Learning from Successful and Failed Demonstrations via Optimization

Read original: arXiv:2107.11918 - Published 7/1/2024 by Brendan Hertel, S. Reza Ahmadzadeh

🛠️

Overview

Learning from Demonstration (LfD) allows humans to teach robots new skills by showing them the correct way to perform a task.
However, human demonstrations are not always optimal, and the teacher often discards or replaces sub-optimal (noisy or faulty) demonstrations.
This paper proposes a novel LfD approach that learns from both successful and failed demonstrations of a skill.

Plain English Explanation

This research aims to improve the way robots learn new skills from human demonstrations. In the traditional Learning from Demonstration (LfD) approach, humans show robots the correct way to perform a task, and the robots try to learn and replicate that skill.

However, human demonstrations are not always perfect. Sometimes, the human might make mistakes or show the robot an inefficient way of doing things. In these cases, the teacher usually tries to fix the problem by discarding or replacing the "bad" demonstrations.

Instead, the researchers in this paper propose a new LfD method that learns from both the successful and failed demonstrations. Their approach encodes the different types of demonstrations into a statistical skill model, constructs a set of costs, and finds an optimal way for the robot to reproduce the skill under new conditions.

This way, the robot can learn from the teacher's mistakes as well as the successes, potentially leading to a more well-rounded understanding of the skill. The researchers evaluate their approach through various experiments with a robotic arm, and compare it to existing LfD methods to show its benefits.

Technical Explanation

The key elements of this paper's approach are:

Encoding both successful and failed demonstrations: The researchers capture two subsets of demonstrations - those labeled by the teacher as successful, and those labeled as failed. They then encode these two groups into a statistical skill model.
Constructing quadratic costs: The researchers construct a set of quadratic costs that balance convergence towards successful examples and divergence from failed examples. This allows the robot to learn the skill while avoiding the mistakes.
Optimal skill reproduction: Using the statistical model and cost functions, the researchers find an optimal reproduction of the skill under novel problem conditions (i.e., constraints). This optimal reproduction balances the competing objectives of the successful and failed demonstrations.

The paper evaluates this approach through several 2D and 3D experiments using a UR5e robotic arm. They show that their method can reproduce a skill even from only failed demonstrations, and demonstrate its benefits compared to two existing LfD approaches, as well as a skill refinement method.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and interesting approach to learning from demonstration, with the key innovation being the incorporation of failed demonstrations into the learning process. This is a valuable contribution, as most existing LfD methods focus solely on learning from successful demonstrations, which may lead to suboptimal skill acquisition.

One potential limitation of the approach is the reliance on the teacher to label demonstrations as successful or failed. This labeling process could be subjective or inconsistent, which could impact the quality of the learned skill model. The researchers do not address how to handle cases where the teacher's labeling is ambiguous or inconsistent.

Additionally, the paper focuses on relatively simple 2D and 3D tasks. It would be interesting to see how the method scales to more complex, real-world tasks that involve higher-dimensional state and action spaces, as well as more diverse types of failures. Further research could also explore ways to automate the identification of successful and failed demonstrations, rather than relying on human labeling.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel Learning from Demonstration (LfD) approach that learns from both successful and failed human demonstrations of a skill. By encoding these two types of demonstrations into a statistical model and constructing quadratic costs to balance convergence and divergence, the researchers are able to find an optimal way for the robot to reproduce the skill under novel conditions.

The key contribution of this work is the incorporation of failed demonstrations, which allows the robot to learn from the teacher's mistakes as well as their successes. This could lead to more well-rounded skill acquisition, as the robot can avoid repeating the errors made in the failed demonstrations.

The paper's evaluation of the method on various 2D and 3D tasks with a robotic arm demonstrates its potential benefits, and the comparison to existing LfD approaches highlights its advantages. While the approach has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in the field of Learning from Demonstration, with implications for improving the efficiency and robustness of robot skill learning.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🛠️

