Large Language Models for Explainable Decisions in Dynamic Digital Twins
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Explores the use of large language models (LLMs) to enable explainable and contestable decision-making within dynamic digital twins (DDTs) for smart agriculture applications.
- Proposes a framework that combines LLM-based retrieval and generation to provide explanations for decisions made by the DDT system.
- Focuses on how LLMs can enhance the transparency and interpretability of DDT-driven decision-making processes.
Plain English Explanation
Dynamic digital twins (DDTs) are virtual models that closely mimic real-world systems, such as agricultural operations. These digital models can make decisions to optimize the performance of the physical system. However, it can be challenging for users to understand how these decisions are made, which can limit trust and adoption.
This paper explores how large language models (LLMs) - powerful AI systems trained on vast amounts of text data - can be used to make the decision-making process in DDTs more transparent and explainable. The researchers propose a framework that combines LLM-based retrieval and generation to provide users with explanations for the decisions made by the DDT system.
The key idea is to use the LLM to search for relevant information and generate natural language explanations that help users understand the reasoning behind the DDT's decisions. This could involve, for example, the LLM identifying relevant facts, analyzing the trade-offs considered, and summarizing the decision-making logic in easy-to-understand terms.
By making the decision-making process more transparent and explainable, the researchers aim to foster greater trust and adoption of DDT systems, particularly in critical domains like smart agriculture, where understanding the reasoning behind decisions is important.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a framework for incorporating LLMs into DDT systems to enable explainable and contestable decision-making. The key components of the framework are:
-
LLM-based Retrieval: The LLM is used to retrieve relevant information from a knowledge base to provide context and background for the DDT's decision-making process. This could include retrieving facts, historical data, or domain-specific knowledge.
-
LLM-based Generation: The LLM is then used to generate natural language explanations that describe the reasoning behind the DDT's decisions. This could involve explaining the objectives considered, the constraints faced, the trade-offs evaluated, and the logic used to arrive at the final decision.
-
Explanation Presentation: The retrieved information and generated explanations are presented to the user in a clear and accessible format, such as through a graphical user interface or natural language summaries.
The authors demonstrate the feasibility of their approach through a case study in smart agriculture, where the DDT system makes decisions to optimize crop yield and resource usage. They show how the LLM-based framework can provide users with detailed explanations for the DDT's decisions, enhancing transparency and enabling users to contest or understand the reasoning behind the system's actions.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the use of LLMs to improve the explainability and contestability of DDT-driven decision-making. By providing users with natural language explanations for the DDT's decisions, the proposed framework has the potential to foster greater trust and adoption of these systems, particularly in critical domains like smart agriculture.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and challenges:
-
Robustness and Reliability: The performance and reliability of the LLM-based explanation generation may be influenced by factors such as the quality and completeness of the knowledge base, the complexity of the decision-making process, and the ability of the LLM to accurately capture and communicate the underlying reasoning.
-
Contextual Limitations: The explanations generated by the LLM may not fully capture the nuances and context-specific factors that influenced the DDT's decision-making, potentially leading to oversimplification or missing important details.
-
Ethical Considerations: As with any AI-driven decision-making system, there are potential ethical concerns around bias, transparency, and accountability that should be carefully addressed, particularly in sensitive domains like agriculture.
Further research and real-world testing would be necessary to fully evaluate the practical and ethical implications of the proposed framework, as well as to assess its scalability and robustness across a range of dynamic digital twin applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to enhancing the explainability and contestability of decision-making in dynamic digital twin systems using large language models. By combining LLM-based retrieval and generation, the proposed framework aims to provide users with natural language explanations that foster greater trust and adoption of these AI-powered systems, particularly in critical domains like smart agriculture.
