Manifold Fitting under Unbounded Noise
0
❗
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Researchers are exploring ways to recover a low-dimensional structure, called a manifold, from high-dimensional data
- Existing methods estimate the manifold based on the tangent space at each data point, but this can be inaccurate if the data is noisy
- This paper introduces a new method that estimates the tangent spaces at projected points on the underlying manifold, rather than the noisy data points, to improve accuracy
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you have a crumpled piece of paper - that's like high-dimensional data, with lots of complexity and details. Researchers want to try to "flatten out" that paper, recovering its underlying 2D structure - the manifold. Existing methods do this by looking at the "slopes" or tangent spaces at each crinkle in the paper. But if the paper is really crumpled and messy (noisy data), those tangent spaces won't be very accurate.
This new method tries to improve on that by instead looking at the tangent spaces at "flattened out" points on the underlying 2D structure, rather than the crinkly data points. This helps reduce the error caused by the noise in the data. The paper shows this new method can still accurately recover the underlying manifold, even with unbounded noise in the data.
Technical Explanation
This paper introduces a new method for manifold fitting - recovering the low-dimensional manifold underlying high-dimensional data, even when the data is noisy. Existing methods like this one estimate the manifold by looking at the tangent spaces at each sample point. However, if the noise in the data is unbounded, these tangent space estimates become inaccurate, leading to errors in the final manifold.
The key innovation in this paper is to instead estimate the tangent spaces at projected points on the underlying manifold, rather than the noisy sample points. This helps decrease the error caused by the noise. Theoretically, the authors show this new method can still accurately recover the manifold, even with unbounded noise, with high probability.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a robust theoretical analysis of the new manifold fitting method, including bounds on the distance between the estimated and true manifold, as well as the smoothness of the estimated manifold. The authors also validate their claims through numerical simulations.
That said, the method does rely on certain assumptions, such as the manifold having bounded curvature. It's not clear how sensitive the approach is to violations of these assumptions in real-world datasets. Additionally, the paper does not provide much intuition or visualization to help the reader build an intuitive understanding of how the method works.
Further research could explore extending the method to higher-dimensional manifolds, as well as evaluating its performance on a broader range of real-world datasets beyond the examples provided.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to manifold fitting that is designed to be robust to unbounded noise in the data. By estimating tangent spaces at projected points on the underlying manifold, rather than the noisy sample points, the method can more accurately recover the manifold structure.
The strong theoretical guarantees and validation through simulations suggest this could be a promising direction for manifold learning in applications like this. Further research is needed to fully understand the practical implications and limitations of the approach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
❗
0
Manifold Fitting under Unbounded Noise
Zhigang Yao, Yuqing Xia
There has been an emerging trend in non-Euclidean statistical analysis of aiming to recover a low dimensional structure, namely a manifold, underlying the high dimensional data. Recovering the manifold requires the noise to be of certain concentration. Existing methods address this problem by constructing an approximated manifold based on the tangent space estimation at each sample point. Although theoretical convergence for these methods is guaranteed, either the samples are noiseless or the noise is bounded. However, if the noise is unbounded, which is a common scenario, the tangent space estimation at the noisy samples will be blurred. Fitting a manifold from the blurred tangent space might increase the inaccuracy. In this paper, we introduce a new manifold-fitting method, by which the output manifold is constructed by directly estimating the tangent spaces at the projected points on the underlying manifold, rather than at the sample points, to decrease the error caused by the noise. Assuming the noise is unbounded, our new method provides theoretical convergence in high probability, in terms of the upper bound of the distance between the estimated and underlying manifold. The smoothness of the estimated manifold is also evaluated by bounding the supremum of twice difference above. Numerical simulations are provided to validate our theoretical findings and demonstrate the advantages of our method over other relevant manifold fitting methods. Finally, our method is applied to real data examples.
Read more6/11/2024
📊
0
Inferring Manifolds From Noisy Data Using Gaussian Processes
David B Dunson, Nan Wu
In analyzing complex datasets, it is often of interest to infer lower dimensional structure underlying the higher dimensional observations. As a flexible class of nonlinear structures, it is common to focus on Riemannian manifolds. Most existing manifold learning algorithms replace the original data with lower dimensional coordinates without providing an estimate of the manifold in the observation space or using the manifold to denoise the original data. This article proposes a new methodology for addressing these problems, allowing interpolation of the estimated manifold between fitted data points. The proposed approach is motivated by novel theoretical properties of local covariance matrices constructed from noisy samples on a manifold. Our results enable us to turn a global manifold reconstruction problem into a local regression problem, allowing application of Gaussian processes for probabilistic manifold reconstruction. In addition to theory justifying the algorithm, we provide simulated and real data examples to illustrate the performance.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Learning on manifolds without manifold learning
H. N. Mhaskar, Ryan O'Dowd
Function approximation based on data drawn randomly from an unknown distribution is an important problem in machine learning. The manifold hypothesis assumes that the data is sampled from an unknown submanifold of a high dimensional Euclidean space. A great deal of research deals with obtaining information about this manifold, such as the eigendecomposition of the Laplace-Beltrami operator or coordinate charts, and using this information for function approximation. This two-step approach implies some extra errors in the approximation stemming from estimating the basic quantities of the data manifold in addition to the errors inherent in function approximation. In this paper, we project the unknown manifold as a submanifold of an ambient hypersphere and study the question of constructing a one-shot approximation using a specially designed sequence of localized spherical polynomial kernels on the hypersphere. Our approach does not require preprocessing of the data to obtain information about the manifold other than its dimension. We give optimal rates of approximation for relatively ``rough'' functions.
Read more8/20/2024
↗️
0
Non-parametric regression for robot learning on manifolds
P. C. Lopez-Custodio, K. Bharath, A. Kucukyilmaz, S. P. Preston
Many of the tools available for robot learning were designed for Euclidean data. However, many applications in robotics involve manifold-valued data. A common example is orientation; this can be represented as a 3-by-3 rotation matrix or a quaternion, the spaces of which are non-Euclidean manifolds. In robot learning, manifold-valued data are often handled by relating the manifold to a suitable Euclidean space, either by embedding the manifold or by projecting the data onto one or several tangent spaces. These approaches can result in poor predictive accuracy, and convoluted algorithms. In this paper, we propose an intrinsic approach to regression that works directly within the manifold. It involves taking a suitable probability distribution on the manifold, letting its parameter be a function of a predictor variable, such as time, then estimating that function non-parametrically via a local likelihood method that incorporates a kernel. We name the method kernelised likelihood estimation. The approach is conceptually simple, and generally applicable to different manifolds. We implement it with three different types of manifold-valued data that commonly appear in robotics applications. The results of these experiments show better predictive accuracy than projection-based algorithms.
Read more5/15/2024