohesive feature space, demonstrated superior performance over standard concatenation-based fusion models and other baselines (including models built on traditional acoustic features). In a randomized data split configuration, the model achieved an Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUROC) of 88.94% and an accuracy of 85.65%. Rigorous statistical analysis confirmed that our model performs equitably across various demographic subgroups in terms of sex, ethnicity, and age, and remains robust regardless of disease duration. Furthermore, our model, when tested on two entirely unseen test datasets collected from clinical settings and from a PD care center, maintained AUROC scores of 82.12% and 78.44%, respectively. This affirms the model's robustness and it's potential to enhance accessibility and health equity in real-world applications.

5/28/2024

Exploiting Foundation Models and Speech Enhancement for Parkinson's Disease Detection from Speech in Real-World Operative Conditions

Moreno La Quatra, Maria Francesca Turco, Torbj{o}rn Svendsen, Giampiero Salvi, Juan Rafael Orozco-Arroyave, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi

This work is concerned with devising a robust Parkinson's (PD) disease detector from speech in real-world operating conditions using (i) foundational models, and (ii) speech enhancement (SE) methods. To this end, we first fine-tune several foundational-based models on the standard PC-GITA (s-PC-GITA) clean data. Our results demonstrate superior performance to previously proposed models. Second, we assess the generalization capability of the PD models on the extended PC-GITA (e-PC-GITA) recordings, collected in real-world operative conditions, and observe a severe drop in performance moving from ideal to real-world conditions. Third, we align training and testing conditions applaying off-the-shelf SE techniques on e-PC-GITA, and a significant boost in performance is observed only for the foundational-based models. Finally, combining the two best foundational-based models trained on s-PC-GITA, namely WavLM Base and Hubert Base, yielded top performance on the enhanced e-PC-GITA.

6/25/2024