ITEM: Improving Training and Evaluation of Message-Passing based GNNs for top-k recommendation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper focuses on improving the training and evaluation of message-passing-based graph neural networks (GNNs) for top-k recommendation tasks.
• The authors identify several challenges with the current approaches to training and evaluating GNNs for recommendation, and propose solutions to address these issues.
Plain English Explanation
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are a type of machine learning model that can work with data represented as a graph, where entities are nodes and the relationships between them are edges. These models have shown promise for recommendation systems, where the goal is to suggest the top-k items a user might be most interested in.
However, the authors of this paper argue that the current approaches to training and evaluating GNNs for top-k recommendation have some problems. For example, the way these models are trained may not align well with the actual top-k recommendation task, and the evaluation metrics used may not capture the most important aspects of recommendation performance.
To address these issues, the authors propose several improvements, including: • Modifying the training objective to better match the top-k recommendation goal • Using more appropriate evaluation metrics that focus on the quality of the top recommendations • Incorporating additional information, such as user preferences and item attributes, to enhance the model's performance
By implementing these changes, the authors believe they can significantly improve the effectiveness of message-passing-based GNNs for top-k recommendation tasks.
Technical Explanation
The key elements of this paper include:
-
Identifying issues with the current approaches to training and evaluating GNNs for top-k recommendation: • Training objectives that do not align well with the top-k recommendation task • Evaluation metrics that may not capture the most important aspects of recommendation performance
-
Proposing solutions to address these issues: • Modifying the training objective to better match the top-k recommendation goal, such as by incorporating a ranking-based loss function • Using more appropriate evaluation metrics that focus on the quality of the top recommendations, such as [internal link: Normalized Discounted Cumulative Gain (NDCG)]
-
Incorporating additional information to enhance the model's performance: • Using user preferences and item attributes as input features • Leveraging [internal link: knowledge graphs] to capture richer relationships between items
-
Conducting extensive experiments to validate the effectiveness of the proposed approach, using [internal link: multiple benchmark datasets] and comparing against state-of-the-art GNN-based recommendation methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper identifies valid concerns with the current practices for training and evaluating GNNs for top-k recommendation, and the proposed solutions seem promising. However, the authors do not discuss potential limitations or caveats of their approach.
For example, the incorporation of additional user and item features may not always be feasible, as the availability and quality of such data can vary across different domains. Additionally, the reliance on knowledge graphs may be challenging in scenarios where such structured data is not readily available.
Further research could explore the robustness of the proposed methods to different data conditions and investigate ways to make the approach more generally applicable, potentially by reducing the dependence on external data sources.
Conclusion
This paper presents a thoughtful approach to improving the training and evaluation of message-passing-based GNNs for top-k recommendation tasks. By addressing key issues with current practices and incorporating additional relevant information, the authors demonstrate the potential for enhancing the performance and usefulness of GNN-based recommendation systems.
The proposed solutions have the capacity to drive advancements in the field of [internal link: graph neural networks for social recommender systems] and could lead to more accurate and personalized recommendations for users. Continued research in this direction, with a focus on addressing potential limitations, could further strengthen the applicability of these techniques in real-world recommendation scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
ITEM: Improving Training and Evaluation of Message-Passing based GNNs for top-k recommendation
Yannis Karmim, Elias Ramzi, Raphael Fournier-S'niehotta, Nicolas Thome
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), especially message-passing-based models, have become prominent in top-k recommendation tasks, outperforming matrix factorization models due to their ability to efficiently aggregate information from a broader context. Although GNNs are evaluated with ranking-based metrics, e.g NDCG@k and Recall@k, they remain largely trained with proxy losses, e.g the BPR loss. In this work we explore the use of ranking loss functions to directly optimize the evaluation metrics, an area not extensively investigated in the GNN community for collaborative filtering. We take advantage of smooth approximations of the rank to facilitate end-to-end training of GNNs and propose a Personalized PageRank-based negative sampling strategy tailored for ranking loss functions. Moreover, we extend the evaluation of GNN models for top-k recommendation tasks with an inductive user-centric protocol, providing a more accurate reflection of real-world applications. Our proposed method significantly outperforms the standard BPR loss and more advanced losses across four datasets and four recent GNN architectures while also exhibiting faster training. Demonstrating the potential of ranking loss functions in improving GNN training for collaborative filtering tasks.
