Learning to connect in action: Measuring and understanding the emergence of boundary spanners in volatile times
2405.11998
0
0
Abstract
Collective intelligence of diverse groups is key for tackling many of today's grand challenges such as fostering resilience and climate adaptation. Information exchange across such diverse groups is crucial for collective intelligence, especially in volatile environments. To facilitate inter-group information exchange, Informational Boundary Spanners (IBSs) as pivotal information exchange 'hubs' are promising. However, the mechanisms that drive the emergence of IBSs remain poorly understood. To address this gap there is first a need for a method to identify and measure the emergence of IBSs. Second, an Agent-Based Modelling (ABM) framework is not available to systematically study mechanisms for the emergence of IBSs in volatile environments. Third, even though the ability to learn who provides high-quality information is thought to be essential to explain the emergence of IBSs, a rigorous test of this mechanism is missing. The learning mechanism is formalized using an ABM framework, with the model's outputs analyzed using the proposed IBS emergence measurement method. To illustrate both the method and the learning mechanism, we present a case study focused on information sharing in the volatile environment of a disaster. The study shows that learning constitutes a mechanism for the emergence of effective IBSs in (a) low-volatility environments characterised by low uncertainty and (b) in high-volatility environments characterised by rapid change if the number of inter-group connections is sufficient. With the method and model, this paper aims to lay the foundations for exploring mechanisms for the emergence of IBSs that facilitate inter-group information exchange. This article advances collective intelligence by providing the essential elements for measuring and understanding the emergence of IBSs and exploring the effect of learning on their emergence in volatile environments.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how "boundary spanners" - individuals who can effectively connect and coordinate across different groups and organizations - emerge during times of crisis and volatility.
- The researchers use a case study of disaster response efforts in Jakarta, Indonesia to investigate the factors that enable and hinder the development of these critical connective roles.
- The study provides insights into how organizations can better foster and support the boundary spanning capabilities needed to respond effectively to complex, unpredictable challenges.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers examine how certain people, called "boundary spanners," are able to effectively bridge connections and coordinate efforts between different groups and organizations, especially during times of crisis and upheaval. Using a case study of disaster response in Jakarta, Indonesia, the researchers explore the factors that enable or inhibit the emergence of these crucial linking roles.
The research provides valuable insights into how organizations can better nurture and support the boundary spanning skills needed to respond agilely and collaboratively to complex, dynamic challenges. By understanding the dynamics that allow some individuals to effectively traverse boundaries, organizations can work to cultivate this important capacity across their teams.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the emergence and role of "boundary spanners" - individuals who can effectively connect and coordinate across diverse groups and organizations - in the context of disaster response efforts in Jakarta, Indonesia.
Through an in-depth case study, the researchers analyzed various factors that influenced the development of these critical bridging roles, including individual characteristics, organizational structures and incentives, and the evolving nature of the crisis situation. The researchers collected data from interviews, observations, and document analysis to gain a rich, nuanced understanding of the boundary spanning dynamics at play.
The findings shed light on how certain capabilities, relationships, and contextual conditions enabled some actors to transcend traditional boundaries and facilitate crucial information sharing, resource allocation, and collaborative problem-solving during the crisis response. Conversely, the researchers also identified barriers that hindered the emergence and impact of boundary spanners.
Based on the insights from this case study, the paper discusses implications for how organizations can better recognize, support, and leverage boundary spanning roles and behaviors to enhance their agility and responsiveness in the face of complex, volatile challenges.
Critical Analysis
The case study approach provides valuable, contextualized insights into the emergence and role of boundary spanners, but the findings may be limited in their generalizability to other crisis situations or organizational settings. Further research would be needed to assess the broader applicability of the identified factors and dynamics.
Additionally, while the paper highlights the importance of boundary spanning capabilities, it does not delve deeply into the specific skills, knowledge, and competencies that enable individuals to effectively bridge across boundaries. A more detailed examination of the microfoundations of boundary spanning could further inform how organizations can cultivate this capacity.
The paper also acknowledges that the research was conducted in a relatively short timeframe during the unfolding crisis, which may have constrained the researchers' ability to fully capture the long-term evolution of boundary spanning roles and their impacts. Longitudinal studies could provide additional insights into the sustainability and institutionalization of boundary spanning practices.
