Learning Transductions and Alignments with RNN Seq2seq Models
2303.06841
0
0
🎲
Abstract
The paper studies the capabilities of Recurrent-Neural-Network sequence to sequence (RNN seq2seq) models in learning four transduction tasks: identity, reversal, total reduplication, and quadratic copying. These transductions are traditionally well studied under finite state transducers and attributed with increasing complexity. We find that RNN seq2seq models are only able to approximate a mapping that fits the training or in-distribution data, instead of learning the underlying functions. Although attention makes learning more efficient and robust, it does not overcome the out-of-distribution generalization limitation. We establish a novel complexity hierarchy for learning the four tasks for attention-less RNN seq2seq models, which may be understood in terms of the complexity hierarchy of formal languages, instead of string transductions. RNN variants also play a role in the results. In particular, we show that Simple RNN seq2seq models cannot count the input length.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- The paper examines the abilities of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models to learn four different transduction tasks: identity, reversal, total reduplication, and quadratic copying.
- These tasks are traditionally studied using finite state transducers and are considered to have increasing complexity.
- The researchers found that RNN seq2seq models can only approximate a mapping that fits the training data, rather than learning the underlying functions.
- Attention mechanisms can make learning more efficient and robust, but do not overcome the limitations in out-of-distribution generalization.
- The paper establishes a novel complexity hierarchy for these four tasks, which may be understood in terms of the complexity hierarchy of formal languages, rather than just string transductions.
- The performance of different RNN variants is also explored, with the key finding that Simple RNN seq2seq models cannot count the input length.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how well Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models can learn four different tasks that involve transforming one sequence of characters into another. These tasks, like reversing the order of characters or duplicating each character, are commonly studied using a type of computer program called a finite state transducer.
The researchers found that while RNN seq2seq models can learn to perform these tasks on the training data they were shown, they don't truly understand the underlying rules. The models just find a way to approximate the correct output, rather than learning the actual function that defines the transformation.
Adding attention mechanisms, a technique used to improve RNN and transformer models, can make the models more efficient and robust at learning these tasks. However, it still doesn't allow them to generalize beyond the data they were trained on.
The paper also establishes a new way to think about the complexity of these four tasks, relating them to the complexity of different types of formal languages, rather than just the complexity of the string transformations themselves. Additionally, the researchers show that a basic type of RNN seq2seq model, called a Simple RNN, cannot even keep track of the length of the input sequence.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates the capabilities of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models in learning four transduction tasks: identity, reversal, total reduplication, and quadratic copying. These tasks are traditionally well-studied using finite state transducers and are considered to have increasing complexity.
The experimental setup involves training RNN seq2seq models, both with and without attention mechanisms, on each of the four transduction tasks. The researchers analyze the models' ability to learn the underlying functions, rather than just memorizing the training data. They also explore the role of different RNN variants, including Simple RNN, Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU), and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM).
The key findings are:
- RNN seq2seq models can only approximate a mapping that fits the training data, rather than learning the true underlying functions for these transductions.
- Attention mechanisms can make learning more efficient and robust, but do not overcome the fundamental limitations in out-of-distribution generalization.
- The paper establishes a novel complexity hierarchy for the four tasks, which may be understood in terms of the complexity hierarchy of formal languages, rather than just string transductions.
- Simple RNN seq2seq models, in particular, are unable to count the length of the input sequence, a key capability required for some of the tasks.
These findings contribute to our understanding of the limitations of RNN seq2seq models, even with the addition of attention, in learning complex transduction tasks that are well-studied in theoretical computer science.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and rigorous analysis of the capabilities and limitations of RNN seq2seq models in learning a set of transduction tasks. The researchers' approach of comparing the models' performance to the established complexity hierarchy of these tasks is a novel and insightful way to assess the models' underlying understanding, rather than just their ability to memorize the training data.
One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses solely on these four specific transduction tasks, which may not fully capture the breadth of challenges faced by RNN seq2seq models in real-world sequence-to-sequence learning problems. Further research could explore the generalization of these findings to a wider range of sequence-to-sequence tasks, including those with more practical applications.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential reasons why RNN seq2seq models struggle to learn the true underlying functions for these transductions, despite the added complexity of attention mechanisms. Exploring the interpretability and inner workings of these models could provide valuable insights into the limitations and guide future model development.
Overall, the paper makes a significant contribution to our understanding of the capabilities and limitations of RNN seq2seq models, and sets the stage for further research into more efficient and generally applicable sequence-to-sequence modeling techniques.
Conclusion
The paper investigates the abilities of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models in learning four transduction tasks: identity, reversal, total reduplication, and quadratic copying. These tasks are traditionally studied using finite state transducers and are considered to have increasing complexity.
The key findings are that RNN seq2seq models can only approximate the correct mapping for the training data, rather than learning the underlying functions. While attention mechanisms can improve the efficiency and robustness of learning, they do not overcome the fundamental limitations in out-of-distribution generalization. The paper also establishes a novel complexity hierarchy for these tasks, relating them to the complexity hierarchy of formal languages.
