Interpretable Deep Clustering for Tabular Data

2306.04785

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/11/2024 by Jonathan Svirsky, Ofir Lindenbaum

🤿

Abstract

Clustering is a fundamental learning task widely used as a first step in data analysis. For example, biologists use cluster assignments to analyze genome sequences, medical records, or images. Since downstream analysis is typically performed at the cluster level, practitioners seek reliable and interpretable clustering models. We propose a new deep-learning framework for general domain tabular data that predicts interpretable cluster assignments at the instance and cluster levels. First, we present a self-supervised procedure to identify the subset of the most informative features from each data point. Then, we design a model that predicts cluster assignments and a gate matrix that provides cluster-level feature selection. Overall, our model provides cluster assignments with an indication of the driving feature for each sample and each cluster. We show that the proposed method can reliably predict cluster assignments in biological, text, image, and physics tabular datasets. Furthermore, using previously proposed metrics, we verify that our model leads to interpretable results at a sample and cluster level. Our code is available at https://github.com/jsvir/idc.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Presents a new deep learning framework for general domain tabular data that predicts interpretable cluster assignments at the instance and cluster levels
  • Includes a self-supervised procedure to identify the most informative features from each data point
  • Designs a model that predicts cluster assignments and a gate matrix for cluster-level feature selection
  • Provides cluster assignments with an indication of the driving feature for each sample and each cluster
  • Demonstrates reliable cluster assignment predictions across biological, text, image, and physics tabular datasets

Plain English Explanation

Clustering is a commonly used data analysis technique, where similar data points are grouped together. This can be particularly useful in fields like biology, where researchers may want to analyze genome sequences, medical records, or images by first grouping similar data points together.

The proposed framework aims to make clustering more interpretable, meaning that users can understand not just which data points are grouped together, but also what features of the data are driving those groupings. It does this in a few key ways:

  1. First, it identifies the most informative features from each data point using a self-supervised procedure. This helps the model focus on the most relevant parts of the data.

  2. Next, the model predicts both the cluster assignments and a "gate matrix" that indicates which features are most important for each cluster. This provides insight into why the data points were grouped together the way they were.

  3. The end result is a clustering model that not only groups the data, but also explains what aspects of the data are responsible for those groupings. This can be valuable for researchers who need to understand the underlying drivers behind the patterns in their data.

The authors demonstrate that this interpretable clustering approach works well across a variety of different types of tabular data, including biological, text, image, and physics datasets. By making the clustering process more transparent, the framework can help users gain deeper insights from their data.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new deep learning framework for general domain tabular data that predicts interpretable cluster assignments at both the instance and cluster levels.

First, the authors present a self-supervised procedure to identify the most informative features from each data point. This helps the model focus on the relevant parts of the data, rather than getting distracted by irrelevant or redundant features.

Next, the framework includes a model that predicts both the cluster assignments and a "gate matrix" that provides cluster-level feature selection. This gate matrix indicates which features are most important for each cluster, giving users insight into why the data was grouped in a particular way.

The authors evaluate their approach on a range of tabular datasets, including biological, text, image, and physics data. They find that the proposed method can reliably predict cluster assignments and provide interpretable results at both the sample and cluster level.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to making clustering more interpretable, which could be valuable for researchers in a variety of domains. By providing information about the driving features behind each cluster, the framework gives users a better understanding of the underlying patterns in their data.

That said, the authors do acknowledge some limitations of their work. For example, they note that the self-supervised feature selection procedure may not always identify the most relevant features, particularly in cases where there are complex, nonlinear relationships in the data. Additionally, the interpretability of the gate matrix may be challenging to fully assess, as the importance of different features can depend on the specific context and use case.

Further research could explore ways to make the feature selection process more robust, as well as investigate alternative methods for interpreting the cluster-level insights. Additionally, it would be interesting to see how this framework compares to other interpretable clustering approaches, both in terms of performance and the nature of the insights provided.