Read more7/12/2024
0
Performance Comparison of Session-based Recommendation Algorithms based on GNNs
Faisal Shehzad, Dietmar Jannach
In session-based recommendation settings, a recommender system has no access to long-term user profiles and thus has to base its suggestions on the user interactions that are observed in an ongoing session. Since such sessions can consist of only a small set of interactions, various approaches based on Graph Neural Networks (GNN) were recently proposed, as they allow us to integrate various types of side information about the items in a natural way. Unfortunately, a variety of evaluation settings are used in the literature, e.g., in terms of protocols, metrics and baselines, making it difficult to assess what represents the state of the art. In this work, we present the results of an evaluation of eight recent GNN-based approaches that were published in high-quality outlets. For a fair comparison, all models are systematically tuned and tested under identical conditions using three common datasets. We furthermore include k-nearest-neighbor and sequential rules-based models as baselines, as such models have previously exhibited competitive performance results for similar settings. To our surprise, the evaluation showed that the simple models outperform all recent GNN models in terms of the Mean Reciprocal Rank, which we used as an optimization criterion, and were only outperformed in three cases in terms of the Hit Rate. Additional analyses furthermore reveal that several other factors that are often not deeply discussed in papers, e.g., random seeds, can markedly impact the performance of GNN-based models. Our results therefore (a) point to continuing issues in the community in terms of research methodology and (b) indicate that there is ample room for improvement in session-based recommendation.
Read more7/19/2024
➖
0
A Novel Evaluation Perspective on GNNs-based Recommender Systems through the Topology of the User-Item Graph
Daniele Malitesta, Claudio Pomo, Vito Walter Anelli, Alberto Carlo Maria Mancino, Tommaso Di Noia, Eugenio Di Sciascio
Recently, graph neural networks (GNNs)-based recommender systems have encountered great success in recommendation. As the number of GNNs approaches rises, some works have started questioning the theoretical and empirical reasons behind their superior performance. Nevertheless, this investigation still disregards that GNNs treat the recommendation data as a topological graph structure. Building on this assumption, in this work, we provide a novel evaluation perspective on GNNs-based recommendation, which investigates the impact of the graph topology on the recommendation performance. To this end, we select some (topological) properties of the recommendation data and three GNNs-based recommender systems (i.e., LightGCN, DGCF, and SVD-GCN). Then, starting from three popular recommendation datasets (i.e., Yelp2018, Gowalla, and Amazon-Book) we sample them to obtain 1,800 size-reduced datasets that still resemble the original ones but can encompass a wider range of topological structures. We use this procedure to build a large pool of samples for which data characteristics and recommendation performance of the selected GNNs models are measured. Through an explanatory framework, we find strong correspondences between graph topology and GNNs performance, offering a novel evaluation perspective on these models.
Read more8/22/2024
0
All Against Some: Efficient Integration of Large Language Models for Message Passing in Graph Neural Networks
Ajay Jaiswal, Nurendra Choudhary, Ravinarayana Adkathimar, Muthu P. Alagappan, Gaurush Hiranandani, Ying Ding, Zhangyang Wang, Edward W Huang, Karthik Subbian
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have attracted immense attention in the past decade due to their numerous real-world applications built around graph-structured data. On the other hand, Large Language Models (LLMs) with extensive pretrained knowledge and powerful semantic comprehension abilities have recently shown a remarkable ability to benefit applications using vision and text data. In this paper, we investigate how LLMs can be leveraged in a computationally efficient fashion to benefit rich graph-structured data, a modality relatively unexplored in LLM literature. Prior works in this area exploit LLMs to augment every node features in an ad-hoc fashion (not scalable for large graphs), use natural language to describe the complex structural information of graphs, or perform computationally expensive finetuning of LLMs in conjunction with GNNs. We propose E-LLaGNN (Efficient LLMs augmented GNNs), a framework with an on-demand LLM service that enriches message passing procedure of graph learning by enhancing a limited fraction of nodes from the graph. More specifically, E-LLaGNN relies on sampling high-quality neighborhoods using LLMs, followed by on-demand neighborhood feature enhancement using diverse prompts from our prompt catalog, and finally information aggregation using message passing from conventional GNN architectures. We explore several heuristics-based active node selection strategies to limit the computational and memory footprint of LLMs when handling millions of nodes. Through extensive experiments & ablation on popular graph benchmarks of varying scales (Cora, PubMed, ArXiv, & Products), we illustrate the effectiveness of our E-LLaGNN framework and reveal many interesting capabilities such as improved gradient flow in deep GNNs, LLM-free inference ability etc.
Read more7/23/2024