Laplacian Segmentation Networks Improve Epistemic Uncertainty Quantification
0
🔍
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Image segmentation often relies on neural networks, which can be overconfident, especially on out-of-distribution (OOD) images.
- This is common in medical applications due to variations in equipment, acquisition sites, or image corruptions.
- The paper proposes Laplacian Segmentation Networks (LSN) to address OOD detection by jointly modeling epistemic (model) and aleatoric (data) uncertainty.
- LSN provides the first Laplace approximation of the weight posterior that scales to large neural networks with skip connections and high-dimensional outputs.
- The paper demonstrates that LSN-modeled parameter distributions, combined with suitable uncertainty measures, provide superior OOD detection on three datasets.
Plain English Explanation
Neural networks, the algorithms behind many image segmentation models, are known to be overconfident in their predictions, especially when dealing with images that are different from the ones they were trained on. This can be a problem in the medical field, where images can vary a lot due to differences in equipment, locations, or other factors.
To address this challenge, the researchers propose a new method called Laplacian Segmentation Networks (LSN). LSN jointly models two types of uncertainty: epistemic uncertainty, which is uncertainty about the model itself, and aleatoric uncertainty, which is uncertainty about the data. By doing this, LSN can better detect when an image is out of the distribution of images it was trained on.
The key innovation in LSN is the way it approximates the uncertainty in the model's parameters, or the values that determine how the model makes its predictions. This approximation allows LSN to work with large, complex neural networks that have many connections and produce high-dimensional outputs, which is common in real-world image segmentation tasks.
The paper shows that LSN's approach to modeling uncertainty leads to better performance in detecting out-of-distribution images compared to other methods, across three different datasets.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes Laplacian Segmentation Networks (LSN), a method for jointly modeling epistemic (model) and aleatoric (data) uncertainty to improve out-of-distribution (OOD) detection in image segmentation.
LSN uses a Laplace approximation to model the posterior distribution of the neural network's weights. This allows LSN to scale to large networks with skip connections and high-dimensional outputs, which is common in real-world image segmentation tasks.
The authors evaluate LSN on three different datasets and show that the LSN-modeled parameter distributions, combined with suitable uncertainty measures, provide superior OOD detection compared to other approaches, such as USL-Net and Bayesian SegNet.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a promising approach to addressing the challenge of overconfidence in neural networks, particularly in the context of medical image segmentation. By jointly modeling epistemic and aleatoric uncertainty, LSN can better detect when an image is out of the distribution of images the model was trained on.
One potential limitation is the reliance on the Laplace approximation, which may not fully capture the true complexity of the weight posterior distribution in large, deep neural networks. Additionally, the paper only evaluates LSN on three datasets, and further testing on a wider range of medical imaging scenarios would be valuable to assess the generalizability of the approach.
It would also be interesting to see how LSN compares to other uncertainty quantification methods, such as Monte Carlo dropout or deep ensembles, in terms of OOD detection performance and computational efficiency.
Conclusion
The Laplacian Segmentation Networks (LSN) proposed in this paper represent an important step forward in addressing the challenge of overconfidence in neural networks, particularly in the context of medical image segmentation. By jointly modeling epistemic and aleatoric uncertainty, LSN can provide more reliable OOD detection, which is crucial for ensuring the safe and effective deployment of these models in real-world medical applications.
The innovative use of the Laplace approximation to scale LSN to large, complex neural networks is a significant technical contribution, and the demonstrated improvements in OOD detection performance are promising. Further research to expand the evaluation of LSN and explore other uncertainty quantification approaches could help advance the field and bring us closer to more robust and trustworthy image segmentation models in the medical domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔍
0
Laplacian Segmentation Networks Improve Epistemic Uncertainty Quantification
Kilian Zepf, Selma Wanna, Marco Miani, Juston Moore, Jes Frellsen, S{o}ren Hauberg, Frederik Warburg, Aasa Feragen
Image segmentation relies heavily on neural networks which are known to be overconfident, especially when making predictions on out-of-distribution (OOD) images. This is a common scenario in the medical domain due to variations in equipment, acquisition sites, or image corruptions. This work addresses the challenge of OOD detection by proposing Laplacian Segmentation Networks (LSN): methods which jointly model epistemic (model) and aleatoric (data) uncertainty for OOD detection. In doing so, we propose the first Laplace approximation of the weight posterior that scales to large neural networks with skip connections that have high-dimensional outputs. We demonstrate on three datasets that the LSN-modeled parameter distributions, in combination with suitable uncertainty measures, gives superior OOD detection.