Overall, this study makes a valuable contribution to understanding the emergence and significance of boundary spanners in volatile, uncertain contexts. Building on these insights, further research could explore how organizations can more systematically identify, develop, and leverage boundary spanning capabilities to enhance their resilience and adaptability.
Conclusion
This paper provides a rich, contextualized exploration of how "boundary spanners" - individuals who can effectively connect and coordinate across diverse groups and organizations - emerge and play a crucial role during times of crisis and volatility. Through a case study of disaster response efforts in Jakarta, Indonesia, the researchers uncover various factors that enable and hinder the development of these critical bridging roles.
The findings offer important implications for how organizations can better recognize, support, and leverage boundary spanning capabilities to enhance their agility and responsiveness in the face of complex, unpredictable challenges. By cultivating the skills and conditions that foster effective boundary spanning, organizations can build their capacity to navigate uncertainty, facilitate collaboration, and drive coordinated, adaptive responses.
This research contributes to a growing body of work on the microfoundations of organizational resilience and the role of individual behaviors and relationships in enabling successful adaptation and transformation. Continued exploration of boundary spanning dynamics and their organizational implications can yield valuable insights to help organizations navigate an increasingly volatile and interconnected world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
Exploring the Independent Cascade Model and Its Evolution in Social Network Information Diffusion
Jixuan He, Yutong Guo, Jiacheng Zhao
0
0
This paper delves into the paramount significance of information dissemination within the dynamic realm of social networks. It underscores the pivotal role of information communication models in unraveling the intricacies of data propagation in the digital age. By shedding light on the profound influence of these models, it not only lays the groundwork for exploring various hierarchies and their manifestations but also serves as a catalyst for further research in this formidable field.
5/20/2024
🎯
Navigating simplicity and complexity of social-ecological systems through a dialog between dynamical systems and agent-based models
Sonja Radosavljevic, Udita Sanga, Maja Schluter
0
0
Social-ecological systems research aims to understand the nature of social-ecological phenomena, to find ways to foster or manage conditions under which desired phenomena occur or to reduce the negative consequences of undesirable phenomena. Such challenges are often addressed using dynamical systems models (DSM) or agent-based models (ABM). Here we develop an iterative procedure for combining DSM and ABM to leverage their strengths and gain insights that surpass insights obtained by each approach separately. The procedure uses results of an ABM as inputs for a DSM development. In the following steps, results of the DSM analyses guide future analysis of the ABM and vice versa. This dialogue, more than having a tight connection between the models, enables pushing the research frontier, expanding the set of research questions and insights. We illustrate our method with the example of poverty traps and innovation in agricultural systems, but our conclusions are general and can be applied to other DSM-ABM combinations.
6/26/2024
🔗
Learning Collective Behaviors from Observation
Jinchao Feng, Ming Zhong
0
0
We present a comprehensive examination of learning methodologies employed for the structural identification of dynamical systems. These techniques are designed to elucidate emergent phenomena within intricate systems of interacting agents. Our approach not only ensures theoretical convergence guarantees but also exhibits computational efficiency when handling high-dimensional observational data. The methods adeptly reconstruct both first- and second-order dynamical systems, accommodating observation and stochastic noise, intricate interaction rules, absent interaction features, and real-world observations in agent systems. The foundational aspect of our learning methodologies resides in the formulation of tailored loss functions using the variational inverse problem approach, inherently equipping our methods with dimension reduction capabilities.
4/8/2024
⛏️
New!Multi-topic belief formation through bifurcations over signed social networks
Anastasia Bizyaeva, Alessio Franci, Naomi Ehrich Leonard
0
0
We propose and analyze a nonlinear dynamic model of continuous-time multi-dimensional belief formation over signed social networks. Our model accounts for the effects of a structured belief system, self-appraisal, internal biases, and various sources of cognitive dissonance posited by recent theories in social psychology. We prove that agents become opinionated as a consequence of a bifurcation. We analyze how the balance of social network effects in the model controls the nature of the bifurcation and, therefore, the belief-forming limit-set solutions. Our analysis provides constructive conditions on how multi-stable network belief equilibria and belief oscillations emerging at a belief-forming bifurcation depend on the communication network graph and belief system network graph. Our model and analysis provide new theoretical insights on the dynamics of social systems and a new principled framework for designing decentralized decision-making on engineered networks in the presence of structured relationships among alternatives.
7/4/2024