Learning from Successful and Failed Demonstrations via Optimization

Brendan Hertel, S. Reza Ahmadzadeh

Learning from Demonstration (LfD) is a popular approach that allows humans to teach robots new skills by showing the correct way(s) of performing the desired skill. Human-provided demonstrations, however, are not always optimal and the teacher usually addresses this issue by discarding or replacing sub-optimal (noisy or faulty) demonstrations. We propose a novel LfD representation that learns from both successful and failed demonstrations of a skill. Our approach encodes the two subsets of captured demonstrations (labeled by the teacher) into a statistical skill model, constructs a set of quadratic costs, and finds an optimal reproduction of the skill under novel problem conditions (i.e. constraints). The optimal reproduction balances convergence towards successful examples and divergence from failed examples. We evaluate our approach through several 2D and 3D experiments in real-world using a UR5e manipulator arm and also show that it can reproduce a skill from only failed demonstrations. The benefits of exploiting both failed and successful demonstrations are shown through comparison with two existing LfD approaches. We also compare our approach against an existing skill refinement method and show its capabilities in a multi-coordinate setting.

7/1/2024

➖

Robot Learning from Demonstration Using Elastic Maps

Brendan Hertel, Matthew Pelland, S. Reza Ahmadzadeh

Learning from Demonstration (LfD) is a popular method of reproducing and generalizing robot skills from human-provided demonstrations. In this paper, we propose a novel optimization-based LfD method that encodes demonstrations as elastic maps. An elastic map is a graph of nodes connected through a mesh of springs. We build a skill model by fitting an elastic map to the set of demonstrations. The formulated optimization problem in our approach includes three objectives with natural and physical interpretations. The main term rewards the mean squared error in the Cartesian coordinate. The second term penalizes the non-equidistant distribution of points resulting in the optimum total length of the trajectory. The third term rewards smoothness while penalizing nonlinearity. These quadratic objectives form a convex problem that can be solved efficiently with local optimizers. We examine nine methods for constructing and weighting the elastic maps and study their performance in robotic tasks. We also evaluate the proposed method in several simulated and real-world experiments using a UR5e manipulator arm, and compare it to other LfD approaches to demonstrate its benefits and flexibility across a variety of metrics.

7/1/2024

🎲

Similarity-Aware Skill Reproduction based on Multi-Representational Learning from Demonstration

Brendan Hertel, S. Reza Ahmadzadeh

Learning from Demonstration (LfD) algorithms enable humans to teach new skills to robots through demonstrations. The learned skills can be robustly reproduced from the identical or near boundary conditions (e.g., initial point). However, when generalizing a learned skill over boundary conditions with higher variance, the similarity of the reproductions changes from one boundary condition to another, and a single LfD representation cannot preserve a consistent similarity across a generalization region. We propose a novel similarity-aware framework including multiple LfD representations and a similarity metric that can improve skill generalization by finding reproductions with the highest similarity values for a given boundary condition. Given a demonstration of the skill, our framework constructs a similarity region around a point of interest (e.g., initial point) by evaluating individual LfD representations using the similarity metric. Any point within this volume corresponds to a representation that reproduces the skill with the greatest similarity. We validate our multi-representational framework in three simulated and four sets of real-world experiments using a physical 6-DOF robot. We also evaluate 11 different similarity metrics and categorize them according to their biases in 286 simulated experiments.

7/1/2024

👁️

New!Learning from Demonstration with Implicit Nonlinear Dynamics Models

Peter David Fagan, Subramanian Ramamoorthy

Learning from Demonstration (LfD) is a useful paradigm for training policies that solve tasks involving complex motions. In practice, the successful application of LfD requires overcoming error accumulation during policy execution, i.e. the problem of drift due to errors compounding over time and the consequent out-of-distribution behaviours. Existing works seek to address this problem through scaling data collection, correcting policy errors with a human-in-the-loop, temporally ensembling policy predictions or through learning the parameters of a dynamical system model. In this work, we propose and validate an alternative approach to overcoming this issue. Inspired by reservoir computing, we develop a novel neural network layer that includes a fixed nonlinear dynamical system with tunable dynamical properties. We validate the efficacy of our neural network layer on the task of reproducing human handwriting motions using the LASA Human Handwriting Dataset. Through empirical experiments we demonstrate that incorporating our layer into existing neural network architectures addresses the issue of compounding errors in LfD. Furthermore, we perform a comparative evaluation against existing approaches including a temporal ensemble of policy predictions and an Echo State Networks (ESNs) implementation. We find that our approach yields greater policy precision and robustness on the handwriting task while also generalising to multiple dynamics regimes and maintaining competitive latency scores.

9/30/2024