Conclusion

Overall, the proposed deep learning framework represents an interesting step towards more interpretable clustering models for tabular data. By providing information about the driving features behind each cluster, the approach can help users gain deeper insights from their data, which could be particularly valuable in applications like biology, medicine, and physics. While the method has some limitations, the authors have demonstrated its effectiveness across a range of datasets, and the ideas presented could inspire further innovations in this important area of research.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

📊

InterpreTabNet: Distilling Predictive Signals from Tabular Data by Salient Feature Interpretation

Jacob Si, Wendy Yusi Cheng, Michael Cooper, Rahul G. Krishnan

YC

0

Reddit

0

Tabular data are omnipresent in various sectors of industries. Neural networks for tabular data such as TabNet have been proposed to make predictions while leveraging the attention mechanism for interpretability. However, the inferred attention masks are often dense, making it challenging to come up with rationales about the predictive signal. To remedy this, we propose InterpreTabNet, a variant of the TabNet model that models the attention mechanism as a latent variable sampled from a Gumbel-Softmax distribution. This enables us to regularize the model to learn distinct concepts in the attention masks via a KL Divergence regularizer. It prevents overlapping feature selection by promoting sparsity which maximizes the model's efficacy and improves interpretability to determine the important features when predicting the outcome. To assist in the interpretation of feature interdependencies from our model, we employ a large language model (GPT-4) and use prompt engineering to map from the learned feature mask onto natural language text describing the learned signal. Through comprehensive experiments on real-world datasets, we demonstrate that InterpreTabNet outperforms previous methods for interpreting tabular data while attaining competitive accuracy.

Read more

6/12/2024

🔮

Topological Interpretability for Deep-Learning

Adam Spannaus, Heidi A. Hanson, Lynne Penberthy, Georgia Tourassi

YC

0

Reddit

0

With the growing adoption of AI-based systems across everyday life, the need to understand their decision-making mechanisms is correspondingly increasing. The level at which we can trust the statistical inferences made from AI-based decision systems is an increasing concern, especially in high-risk systems such as criminal justice or medical diagnosis, where incorrect inferences may have tragic consequences. Despite their successes in providing solutions to problems involving real-world data, deep learning (DL) models cannot quantify the certainty of their predictions. These models are frequently quite confident, even when their solutions are incorrect. This work presents a method to infer prominent features in two DL classification models trained on clinical and non-clinical text by employing techniques from topological and geometric data analysis. We create a graph of a model's feature space and cluster the inputs into the graph's vertices by the similarity of features and prediction statistics. We then extract subgraphs demonstrating high-predictive accuracy for a given label. These subgraphs contain a wealth of information about features that the DL model has recognized as relevant to its decisions. We infer these features for a given label using a distance metric between probability measures, and demonstrate the stability of our method compared to the LIME and SHAP interpretability methods. This work establishes that we may gain insights into the decision mechanism of a DL model. This method allows us to ascertain if the model is making its decisions based on information germane to the problem or identifies extraneous patterns within the data.

Read more

4/15/2024

👨‍🏫

ClusterTabNet: Supervised clustering method for table detection and table structure recognition

Marek Polewczyk, Marco Spinaci

YC

0

Reddit

0

We present a novel deep-learning-based method to cluster words in documents which we apply to detect and recognize tables given the OCR output. We interpret table structure bottom-up as a graph of relations between pairs of words (belonging to the same row, column, header, as well as to the same table) and use a transformer encoder model to predict its adjacency matrix. We demonstrate the performance of our method on the PubTables-1M dataset as well as PubTabNet and FinTabNet datasets. Compared to the current state-of-the-art detection methods such as DETR and Faster R-CNN, our method achieves similar or better accuracy, while requiring a significantly smaller model.

Read more

5/24/2024

Interpretable Multi-View Clustering

Interpretable Multi-View Clustering

Mudi Jiang, Lianyu Hu, Zengyou He, Zhikui Chen

YC

0

Reddit

0

Multi-view clustering has become a significant area of research, with numerous methods proposed over the past decades to enhance clustering accuracy. However, in many real-world applications, it is crucial to demonstrate a clear decision-making process-specifically, explaining why samples are assigned to particular clusters. Consequently, there remains a notable gap in developing interpretable methods for clustering multi-view data. To fill this crucial gap, we make the first attempt towards this direction by introducing an interpretable multi-view clustering framework. Our method begins by extracting embedded features from each view and generates pseudo-labels to guide the initial construction of the decision tree. Subsequently, it iteratively optimizes the feature representation for each view along with refining the interpretable decision tree. Experimental results on real datasets demonstrate that our method not only provides a transparent clustering process for multi-view data but also delivers performance comparable to state-of-the-art multi-view clustering methods. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first effort to design an interpretable clustering framework specifically for multi-view data, opening a new avenue in this field.

Read more

5/7/2024