Intelligent tutoring systems by Bayesian networks with noisy gates

Read original: arXiv:2409.04102 - Published 9/10/2024 by Alessandro Antonucci, Francesca Mangili, Claudio Bonesana, Giorgia Adorni

🐍

Overview

This paper presents an approach to building intelligent tutoring systems using Bayesian networks with noisy gates.
The key ideas are using Bayesian networks to model student knowledge and performance, and incorporating noisy gates to handle the uncertainty and randomness in student learning.
The research aims to develop more effective and personalized tutoring systems by leveraging Bayesian modeling techniques.

Plain English Explanation

Intelligent tutoring systems are computer programs designed to provide personalized learning experiences for students. This paper describes a new approach to building these systems using Bayesian networks - statistical models that can represent relationships between different factors.

The researchers propose using Bayesian networks to model a student's knowledge and performance. This allows the tutoring system to keep track of what the student understands and where they are struggling. Importantly, the networks incorporate "noisy gates" - a way of handling the uncertainty and randomness that is inherent in how students learn.

By using this Bayesian network approach, the tutoring system can make more accurate assessments of the student's state of knowledge. This enables the system to provide more personalized and effective instruction, tailored to the individual student's needs. The goal is to develop tutoring systems that can adapt and respond to each student in a way that traditional one-size-fits-all approaches cannot.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces an intelligent tutoring system that models student knowledge and performance using Bayesian networks. Bayesian networks are probabilistic graphical models that can capture the relationships between different variables.

In this case, the Bayesian network represents the concepts that a student is learning, their proficiency in those concepts, and how their actions and responses feed back into their understanding. Crucially, the network includes "noisy gates" - stochastic components that introduce randomness to account for the unpredictability of human learning.

The authors demonstrate how this Bayesian network approach can be used to model assessment rubrics and provide personalized feedback to students. They also show how the network structure can be learned automatically from data, making the system more scalable and adaptable.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to developing intelligent tutoring systems, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

Handling complex domains: The examples in the paper focus on relatively simple conceptual domains. It's unclear how well the Bayesian network approach would scale to more complex, interdependent subject areas.
Incorporating other data sources: The current system relies primarily on student responses and actions. Integrating additional data sources, such as eye-tracking or biosensor information, could potentially further improve the accuracy of the student models.
Balancing personalization and generalization: While the personalized approach is a key strength, there may be a trade-off between tailoring the system to individual students and developing more broadly applicable models that can benefit a wider range of learners.

Overall, the paper presents a promising direction for intelligent tutoring systems, leveraging the power of Bayesian networks to create more adaptive and responsive learning experiences. Further research and real-world deployment could help address the identified limitations and unlock the full potential of this approach.

Conclusion

This paper introduces an innovative approach to building intelligent tutoring systems using Bayesian networks with noisy gates. By modeling student knowledge and performance probabilistically, the system can provide personalized feedback and instruction tailored to each individual learner's needs.

The key contributions of this research are:

Demonstrating the potential of Bayesian networks to capture the complexities and uncertainties inherent in human learning.
Incorporating noisy gates to handle the randomness and unpredictability of student behavior.
Showing how this Bayesian network approach can be used to model assessment rubrics and automatically learn the network structure from data.

While there are some potential limitations that require further exploration, this work represents an important step forward in the development of more effective and adaptive intelligent tutoring systems. By leveraging the power of Bayesian modeling techniques, these systems can become valuable tools for personalizing and optimizing the learning experience for students.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🐍

Intelligent tutoring systems by Bayesian networks with noisy gates

Alessandro Antonucci, Francesca Mangili, Claudio Bonesana, Giorgia Adorni

Directed graphical models such as Bayesian nets are often used to implement intelligent tutoring systems able to interact in real-time with learners in a purely automatic way. When coping with such models, keeping a bound on the number of parameters might be important for multiple reasons. First, as these models are typically based on expert knowledge, a huge number of parameters to elicit might discourage practitioners from adopting them. Moreover, the number of model parameters affects the complexity of the inferences, while a fast computation of the queries is needed for real-time feedback. We advocate logical gates with uncertainty for a compact parametrization of the conditional probability tables in the underlying Bayesian net used by tutoring systems. We discuss the semantics of the model parameters to elicit and the assumptions required to apply such approach in this domain. We also derive a dedicated inference scheme to speed up computations.

