On instabilities in neural network-based physics simulators
2406.13101
0
0
Abstract
When neural networks are trained from data to simulate the dynamics of physical systems, they encounter a persistent challenge: the long-time dynamics they produce are often unphysical or unstable. We analyze the origin of such instabilities when learning linear dynamical systems, focusing on the training dynamics. We make several analytical findings which empirical observations suggest extend to nonlinear dynamical systems. First, the rate of convergence of the training dynamics is uneven and depends on the distribution of energy in the data. As a special case, the dynamics in directions where the data have no energy cannot be learned. Second, in the unlearnable directions, the dynamics produced by the neural network depend on the weight initialization, and common weight initialization schemes can produce unstable dynamics. Third, injecting synthetic noise into the data during training adds damping to the training dynamics and can stabilize the learned simulator, though doing so undesirably biases the learned dynamics. For each contributor to instability, we suggest mitigative strategies. We also highlight important differences between learning discrete-time and continuous-time dynamics, and discuss extensions to nonlinear systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the potential for instabilities in neural network-based physics simulators, which are becoming increasingly popular for modeling complex physical systems.
- The authors investigate the discrete-time dynamics of such neural networks and identify conditions under which the network trajectories can exhibit chaotic behavior, leading to unpredictable and unstable outputs.
- The findings have important implications for the use of neural networks in critical applications where reliability and stability are paramount, such as simulating complex network dynamics, modeling dissipative dynamics, and understanding the persistence of neural network dynamics.
Plain English Explanation
Neural networks have become a popular tool for simulating complex physical systems, as they can learn to model the underlying dynamics from data. However, this paper shows that these neural network-based simulators can be prone to instabilities, where small changes in the inputs can lead to vastly different, unpredictable outputs over time.
Imagine a neural network that is trying to simulate the motion of a pendulum. If the initial conditions of the pendulum (e.g., its starting position and velocity) are slightly different, the neural network may predict completely different trajectories for the pendulum's motion, even though the underlying physics is the same. This is because the neural network's internal dynamics can become chaotic, meaning that its outputs are highly sensitive to tiny changes in the inputs.
This instability problem is particularly concerning in applications where the neural network-based simulator is being used to make important decisions, such as in simulating the behavior of complex networks or modeling the dynamics of physical systems. If the simulator's outputs are unreliable or unpredictable, it could lead to poor decisions or even catastrophic failures.
The authors of this paper analyze the mathematical properties of these neural network-based simulators to identify the conditions under which they are likely to become unstable. By understanding these instabilities, researchers and engineers can work to develop more robust and reliable neural network architectures and training approaches, ensuring that these powerful tools can be used safely and effectively in a wide range of applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the discrete-time dynamics of neural network-based physics simulators, which can be represented as dynamical systems. The authors investigate the stability and chaos properties of these dynamical systems, drawing insights from the field of weight dynamics in neural networks.
Specifically, the paper analyzes the Jacobian matrix of the neural network's update function, which describes how small changes in the inputs propagate through the network. The authors show that if the eigenvalues of this Jacobian matrix have magnitudes greater than 1, the network's trajectories can become chaotic, leading to unpredictable and unstable outputs.
The paper presents a detailed mathematical analysis of this phenomenon, including conditions on the network architecture, activation functions, and training procedures that can contribute to the emergence of chaotic behavior. The authors also discuss potential mitigation strategies, such as using dissipative neural network architectures or incorporating regularization techniques to improve the stability and reliability of the neural network-based simulators.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous and well-grounded analysis of the instability issues that can arise in neural network-based physics simulators. The authors' use of dynamical systems theory and their focus on the Jacobian matrix of the network's update function offers a solid theoretical foundation for understanding the potential for chaotic behavior in these systems.
One limitation of the work is that it primarily focuses on the discrete-time dynamics of the neural networks, whereas many real-world physical systems are governed by continuous-time dynamics. While the authors do discuss the implications for continuous-time systems, further analysis of the transition from discrete to continuous time could provide additional insights.
Additionally, the paper does not provide extensive empirical validation of the theoretical results, relying more on the mathematical analysis. Experimental studies that demonstrate the practical manifestations of these instabilities, as well as the effectiveness of the proposed mitigation strategies, would further strengthen the impact of the research.
Nevertheless, the paper's findings have important implications for the responsible development and deployment of neural network-based simulators, particularly in safety-critical applications. By bringing attention to these instability issues, the authors highlight the need for careful consideration of the dynamical properties of neural networks and the development of more robust and reliable neural network architectures and training methods.
