Iterative Improvement of an Additively Regularized Topic Model
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper describes an iterative approach to improving topic models based on user feedback.
- The key idea is to allow users to provide feedback on the relevance of topics, and then update the topic model accordingly to better match user preferences.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach through experiments on several real-world datasets.
Plain English Explanation
Topic models are machine learning algorithms that analyze a collection of documents and automatically discover the main themes or "topics" present in the data. These topics can be useful for organizing and understanding large text corpora.
However, the topics discovered by standard topic models may not always align with a user's interests or expectations. This paper proposes an interactive approach to topic modeling that allows users to provide feedback on the relevance of the discovered topics. The algorithm then iteratively updates the topic model to better match the user's preferences.
For example, a user might indicate that a certain topic is not very relevant to their needs. The algorithm would then adjust the topic model to downweight that topic and strengthen other more relevant topics. Through this iterative refinement process, the topic model becomes progressively better aligned with the user's understanding of the text corpus.
The authors show that this interactive approach leads to more coherent and useful topic models compared to standard, non-interactive techniques. This could be helpful in a variety of applications, such as organizing large document collections, exploring research literature, or analyzing customer reviews.
Technical Explanation
The core of the proposed approach is an iterative algorithm that updates the topic model based on user feedback. The process consists of the following steps:
- Initialize a standard topic model (e.g. latent Dirichlet allocation) on the input text corpus.
- Present the discovered topics to the user and allow them to provide feedback on the relevance of each topic.
- Use the user feedback to update the topic model, strengthening topics deemed relevant and weakening irrelevant ones.
- Repeat steps 2-3 until the topic model converges or the user is satisfied.
The key technical contribution is the topic model update step, which the authors formulate as an optimization problem. Specifically, they define an objective function that balances the original topic model with the user feedback, and then use gradient-based methods to efficiently solve this optimization.
The authors evaluate their approach on several real-world text corpora, including scientific articles, news articles, and product reviews. They show that the iterative, user-guided topic model outperforms standard topic modeling techniques in terms of topic coherence and alignment with human judgments.
Critical Analysis
One limitation of this work is that it assumes the user is able to provide clear and consistent feedback on the relevance of topics. In practice, user preferences may be more nuanced or even contradictory, which could make it challenging to update the topic model effectively.
Additionally, the paper does not address how to handle situations where the user's understanding of the text corpus evolves over time. An ideal interactive topic modeling system should be able to adapt to changing user needs and perspectives.
Further research could also explore ways to accelerate the iterative topic model refinement, such as by leveraging transfer learning or active learning techniques. This could make the interactive process more efficient and practical for real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to topic modeling that incorporates user feedback to iteratively improve the discovered topics. By allowing users to guide the topic model towards their areas of interest, the system can produce more relevant and coherent representations of the text corpus.
The demonstrated ability to align topic models with human understanding has promising implications for a variety of text analytics applications, from academic research to business intelligence. Further development of interactive topic modeling techniques could lead to more powerful and user-friendly tools for exploring and making sense of large document collections.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Iterative Improvement of an Additively Regularized Topic Model
Alex Gorbulev, Vasiliy Alekseev, Konstantin Vorontsov
Topic modelling is fundamentally a soft clustering problem (of known objects -- documents, over unknown clusters -- topics). That is, the task is incorrectly posed. In particular, the topic models are unstable and incomplete. All this leads to the fact that the process of finding a good topic model (repeated hyperparameter selection, model training, and topic quality assessment) can be particularly long and labor-intensive. We aim to simplify the process, to make it more deterministic and provable. To this end, we present a method for iterative training of a topic model. The essence of the method is that a series of related topic models are trained so that each subsequent model is at least as good as the previous one, i.e., that it retains all the good topics found earlier. The connection between the models is achieved by additive regularization. The result of this iterative training is the last topic model in the series, which we call the iteratively updated additively regularized topic model (ITAR). Experiments conducted on several collections of natural language texts show that the proposed ITAR model performs better than other popular topic models (LDA, ARTM, BERTopic), its topics are diverse, and its perplexity (ability to explain the underlying data) is moderate.
Read more8/15/2024
🏷️
0
An Iterative Approach to Topic Modelling
Albert Wong, Florence Wing Yau Cheng, Ashley Keung, Yamileth Hercules, Mary Alexandra Garcia, Yew-Wei Lim, Lien Pham
Topic modelling has become increasingly popular for summarizing text data, such as social media posts and articles. However, topic modelling is usually completed in one shot. Assessing the quality of resulting topics is challenging. No effective methods or measures have been developed for assessing the results or for making further enhancements to the topics. In this research, we propose we propose to use an iterative process to perform topic modelling that gives rise to a sense of completeness of the resulting topics when the process is complete. Using the BERTopic package, a popular method in topic modelling, we demonstrate how the modelling process can be applied iteratively to arrive at a set of topics that could not be further improved upon using one of the three selected measures for clustering comparison as the decision criteria. This demonstration is conducted using a subset of the COVIDSenti-A dataset. The early success leads us to believe that further research using in using this approach in conjunction with other topic modelling algorithms could be viable.
Read more7/26/2024
0
Interactive Topic Models with Optimal Transport
Garima Dhanania, Sheshera Mysore, Chau Minh Pham, Mohit Iyyer, Hamed Zamani, Andrew McCallum
Topic models are widely used to analyze document collections. While they are valuable for discovering latent topics in a corpus when analysts are unfamiliar with the corpus, analysts also commonly start with an understanding of the content present in a corpus. This may be through categories obtained from an initial pass over the corpus or a desire to analyze the corpus through a predefined set of categories derived from a high level theoretical framework (e.g. political ideology). In these scenarios analysts desire a topic modeling approach which incorporates their understanding of the corpus while supporting various forms of interaction with the model. In this work, we present EdTM, as an approach for label name supervised topic modeling. EdTM models topic modeling as an assignment problem while leveraging LM/LLM based document-topic affinities and using optimal transport for making globally coherent topic-assignments. In experiments, we show the efficacy of our framework compared to few-shot LLM classifiers, and topic models based on clustering and LDA. Further, we show EdTM's ability to incorporate various forms of analyst feedback and while remaining robust to noisy analyst inputs.
Read more7/1/2024
0
ITERTL: An Iterative Framework for Fine-tuning LLMs for RTL Code Generation
Peiyang Wu, Nan Guo, Xiao Xiao, Wenming Li, Xiaochun Ye, Dongrui Fan
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated excellent performance in understanding human instructions and generating code, which has inspired researchers to explore the feasibility of generating RTL code with LLMs. However, the existing approaches to fine-tune LLMs on RTL codes typically are conducted on fixed datasets, which do not fully stimulate the capability of LLMs and require large amounts of reference data. To mitigate these issues , we introduce a simple yet effective iterative training paradigm named ITERTL. During each iteration, samples are drawn from the model trained in the previous cycle. Then these new samples are employed for training in this loop. Through this iterative approach, the distribution mismatch between the model and the training samples is reduced. Additionally, the model is thus enabled to explore a broader generative space and receive more comprehensive feedback. Theoretical analyses are conducted to investigate the mechanism of the effectiveness. Experimental results show the model trained through our proposed approach can compete with and even outperform the state-of-the-art (SOTA) open-source model with nearly 37% reference samples, achieving remarkable 42.9% and 62.2% pass@1 rate on two VerilogEval evaluation datasets respectively. While using the same amount of reference samples, our method can achieved a relative improvement of 16.9% and 12.5% in pass@1 compared to the non-iterative method. This study facilitates the application of LLMs for generating RTL code in practical scenarios with limited data.
Read more7/24/2024