Read more7/24/2024
📈
0
Investigating and Improving Latent Density Segmentation Models for Aleatoric Uncertainty Quantification in Medical Imaging
M. M. Amaan Valiuddin, Christiaan G. A. Viviers, Ruud J. G. van Sloun, Peter H. N. de With, Fons van der Sommen
Data uncertainties, such as sensor noise, occlusions or limitations in the acquisition method can introduce irreducible ambiguities in images, which result in varying, yet plausible, semantic hypotheses. In Machine Learning, this ambiguity is commonly referred to as aleatoric uncertainty. In image segmentation, latent density models can be utilized to address this problem. The most popular approach is the Probabilistic U-Net (PU-Net), which uses latent Normal densities to optimize the conditional data log-likelihood Evidence Lower Bound. In this work, we demonstrate that the PU-Net latent space is severely sparse and heavily under-utilized. To address this, we introduce mutual information maximization and entropy-regularized Sinkhorn Divergence in the latent space to promote homogeneity across all latent dimensions, effectively improving gradient-descent updates and latent space informativeness. Our results show that by applying this on public datasets of various clinical segmentation problems, our proposed methodology receives up to 11% performance gains compared against preceding latent variable models for probabilistic segmentation on the Hungarian-Matched Intersection over Union. The results indicate that encouraging a homogeneous latent space significantly improves latent density modeling for medical image segmentation.
Read more8/21/2024
0
USL-Net: Uncertainty Self-Learning Network for Unsupervised Skin Lesion Segmentation
Xiaofan Li, Bo Peng, Jie Hu, Changyou Ma, Daipeng Yang, Zhuyang Xie
Unsupervised skin lesion segmentation offers several benefits, including conserving expert human resources, reducing discrepancies due to subjective human labeling, and adapting to novel environments. However, segmenting dermoscopic images without manual labeling guidance presents significant challenges due to dermoscopic image artifacts such as hair noise, blister noise, and subtle edge differences. To address these challenges, we introduce an innovative Uncertainty Self-Learning Network (USL-Net) designed for skin lesion segmentation. The USL-Net can effectively segment a range of lesions, eliminating the need for manual labeling guidance. Initially, features are extracted using contrastive learning, followed by the generation of Class Activation Maps (CAMs) as saliency maps using these features. The different CAM locations correspond to the importance of the lesion region based on their saliency. High-saliency regions in the map serve as pseudo-labels for lesion regions while low-saliency regions represent the background. However, intermediate regions can be hard to classify, often due to their proximity to lesion edges or interference from hair or blisters. Rather than risk potential pseudo-labeling errors or learning confusion by forcefully classifying these regions, we consider them as uncertainty regions, exempting them from pseudo-labeling and allowing the network to self-learn. Further, we employ connectivity detection and centrality detection to refine foreground pseudo-labels and reduce noise-induced errors. The application of cycle refining enhances performance further. Our method underwent thorough experimental validation on the ISIC-2017, ISIC-2018, and PH2 datasets, demonstrating that its performance is on par with weakly supervised and supervised methods, and exceeds that of other existing unsupervised methods.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Navigating Uncertainty in Medical Image Segmentation
Kilian Zepf, Jes Frellsen, Aasa Feragen
We address the selection and evaluation of uncertain segmentation methods in medical imaging and present two case studies: prostate segmentation, illustrating that for minimal annotator variation simple deterministic models can suffice, and lung lesion segmentation, highlighting the limitations of the Generalized Energy Distance (GED) in model selection. Our findings lead to guidelines for accurately choosing and developing uncertain segmentation models, that integrate aleatoric and epistemic components. These guidelines are designed to aid researchers and practitioners in better developing, selecting, and evaluating uncertain segmentation methods, thereby facilitating enhanced adoption and effective application of segmentation uncertainty in practice.
Read more7/24/2024