9/10/2024

➖

Rubric-based Learner Modelling via Noisy Gates Bayesian Networks for Computational Thinking Skills Assessment

Giorgia Adorni, Francesca Mangili, Alberto Piatti, Claudio Bonesana, Alessandro Antonucci

In modern and personalised education, there is a growing interest in developing learners' competencies and accurately assessing them. In a previous work, we proposed a procedure for deriving a learner model for automatic skill assessment from a task-specific competence rubric, thus simplifying the implementation of automated assessment tools. The previous approach, however, suffered two main limitations: (i) the ordering between competencies defined by the assessment rubric was only indirectly modelled; (ii) supplementary skills, not under assessment but necessary for accomplishing the task, were not included in the model. In this work, we address issue (i) by introducing dummy observed nodes, strictly enforcing the skills ordering without changing the network's structure. In contrast, for point (ii), we design a network with two layers of gates, one performing disjunctive operations by noisy-OR gates and the other conjunctive operations through logical ANDs. Such changes improve the model outcomes' coherence and the modelling tool's flexibility without compromising the model's compact parametrisation, interpretability and simple experts' elicitation. We used this approach to develop a learner model for Computational Thinking (CT) skills assessment. The CT-cube skills assessment framework and the Cross Array Task (CAT) are used to exemplify it and demonstrate its feasibility.

8/6/2024

Graph Structure Learning with Interpretable Bayesian Neural Networks

Max Wasserman, Gonzalo Mateos

Graphs serve as generic tools to encode the underlying relational structure of data. Often this graph is not given, and so the task of inferring it from nodal observations becomes important. Traditional approaches formulate a convex inverse problem with a smoothness promoting objective and rely on iterative methods to obtain a solution. In supervised settings where graph labels are available, one can unroll and truncate these iterations into a deep network that is trained end-to-end. Such a network is parameter efficient and inherits inductive bias from the optimization formulation, an appealing aspect for data constrained settings in, e.g., medicine, finance, and the natural sciences. But typically such settings care equally about uncertainty over edge predictions, not just point estimates. Here we introduce novel iterations with independently interpretable parameters, i.e., parameters whose values - independent of other parameters' settings - proportionally influence characteristics of the estimated graph, such as edge sparsity. After unrolling these iterations, prior knowledge over such graph characteristics shape prior distributions over these independently interpretable network parameters to yield a Bayesian neural network (BNN) capable of graph structure learning (GSL) from smooth signal observations. Fast execution and parameter efficiency allow for high-fidelity posterior approximation via Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and thus uncertainty quantification on edge predictions. Synthetic and real data experiments corroborate this model's ability to provide well-calibrated estimates of uncertainty, in test cases that include unveiling economic sector modular structure from S$&$P$500$ data and recovering pairwise digit similarities from MNIST images. Overall, this framework enables GSL in modest-scale applications where uncertainty on the data structure is paramount.

6/24/2024

🔎

Modelling Assessment Rubrics through Bayesian Networks: a Pragmatic Approach

Francesca Mangili, Giorgia Adorni, Alberto Piatti, Claudio Bonesana, Alessandro Antonucci

Automatic assessment of learner competencies is a fundamental task in intelligent tutoring systems. An assessment rubric typically and effectively describes relevant competencies and competence levels. This paper presents an approach to deriving a learner model directly from an assessment rubric defining some (partial) ordering of competence levels. The model is based on Bayesian networks and exploits logical gates with uncertainty (often referred to as noisy gates) to reduce the number of parameters of the model, so to simplify their elicitation by experts and allow real-time inference in intelligent tutoring systems. We illustrate how the approach can be applied to automatize the human assessment of an activity developed for testing computational thinking skills. The simple elicitation of the model starting from the assessment rubric opens up the possibility of quickly automating the assessment of several tasks, making them more easily exploitable in the context of adaptive assessment tools and intelligent tutoring systems.

8/6/2024