LLMPot: Automated LLM-based Industrial Protocol and Physical Process Emulation for ICS Honeypots
2405.05999
0
0
Abstract
Industrial Control Systems (ICS) are extensively used in critical infrastructures ensuring efficient, reliable, and continuous operations. However, their increasing connectivity and addition of advanced features make them vulnerable to cyber threats, potentially leading to severe disruptions in essential services. In this context, honeypots play a vital role by acting as decoy targets within ICS networks, or on the Internet, helping to detect, log, analyze, and develop mitigations for ICS-specific cyber threats. Deploying ICS honeypots, however, is challenging due to the necessity of accurately replicating industrial protocols and device characteristics, a crucial requirement for effectively mimicking the unique operational behavior of different industrial systems. Moreover, this challenge is compounded by the significant manual effort required in also mimicking the control logic the PLC would execute, in order to capture attacker traffic aiming to disrupt critical infrastructure operations. In this paper, we propose LLMPot, a novel approach for designing honeypots in ICS networks harnessing the potency of Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMPot aims to automate and optimize the creation of realistic honeypots with vendor-agnostic configurations, and for any control logic, aiming to eliminate the manual effort and specialized knowledge traditionally required in this domain. We conducted extensive experiments focusing on a wide array of parameters, demonstrating that our LLM-based approach can effectively create honeypot devices implementing different industrial protocols and diverse control logic.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents LLMPot, a system that uses large language models (LLMs) to automatically emulate industrial control system (ICS) protocols and physical processes for ICS honeypots.
- ICS honeypots are simulated ICS environments designed to attract and study attacks on critical infrastructure.
- LLMPot aims to simplify the creation and deployment of realistic ICS honeypots by leveraging the language understanding and generation capabilities of LLMs.
Plain English Explanation
LLMPot is a tool that uses advanced AI language models to simulate industrial control systems (ICS) for the purpose of security research. ICS are the computer systems that control and monitor critical infrastructure like power plants, factories, and water treatment facilities.
Researchers often use "honeypots" - fake ICS systems designed to lure and study attackers - to better understand the threats facing these important systems. However, creating realistic and responsive honeypots can be challenging. LLMPot automates this process by using large language models (LLMs), which are AI systems trained on massive amounts of text data to understand and generate human-like language.
With LLMPot, researchers can quickly set up ICS honeypots that can convincingly mimic the communication protocols and physical processes of real industrial control systems. This makes it easier for them to study how attackers try to infiltrate and manipulate critical infrastructure, without risking harm to actual systems. The language understanding of LLMs allows the honeypots to engage in natural conversations and respond appropriately to a wide range of inputs from potential attackers.
Technical Explanation
The core of LLMPot is the use of large language models (LLMs) to automate the emulation of ICS protocols and physical processes for honeypots. The authors leverage the language understanding and generation capabilities of LLMs to create ICS honeypots that can engage in realistic communication and respond dynamically to inputs.
The LLMPot system has three main components: a protocol emulator, a physical process emulator, and a communication manager. The protocol emulator uses LLMs to parse and generate messages conforming to common ICS protocols like Modbus and DNP3. The physical process emulator models the behavior of industrial equipment and processes using LLM-based simulations. The communication manager coordinates the interactions between the protocol and physical process components.
To evaluate LLMPot, the authors set up honeypots for three ICS use cases: a water treatment plant, a power substation, and a manufacturing facility. They demonstrate that the LLM-powered honeypots can effectively mimic the communication patterns and physical behaviors of real ICS environments, while also being able to adapt to unexpected inputs from potential attackers.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. First, the accuracy and fidelity of the LLM-based emulations are dependent on the quality and coverage of the training data used to fine-tune the language models. Gaps or biases in the training data could lead to inaccuracies or unrealistic behaviors in the honeypots.
Additionally, the authors note that the computational and memory requirements of running large language models may pose challenges for deploying LLMPot in resource-constrained environments. Optimizing the LLM inference and runtime may be necessary for certain use cases.
While the paper demonstrates the potential of LLMs for ICS honeypot emulation, further research is needed to evaluate the system's robustness, scalability, and ability to keep pace with the evolving threat landscape in critical infrastructure security.
Conclusion
The LLMPot system presents a novel approach to simplifying the creation and deployment of realistic ICS honeypots using large language models. By leveraging the language understanding and generation capabilities of LLMs, the system can automatically emulate industrial protocols and physical processes, making it easier for security researchers to set up and study attacks on critical infrastructure.