While the paper highlights the potential benefits of this approach, it also raises important questions around robustness, reliability, and ethical considerations that warrant further investigation. As the use of dynamic digital twins continues to grow, the development of transparent and explainable decision-making systems will be crucial to ensure the responsible and effective deployment of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Large Language Models for Explainable Decisions in Dynamic Digital Twins
Nan Zhang, Christian Vergara-Marcillo, Georgios Diamantopoulos, Jingran Shen, Nikos Tziritas, Rami Bahsoon, Georgios Theodoropoulos
Dynamic data-driven Digital Twins (DDTs) can enable informed decision-making and provide an optimisation platform for the underlying system. By leveraging principles of Dynamic Data-Driven Applications Systems (DDDAS), DDTs can formulate computational modalities for feedback loops, model updates and decision-making, including autonomous ones. However, understanding autonomous decision-making often requires technical and domain-specific knowledge. This paper explores using large language models (LLMs) to provide an explainability platform for DDTs, generating natural language explanations of the system's decision-making by leveraging domain-specific knowledge bases. A case study from smart agriculture is presented.
Read more9/5/2024
💬
0
DeLLMa: A Framework for Decision Making Under Uncertainty with Large Language Models
Ollie Liu, Deqing Fu, Dani Yogatama, Willie Neiswanger
The potential of large language models (LLMs) as decision support tools is increasingly being explored in fields such as business, engineering, and medicine, which often face challenging tasks of decision-making under uncertainty. In this paper, we show that directly prompting LLMs on these types of decision-making problems can yield poor results, especially as the problem complexity increases. To aid in these tasks, we propose DeLLMa (Decision-making Large Language Model assistant), a framework designed to enhance decision-making accuracy in uncertain environments. DeLLMa involves a multi-step scaffolding procedure, drawing upon principles from decision theory and utility theory, to provide a rational and human-auditable decision-making process. We validate our framework on multiple realistic decision-making environments, demonstrating that DeLLMa can consistently enhance the decision-making performance of leading language models, and achieve up to a 40% increase in accuracy over competing methods.
Read more6/11/2024
0
Building Decision Making Models Through Language Model Regime
Yu Zhang, Haoxiang Liu, Feijun Jiang, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang
We propose a novel approach for decision making problems leveraging the generalization capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Traditional methods such as expert systems, planning algorithms, and reinforcement learning often exhibit limited generalization, typically requiring the training of new models for each unique task. In contrast, LLMs demonstrate remarkable success in generalizing across varied language tasks, inspiring a new strategy for training decision making models. Our approach, referred to as Learning then Using (LTU), entails a two-stage process. Initially, the textit{learning} phase develops a robust foundational decision making model by integrating diverse knowledge from various domains and decision making contexts. The subsequent textit{using} phase refines this foundation model for specific decision making scenarios. Distinct from other studies that employ LLMs for decision making through supervised learning, our LTU method embraces a versatile training methodology that combines broad pre-training with targeted fine-tuning. Experiments in e-commerce domains such as advertising and search optimization have shown that LTU approach outperforms traditional supervised learning regimes in decision making capabilities and generalization. The LTU approach is the first practical training architecture for both single-step and multi-step decision making tasks combined with LLMs, which can be applied beyond game and robot domains. It provides a robust and adaptable framework for decision making, enhances the effectiveness and flexibility of various systems in tackling various challenges.
Read more8/13/2024
💬
0
LLM experiments with simulation: Large Language Model Multi-Agent System for Process Simulation Parametrization in Digital Twins
Yuchen Xia, Daniel Dittler, Nasser Jazdi, Haonan Chen, Michael Weyrich
This paper presents a novel design of a multi-agent system framework that applies large language models (LLMs) to automate the parametrization of simulation models in digital twins. This framework features specialized LLM agents tasked with observing, reasoning, decision-making, and summarizing, enabling them to dynamically interact with digital twin simulations to explore parametrization possibilities and determine feasible parameter settings to achieve an objective. The proposed approach enhances the usability of simulation model by infusing it with knowledge heuristics from LLM and enables autonomous search for feasible parametrization to solve a user task. Furthermore, the system has the potential to increase user-friendliness and reduce the cognitive load on human users by assisting in complex decision-making processes. The effectiveness and functionality of the system are demonstrated through a case study, and the visualized demos and codes are available at a GitHub Repository: https://github.com/YuchenXia/LLMDrivenSimulation
Read more7/23/2024