IPC: Incremental Probabilistic Consensus-based Consistent Set Maximization for SLAM Backends
2405.08503
0
0
🎯
Abstract
In SLAM (Simultaneous localization and mapping) problems, Pose Graph Optimization (PGO) is a technique to refine an initial estimate of a set of poses (positions and orientations) from a set of pairwise relative measurements. The optimization procedure can be negatively affected even by a single outlier measurement, with possible catastrophic and meaningless results. Although recent works on robust optimization aim to mitigate the presence of outlier measurements, robust solutions capable of handling large numbers of outliers are yet to come. This paper presents IPC, acronym for Incremental Probabilistic Consensus, a method that approximates the solution to the combinatorial problem of finding the maximally consistent set of measurements in an incremental fashion. It evaluates the consistency of each loop closure measurement through a consensus-based procedure, possibly applied to a subset of the global problem, where all previously integrated inlier measurements have veto power. We evaluated IPC on standard benchmarks against several state-of-the-art methods. Although it is simple and relatively easy to implement, IPC competes with or outperforms the other tested methods in handling outliers while providing online performances. We release with this paper an open-source implementation of the proposed method.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- SLAM (Simultaneous Localization and Mapping) is a technique used to estimate the position and orientation of a robot or device within an environment while simultaneously building a map of that environment.
- Pose Graph Optimization (PGO) is a method used in SLAM to refine initial estimates of a set of poses (positions and orientations) based on pairwise relative measurements.
- PGO can be negatively affected by even a single outlier measurement, leading to catastrophic and meaningless results.
- This paper presents a method called IPC (Incremental Probabilistic Consensus) that aims to handle large numbers of outliers in PGO.
Plain English Explanation
Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) is a technique used by robots and other devices to figure out where they are and create a map of their surroundings at the same time. One key part of SLAM is Pose Graph Optimization (PGO), which takes an initial guess of the device's positions and orientations and refines them based on measurements of how the device is moving relative to its environment.
The problem is that even a single bad measurement, called an outlier, can really mess up the PGO process and give you completely meaningless results. Recent research has tried to make PGO more robust to outliers, but a solution that can handle a lot of outliers is still needed.
This paper introduces a new method called Incremental Probabilistic Consensus (IPC) that tries to solve this problem. IPC looks at each measurement and checks how consistent it is with all the other measurements that have already been included. This lets it identify and remove outliers in an incremental way, improving the overall optimization process.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the IPC (Incremental Probabilistic Consensus) method, which aims to address the issue of outlier measurements in Pose Graph Optimization (PGO) for SLAM problems.
IPC works by evaluating the consistency of each loop closure measurement through a consensus-based procedure. This is done in an incremental fashion, where all previously integrated inlier measurements have "veto power" over new measurements being considered. This helps the method handle large numbers of outliers, which can otherwise catastrophically affect the PGO optimization.
The authors evaluate IPC on standard SLAM benchmarks and compare it to several state-of-the-art robust optimization methods, such as MAC (Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity), MAD-ICP (Matching And Decoupling ICP), and Probabilistic Drift Correction. They show that IPC can compete with or outperform these methods in handling outliers while providing online performance.
Additionally, the authors release an open-source implementation of the IPC method alongside the paper.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to handling outliers in PGO for SLAM problems. The IPC (Incremental Probabilistic Consensus) method seems to be a relatively simple and easy-to-implement solution that can effectively deal with large numbers of outliers.
However, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the limitations or potential issues with the IPC method. For example, it would be valuable to understand how IPC performs in scenarios with very high percentages of outliers, or how it scales with the size and complexity of the SLAM problem.
Additionally, the paper could have benefited from a more thorough comparison to other state-of-the-art robust optimization techniques, such as RMS (Redundancy Minimizing Sampling) for point cloud registration. This would help readers better understand the unique strengths and weaknesses of the IPC approach.
Overall, the IPC method seems promising, but further research and analysis would be helpful to fully evaluate its capabilities and limitations in real-world SLAM applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new method called Incremental Probabilistic Consensus (IPC) that aims to improve Pose Graph Optimization (PGO) for Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) by handling large numbers of outlier measurements. IPC evaluates the consistency of each loop closure measurement through a consensus-based procedure, allowing it to identify and remove outliers in an incremental way.
The authors show that IPC can compete with or outperform several state-of-the-art robust optimization methods on standard SLAM benchmarks, while providing online performance. This suggests that IPC could be a valuable tool for building more robust and reliable SLAM systems, especially in environments with a high degree of sensor noise or measurement errors.
