Locally Private Estimation with Public Features

Overview

• This paper explores a new approach to machine learning called "Locally Differentially Private (LDP) learning with public features", also known as "semi-feature LDP".
• In semi-feature LDP, some features are publicly available while the remaining features and the label require protection under local differential privacy.
• The researchers demonstrate that this semi-feature LDP approach can significantly improve the convergence rate for non-parametric regression compared to classical LDP methods.
• They propose a new estimator called "HistOfTree" that leverages the information in both public and private features to achieve optimal convergence rates.
• The paper also explores scenarios where users can manually select which features to protect, and provides an estimator and data-driven parameter tuning strategy for this case.

Plain English Explanation

In machine learning, there are often tradeoffs between the accuracy of a model and the privacy of the data used to train it. Differential privacy is a way to protect the privacy of individual data points while still allowing the data to be used for analysis.

This paper looks at a new approach called semi-feature differential privacy, where some features (characteristics) of the data are publicly available, while others are kept private and protected using differential privacy. The researchers show that this semi-feature approach can actually improve the performance of machine learning models compared to using full differential privacy.

They propose a new estimator called "HistOfTree" that can take advantage of both the public and private features to get better results. Imagine you have a dataset with information about people's ages, incomes, and health conditions. Some of that information, like age and income, could be public, while the health conditions are private and need to be protected. The HistOfTree estimator can use the public age and income data along with the protected health data to train a more accurate model.

The paper also explores scenarios where users can choose which specific features to protect, and provides methods for doing that effectively. This gives people more flexibility in deciding how to balance accuracy and privacy for their particular needs.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contributions of this paper are:

1. Semi-feature LDP: The researchers define a new framework called "semi-feature LDP" where some features are publicly available while the remaining features and the label require protection under local differential privacy. They show that this semi-feature LDP approach can significantly improve the mini-max convergence rate for non-parametric regression compared to classical LDP.

2. HistOfTree Estimator: The researchers propose a new estimator called "HistOfTree" that can fully leverage the information contained in both public and private features. Theoretically, HistOfTree achieves the mini-max optimal convergence rate.

3. Manually Selected Features: The paper also explores scenarios where users have the flexibility to select which features to protect manually. In this case, the researchers propose a new estimator and a data-driven parameter tuning strategy that lead to analogous theoretical and empirical results.

The core idea behind semi-feature LDP is to exploit the availability of some public features to overcome the fundamental limitations of classical LDP methods, as shown in prior work on differentially private federated learning and differentially private hierarchical federated learning. The HistOfTree estimator builds on this by carefully combining the public and private features to achieve optimal statistical efficiency.

The manual feature selection approach adds flexibility for users, allowing them to balance accuracy and privacy according to their needs. The researchers provide principled methods for this use case, building on techniques like differentially private log-location-scale regression and adaptive online Bayesian estimation.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising new direction for differentially private machine learning, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

• The theoretical analysis assumes certain conditions on the underlying data distribution, which may not always hold in practice. More work is needed to understand the robustness of the semi-feature LDP approach to real-world data.

• The manual feature selection approach gives users flexibility, but it requires them to have a good understanding of the tradeoffs between accuracy and privacy for their particular use case. Developing more automated methods for this task could make the approach more accessible.

• The paper focuses on non-parametric regression, but it would be valuable to explore the performance of semi-feature LDP for other machine learning tasks, such as classification or clustering.

Overall, this paper demonstrates the potential benefits of leveraging public features in differentially private machine learning, and provides a strong foundation for further research in this area.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel approach to differentially private machine learning called "semi-feature LDP", where some features are publicly available while others require protection. The researchers show that this semi-feature LDP approach can significantly improve the convergence rate for non-parametric regression compared to classical LDP methods.

They propose a new estimator called "HistOfTree" that can fully leverage the information in both public and private features to achieve optimal statistical efficiency. The paper also explores scenarios where users can manually select which features to protect, and provides methods for this case as well.

The work in this paper represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between privacy and accuracy in machine learning, and could have significant implications for a wide range of applications where differential privacy is needed. As the authors note, there are still some limitations and areas for further research, but this paper lays the groundwork for a promising new direction in the field.