These results highlight the limitations of current RNN seq2seq models, even with attention, in truly understanding and generalizing complex sequence-to-sequence transformations. The insights from this research can inform the development of more advanced sequence-to-sequence modeling techniques that can better capture the underlying rules and principles governing complex data transformations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🎲
Transformers as Transducers
Lena Strobl, Dana Angluin, David Chiang, Jonathan Rawski, Ashish Sabharwal
0
0
We study the sequence-to-sequence mapping capacity of transformers by relating them to finite transducers, and find that they can express surprisingly large classes of transductions. We do so using variants of RASP, a programming language designed to help people think like transformers, as an intermediate representation. We extend the existing Boolean variant B-RASP to sequence-to-sequence functions and show that it computes exactly the first-order rational functions (such as string rotation). Then, we introduce two new extensions. B-RASP[pos] enables calculations on positions (such as copying the first half of a string) and contains all first-order regular functions. S-RASP adds prefix sum, which enables additional arithmetic operations (such as squaring a string) and contains all first-order polyregular functions. Finally, we show that masked average-hard attention transformers can simulate S-RASP. A corollary of our results is a new proof that transformer decoders are Turing-complete.
4/3/2024
Does Transformer Interpretability Transfer to RNNs?
Gonc{c}alo Paulo, Thomas Marshall, Nora Belrose
0
0
Recent advances in recurrent neural network architectures, such as Mamba and RWKV, have enabled RNNs to match or exceed the performance of equal-size transformers in terms of language modeling perplexity and downstream evaluations, suggesting that future systems may be built on completely new architectures. In this paper, we examine if selected interpretability methods originally designed for transformer language models will transfer to these up-and-coming recurrent architectures. Specifically, we focus on steering model outputs via contrastive activation addition, on eliciting latent predictions via the tuned lens, and eliciting latent knowledge from models fine-tuned to produce false outputs under certain conditions. Our results show that most of these techniques are effective when applied to RNNs, and we show that it is possible to improve some of them by taking advantage of RNNs' compressed state.
4/10/2024
🧠
Neural Sequence-to-Sequence Modeling with Attention by Leveraging Deep Learning Architectures for Enhanced Contextual Understanding in Abstractive Text Summarization
Bhavith Chandra Challagundla, Chakradhar Peddavenkatagari
0
0
Automatic text summarization (TS) plays a pivotal role in condensing large volumes of information into concise, coherent summaries, facilitating efficient information retrieval and comprehension. This paper presents a novel framework for abstractive TS of single documents, which integrates three dominant aspects: structural, semantic, and neural-based approaches. The proposed framework merges machine learning and knowledge-based techniques to achieve a unified methodology. The framework consists of three main phases: pre-processing, machine learning, and post-processing. In the pre-processing phase, a knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) technique is employed to generalize ambiguous words, enhancing content generalization. Semantic content generalization is then performed to address out-of-vocabulary (OOV) or rare words, ensuring comprehensive coverage of the input document. Subsequently, the generalized text is transformed into a continuous vector space using neural language processing techniques. A deep sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) model with an attention mechanism is employed to predict a generalized summary based on the vector representation. In the post-processing phase, heuristic algorithms and text similarity metrics are utilized to refine the generated summary further. Concepts from the generalized summary are matched with specific entities, enhancing coherence and readability. Experimental evaluations conducted on prominent datasets, including Gigaword, Duc 2004, and CNN/DailyMail, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework. Results indicate significant improvements in handling rare and OOV words, outperforming existing state-of-the-art deep learning techniques. The proposed framework presents a comprehensive and unified approach towards abstractive TS, combining the strengths of structure, semantics, and neural-based methodologies.
4/16/2024
🤿
Mamba-360: Survey of State Space Models as Transformer Alternative for Long Sequence Modelling: Methods, Applications, and Challenges
Badri Narayana Patro, Vijay Srinivas Agneeswaran
0
0
Sequence modeling is a crucial area across various domains, including Natural Language Processing (NLP), speech recognition, time series forecasting, music generation, and bioinformatics. Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) and Long Short Term Memory Networks (LSTMs) have historically dominated sequence modeling tasks like Machine Translation, Named Entity Recognition (NER), etc. However, the advancement of transformers has led to a shift in this paradigm, given their superior performance. Yet, transformers suffer from $O(N^2)$ attention complexity and challenges in handling inductive bias. Several variations have been proposed to address these issues which use spectral networks or convolutions and have performed well on a range of tasks. However, they still have difficulty in dealing with long sequences. State Space Models(SSMs) have emerged as promising alternatives for sequence modeling paradigms in this context, especially with the advent of S4 and its variants, such as S4nd, Hippo, Hyena, Diagnol State Spaces (DSS), Gated State Spaces (GSS), Linear Recurrent Unit (LRU), Liquid-S4, Mamba, etc. In this survey, we categorize the foundational SSMs based on three paradigms namely, Gating architectures, Structural architectures, and Recurrent architectures. This survey also highlights diverse applications of SSMs across domains such as vision, video, audio, speech, language (especially long sequence modeling), medical (including genomics), chemical (like drug design), recommendation systems, and time series analysis, including tabular data. Moreover, we consolidate the performance of SSMs on benchmark datasets like Long Range Arena (LRA), WikiText, Glue, Pile, ImageNet, Kinetics-400, sstv2, as well as video datasets such as Breakfast, COIN, LVU, and various time series datasets. The project page for Mamba-360 work is available on this webpage.url{https://github.com/badripatro/mamba360}.
4/26/2024