Overall, the IPC method represents an interesting and practical contribution to the field of SLAM, and the open-source implementation provided by the authors will likely be valuable for researchers and practitioners working in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Non-convex Pose Graph Optimization in SLAM via Proximal Linearized Riemannian ADMM
Xin Chen, Chunfeng Cui, Deren Han, Liqun Qi
0
0
Pose graph optimization (PGO) is a well-known technique for solving the pose-based simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM) problem. In this paper, we represent the rotation and translation by a unit quaternion and a three-dimensional vector, and propose a new PGO model based on the von Mises-Fisher distribution. The constraints derived from the unit quaternions are spherical manifolds, and the projection onto the constraints can be calculated by normalization. Then a proximal linearized Riemannian alternating direction method of multipliers (PieADMM) is developed to solve the proposed model, which not only has low memory requirements, but also can update the poses in parallel. Furthermore, we establish the iteration complexity of $O(1/epsilon^{2})$ of PieADMM for finding an $epsilon$-stationary solution of our model. The efficiency of our proposed algorithm is demonstrated by numerical experiments on two synthetic and four 3D SLAM benchmark datasets.
4/30/2024
🔍
VICAN: Very Efficient Calibration Algorithm for Large Camera Networks
Gabriel Moreira, Manuel Marques, Jo~ao Paulo Costeira, Alexander Hauptmann
0
0
The precise estimation of camera poses within large camera networks is a foundational problem in computer vision and robotics, with broad applications spanning autonomous navigation, surveillance, and augmented reality. In this paper, we introduce a novel methodology that extends state-of-the-art Pose Graph Optimization (PGO) techniques. Departing from the conventional PGO paradigm, which primarily relies on camera-camera edges, our approach centers on the introduction of a dynamic element - any rigid object free to move in the scene - whose pose can be reliably inferred from a single image. Specifically, we consider the bipartite graph encompassing cameras, object poses evolving dynamically, and camera-object relative transformations at each time step. This shift not only offers a solution to the challenges encountered in directly estimating relative poses between cameras, particularly in adverse environments, but also leverages the inclusion of numerous object poses to ameliorate and integrate errors, resulting in accurate camera pose estimates. Though our framework retains compatibility with traditional PGO solvers, its efficacy benefits from a custom-tailored optimization scheme. To this end, we introduce an iterative primal-dual algorithm, capable of handling large graphs. Empirical benchmarks, conducted on a new dataset of simulated indoor environments, substantiate the efficacy and efficiency of our approach.
5/21/2024
New!Collaborative Graph Exploration with Reduced Pose-SLAM Uncertainty via Submodular Optimization
Ruofei Bai, Shenghai Yuan, Hongliang Guo, Pengyu Yin, Wei-Yun Yau, Lihua Xie
0
0
This paper considers the collaborative graph exploration problem in GPS-denied environments, where a group of robots are required to cover a graph environment while maintaining reliable pose estimations in collaborative simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM). Considering both objectives presents challenges for multi-robot pathfinding, as it involves the expensive covariance inference for SLAM uncertainty evaluation, especially considering various combinations of robots' paths. To reduce the computational complexity, we propose an efficient two-stage strategy where exploration paths are first generated for quick coverage, and then enhanced by adding informative and distance-efficient loop-closing actions, called loop edges, along the paths for reliable pose estimation. We formulate the latter problem as a non-monotone submodular maximization problem by relating SLAM uncertainty with pose graph topology, which (1) facilitates more efficient evaluation of SLAM uncertainty than covariance inference, and (2) allows the application of approximation algorithms in submodular optimization to provide optimality guarantees. We further introduce the ordering heuristics to improve objective values while preserving the optimality bound. Simulation experiments over randomly generated graph environments verify the efficiency of our methods in finding paths for quick coverage and enhanced pose graph reliability, and benchmark the performance of the approximation algorithms and the greedy-based algorithm in the loop edge selection problem. Our implementations will be open-source at https://github.com/bairuofei/CGE.
7/2/2024
The Penalized Inverse Probability Measure for Conformal Classification
Paul Melki (IMS), Lionel Bombrun (IMS), Boubacar Diallo (IMS), J'er^ome Dias (IMS), Jean-Pierre da Costa (IMS)
0
0
The deployment of safe and trustworthy machine learning systems, and particularly complex black box neural networks, in real-world applications requires reliable and certified guarantees on their performance. The conformal prediction framework offers such formal guarantees by transforming any point into a set predictor with valid, finite-set, guarantees on the coverage of the true at a chosen level of confidence. Central to this methodology is the notion of the nonconformity score function that assigns to each example a measure of ''strangeness'' in comparison with the previously seen observations. While the coverage guarantees are maintained regardless of the nonconformity measure, the point predictor and the dataset, previous research has shown that the performance of a conformal model, as measured by its efficiency (the average size of the predicted sets) and its informativeness (the proportion of prediction sets that are singletons), is influenced by the choice of the nonconformity score function. The current work introduces the Penalized Inverse Probability (PIP) nonconformity score, and its regularized version RePIP, that allow the joint optimization of both efficiency and informativeness. Through toy examples and empirical results on the task of crop and weed image classification in agricultural robotics, the current work shows how PIP-based conformal classifiers exhibit precisely the desired behavior in comparison with other nonconformity measures and strike a good balance between informativeness and efficiency.
6/14/2024