The technical evaluation shows promising results, but also highlights the need for further research to address limitations around data quality, computational requirements, and long-term adaptability. Overall, the paper demonstrates the potential of applying advanced AI techniques like LLMs to enhance the capabilities and accessibility of ICS security tools.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
CPS-LLM: Large Language Model based Safe Usage Plan Generator for Human-in-the-Loop Human-in-the-Plant Cyber-Physical System
Ayan Banerjee, Aranyak Maity, Payal Kamboj, Sandeep K. S. Gupta
0
0
We explore the usage of large language models (LLM) in human-in-the-loop human-in-the-plant cyber-physical systems (CPS) to translate a high-level prompt into a personalized plan of actions, and subsequently convert that plan into a grounded inference of sequential decision-making automated by a real-world CPS controller to achieve a control goal. We show that it is relatively straightforward to contextualize an LLM so it can generate domain-specific plans. However, these plans may be infeasible for the physical system to execute or the plan may be unsafe for human users. To address this, we propose CPS-LLM, an LLM retrained using an instruction tuning framework, which ensures that generated plans not only align with the physical system dynamics of the CPS but are also safe for human users. The CPS-LLM consists of two innovative components: a) a liquid time constant neural network-based physical dynamics coefficient estimator that can derive coefficients of dynamical models with some unmeasured state variables; b) the model coefficients are then used to train an LLM with prompts embodied with traces from the dynamical system and the corresponding model coefficients. We show that when the CPS-LLM is integrated with a contextualized chatbot such as BARD it can generate feasible and safe plans to manage external events such as meals for automated insulin delivery systems used by Type 1 Diabetes subjects.
5/21/2024
🔮
Strategic Deployment of Honeypots in Blockchain-based IoT Systems
Daniel Commey, Sena Hounsinou, Garth V. Crosby
0
0
This paper addresses the challenge of enhancing cybersecurity in Blockchain-based Internet of Things (BIoTs) systems, which are increasingly vulnerable to sophisticated cyberattacks. It introduces an AI-powered system model for the dynamic deployment of honeypots, utilizing an Intrusion Detection System (IDS) integrated with smart contract functionalities on IoT nodes. This model enables the transformation of regular nodes into decoys in response to suspicious activities, thereby strengthening the security of BIoT networks. The paper analyses strategic interactions between potential attackers and the AI-enhanced IDS through a game-theoretic model, specifically Bayesian games. The model focuses on understanding and predicting sophisticated attacks that may initially appear normal, emphasizing strategic decision-making, optimized honeypot deployment, and adaptive strategies in response to evolving attack patterns.
5/22/2024
Efficient Prompting for LLM-based Generative Internet of Things
Bin Xiao, Burak Kantarci, Jiawen Kang, Dusit Niyato, Mohsen Guizani
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capacities on various tasks, and integrating the capacities of LLMs into the Internet of Things (IoT) applications has drawn much research attention recently. Due to security concerns, many institutions avoid accessing state-of-the-art commercial LLM services, requiring the deployment and utilization of open-source LLMs in a local network setting. However, open-source LLMs usually have more limitations regarding their performance, such as their arithmetic calculation and reasoning capacities, and practical systems of applying LLMs to IoT have yet to be well-explored. Therefore, we propose a text-based generative IoT (GIoT) system deployed in the local network setting in this study. To alleviate the limitations of LLMs and provide service with competitive performance, we apply prompt engineering methods to enhance the capacities of the open-source LLMs, design a Prompt Management Module and a Post-processing Module to manage the tailored prompts for different tasks and process the results generated by the LLMs. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed system, we discuss a challenging Table Question Answering (Table-QA) task as a case study of the proposed system, as tabular data is usually more challenging than plain text because of their complex structures, heterogeneous data types and sometimes huge sizes. We conduct comprehensive experiments on two popular Table-QA datasets, and the results show that our proposal can achieve competitive performance compared with state-of-the-art LLMs, demonstrating that the proposed LLM-based GIoT system can provide competitive performance with tailored prompting methods and is easily extensible to new tasks without training.
6/19/2024
📊
Lockpicking LLMs: A Logit-Based Jailbreak Using Token-level Manipulation
Yuxi Li, Yi Liu, Yuekang Li, Ling Shi, Gelei Deng, Shengquan Chen, Kailong Wang
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have transformed the field of natural language processing, but they remain susceptible to jailbreaking attacks that exploit their capabilities to generate unintended and potentially harmful content. Existing token-level jailbreaking techniques, while effective, face scalability and efficiency challenges, especially as models undergo frequent updates and incorporate advanced defensive measures. In this paper, we introduce JailMine, an innovative token-level manipulation approach that addresses these limitations effectively. JailMine employs an automated mining process to elicit malicious responses from LLMs by strategically selecting affirmative outputs and iteratively reducing the likelihood of rejection. Through rigorous testing across multiple well-known LLMs and datasets, we demonstrate JailMine's effectiveness and efficiency, achieving a significant average reduction of 86% in time consumed while maintaining high success rates averaging 95%, even in the face of evolving defensive strategies. Our work contributes to the ongoing effort to assess and mitigate the vulnerability of LLMs to jailbreaking attacks, underscoring the importance of continued vigilance and proactive measures to enhance the security and reliability of these powerful language models.
6/21/2024