Leveraging vision-language models for fair facial attribute classification
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores how CLIP, a large vision-language model, can be leveraged to infer sensitive information and improve model fairness.
- It examines the implications of using CLIP for sensitive attribute inference and proposes techniques to mitigate unfairness.
- The research aims to advance understanding of the capabilities and limitations of CLIP in the context of fairness and privacy.
Plain English Explanation
The paper investigates how a powerful artificial intelligence (AI) model called CLIP can be used to infer sensitive information about people from images. CLIP is trained to understand the relationship between images and the text that describes them. The researchers found that CLIP can be used to guess attributes like age, gender, and race from images, even when those attributes are not directly labeled.
This raises concerns about privacy and fairness, as CLIP could potentially be used to make unfair decisions about people based on these inferred attributes. To address this, the researchers propose techniques to make CLIP-based models more fair by reducing biases and ensuring equal treatment regardless of sensitive characteristics.
By understanding the capabilities and limitations of CLIP, the researchers hope to inform the development of more ethical and responsible AI systems that respect individual privacy and promote fairness.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by examining how CLIP can be used to infer sensitive attributes like age, gender, and race from images. The researchers found that CLIP's ability to associate images with textual descriptions can be leveraged to predict these attributes with reasonable accuracy, even when they are not directly labeled in the training data.
To mitigate the potential for unfair use of this capability, the researchers propose several techniques. First, they explore methods to fine-tune CLIP to be more fair, reducing biases and ensuring equal performance across different demographic groups. They also investigate ways to assess the fairness of CLIP-based models and identify potential sources of unfairness.
The paper also discusses the broader implications of using CLIP for sensitive attribute inference and proposes a unified framework for evaluating societal bias in vision-language models. This framework can help researchers and developers better understand the potential harms and mitigate the risks associated with using such powerful AI models.
Critical Analysis
The paper raises important concerns about the potential misuse of CLIP for sensitive attribute inference and unfair decision-making. The researchers' proposed techniques to improve fairness are a valuable contribution, but they acknowledge that more research is needed to fully address these challenges.
One limitation of the study is that it focuses primarily on facial attributes, which may not reflect the broader capabilities of CLIP to infer sensitive information from a wide range of visual inputs. Additionally, the proposed fairness-enhancing methods may not be sufficient to eliminate all forms of bias, and further work is needed to ensure the ethical and responsible deployment of CLIP-based systems.
The paper also does not delve deeply into the broader societal implications of using CLIP for sensitive attribute inference, such as the potential for discrimination, privacy violations, and the perpetuation of harmful stereotypes. These are important considerations that warrant further discussion and analysis.
Conclusion
This paper provides important insights into the capabilities and limitations of CLIP in the context of sensitive information inference and model fairness. By highlighting the potential risks and proposing mitigating techniques, the researchers contribute to the ongoing efforts to develop more ethical and responsible AI systems.
As the use of large vision-language models like CLIP continues to expand, it will be crucial for researchers, developers, and policymakers to collaborate in addressing the complex challenges surrounding privacy, fairness, and the societal impact of these technologies. The findings and recommendations presented in this paper serve as a valuable starting point for these important discussions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Leveraging vision-language models for fair facial attribute classification
Miao Zhang, Rumi Chunara
Performance disparities of image recognition across different demographic populations are known to exist in deep learning-based models, but previous work has largely addressed such fairness problems assuming knowledge of sensitive attribute labels. To overcome this reliance, previous strategies have involved separate learning structures to expose and adjust for disparities. In this work, we explore a new paradigm that does not require sensitive attribute labels, and evades the need for extra training by leveraging general-purpose vision-language model (VLM), as a rich knowledge source for common sensitive attributes. We analyze the correspondence between VLM predicted and human defined sensitive attribute distribution. We find that VLMs can recognize samples with clear attribute information encoded in image representations, thus capture under-performed samples conflicting with attribute-related bias. We train downstream target classifiers by re-sampling and augmenting under-performed attribute groups. Extensive experiments on multiple benchmark facial attribute classification datasets show fairness gains of the model over existing unsupervised baselines that tackle with arbitrary bias. The work indicates that vision-language models can extract discriminative sensitive information prompted by language, and be used to promote model fairness.
Read more9/18/2024
0
Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts
Xuyang Wu, Yuan Wang, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang
Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding. However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life, especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and age. In this paper, we empirically investigate emph{visual fairness} in several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets (e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks. The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes.
Read more6/27/2024
🤯
0
Private Attribute Inference from Images with Vision-Language Models
Batuhan Tomekc{c}e, Mark Vero, Robin Staab, Martin Vechev
As large language models (LLMs) become ubiquitous in our daily tasks and digital interactions, associated privacy risks are increasingly in focus. While LLM privacy research has primarily focused on the leakage of model training data, it has recently been shown that the increase in models' capabilities has enabled LLMs to make accurate privacy-infringing inferences from previously unseen texts. With the rise of multimodal vision-language models (VLMs), capable of understanding both images and text, a pertinent question is whether such results transfer to the previously unexplored domain of benign images posted online. To investigate the risks associated with the image reasoning capabilities of newly emerging VLMs, we compile an image dataset with human-annotated labels of the image owner's personal attributes. In order to understand the additional privacy risk posed by VLMs beyond traditional human attribute recognition, our dataset consists of images where the inferable private attributes do not stem from direct depictions of humans. On this dataset, we evaluate the inferential capabilities of 7 state-of-the-art VLMs, finding that they can infer various personal attributes at up to 77.6% accuracy. Concerningly, we observe that accuracy scales with the general capabilities of the models, implying that future models can be misused as stronger adversaries, establishing an imperative for the development of adequate defenses.
Read more4/17/2024
0
FineFACE: Fair Facial Attribute Classification Leveraging Fine-grained Features
Ayesha Manzoor, Ajita Rattani
Published research highlights the presence of demographic bias in automated facial attribute classification algorithms, particularly impacting women and individuals with darker skin tones. Existing bias mitigation techniques typically require demographic annotations and often obtain a trade-off between fairness and accuracy, i.e., Pareto inefficiency. Facial attributes, whether common ones like gender or others such as chubby or high cheekbones, exhibit high interclass similarity and intraclass variation across demographics leading to unequal accuracy. This requires the use of local and subtle cues using fine-grained analysis for differentiation. This paper proposes a novel approach to fair facial attribute classification by framing it as a fine-grained classification problem. Our approach effectively integrates both low-level local features (like edges and color) and high-level semantic features (like shapes and structures) through cross-layer mutual attention learning. Here, shallow to deep CNN layers function as experts, offering category predictions and attention regions. An exhaustive evaluation on facial attribute annotated datasets demonstrates that our FineFACE model improves accuracy by 1.32% to 1.74% and fairness by 67% to 83.6%, over the SOTA bias mitigation techniques. Importantly, our approach obtains a Pareto-efficient balance between accuracy and fairness between demographic groups. In addition, our approach does not require demographic annotations and is applicable to diverse downstream classification tasks. To facilitate reproducibility, the code and dataset information is available at https://github.com/VCBSL-Fairness/FineFACE.
Read more9/2/2024