Conclusion
This paper provides a detailed analysis of the potential for instabilities in neural network-based physics simulators, a topic of growing importance as these powerful tools become more widely adopted. The authors' exploration of the discrete-time dynamics of such systems and their identification of the conditions under which chaotic behavior can emerge offer valuable insights for researchers and engineers working in this field.
The findings have significant implications for the reliable and trustworthy use of neural networks in a variety of applications, from simulating complex network dynamics to modeling dissipative physical systems and understanding the persistence of neural network dynamics. By addressing these instability issues, the research community can work towards developing more robust and dependable neural network-based simulators that can be safely deployed in critical real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Dynamical stability and chaos in artificial neural network trajectories along training
Kaloyan Danovski, Miguel C. Soriano, Lucas Lacasa
0
0
The process of training an artificial neural network involves iteratively adapting its parameters so as to minimize the error of the network's prediction, when confronted with a learning task. This iterative change can be naturally interpreted as a trajectory in network space -- a time series of networks -- and thus the training algorithm (e.g. gradient descent optimization of a suitable loss function) can be interpreted as a dynamical system in graph space. In order to illustrate this interpretation, here we study the dynamical properties of this process by analyzing through this lens the network trajectories of a shallow neural network, and its evolution through learning a simple classification task. We systematically consider different ranges of the learning rate and explore both the dynamical and orbital stability of the resulting network trajectories, finding hints of regular and chaotic behavior depending on the learning rate regime. Our findings are put in contrast to common wisdom on convergence properties of neural networks and dynamical systems theory. This work also contributes to the cross-fertilization of ideas between dynamical systems theory, network theory and machine learning
4/10/2024
On the weight dynamics of learning networks
Nahal Sharafi, Christoph Martin, Sarah Hallerberg
0
0
Neural networks have become a widely adopted tool for tackling a variety of problems in machine learning and artificial intelligence. In this contribution we use the mathematical framework of local stability analysis to gain a deeper understanding of the learning dynamics of feed forward neural networks. Therefore, we derive equations for the tangent operator of the learning dynamics of three-layer networks learning regression tasks. The results are valid for an arbitrary numbers of nodes and arbitrary choices of activation functions. Applying the results to a network learning a regression task, we investigate numerically, how stability indicators relate to the final training-loss. Although the specific results vary with different choices of initial conditions and activation functions, we demonstrate that it is possible to predict the final training loss, by monitoring finite-time Lyapunov exponents or covariant Lyapunov vectors during the training process.
5/3/2024
π§
Stretched and measured neural predictions of complex network dynamics
Vaiva Vasiliauskaite, Nino Antulov-Fantulin
0
0
Differential equations are a ubiquitous tool to study dynamics, ranging from physical systems to complex systems, where a large number of agents interact through a graph with non-trivial topological features. Data-driven approximations of differential equations present a promising alternative to traditional methods for uncovering a model of dynamical systems, especially in complex systems that lack explicit first principles. A recently employed machine learning tool for studying dynamics is neural networks, which can be used for data-driven solution finding or discovery of differential equations. Specifically for the latter task, however, deploying deep learning models in unfamiliar settings - such as predicting dynamics in unobserved state space regions or on novel graphs - can lead to spurious results. Focusing on complex systems whose dynamics are described with a system of first-order differential equations coupled through a graph, we show that extending the model's generalizability beyond traditional statistical learning theory limits is feasible. However, achieving this advanced level of generalization requires neural network models to conform to fundamental assumptions about the dynamical model. Additionally, we propose a statistical significance test to assess prediction quality during inference, enabling the identification of a neural network's confidence level in its predictions.
4/26/2024
π§
Learning Dissipative Neural Dynamical Systems
Yuezhu Xu, S. Sivaranjani
0
0
Consider an unknown nonlinear dynamical system that is known to be dissipative. The objective of this paper is to learn a neural dynamical model that approximates this system, while preserving the dissipativity property in the model. In general, imposing dissipativity constraints during neural network training is a hard problem for which no known techniques exist. In this work, we address the problem of learning a dissipative neural dynamical system model in two stages. First, we learn an unconstrained neural dynamical model that closely approximates the system dynamics. Next, we derive sufficient conditions to perturb the weights of the neural dynamical model to ensure dissipativity, followed by perturbation of the biases to retain the fit of the model to the trajectories of the nonlinear system. We show that these two perturbation problems can be solved independently to obtain a neural dynamical model that is guaranteed to be dissipative while closely approximating the nonlinear system.
4/9/2024