Marginal Fairness Sliced Wasserstein Barycenter

Overview

• The sliced Wasserstein barycenter (SWB) is a widely used method for averaging probability distributions.
• Achieving marginal fairness in SWB, where the barycenter is equidistant from the marginal distributions, has not been explored.
• The uniform weighted SWB may not be the optimal choice for marginal fairness due to the heterogeneous structure of the marginals and non-optimal optimization.
• This paper introduces the marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter (MFSWB) as a constrained SWB problem and proposes three surrogate formulations to address the computational challenges.

Plain English Explanation

The sliced Wasserstein barycenter (SWB) is a method used to average or combine multiple probability distributions, such as images or point clouds. This is a useful technique in areas like computer vision and machine learning.

However, the standard SWB approach does not necessarily ensure that the resulting barycenter (or average) is equidistant from the original distributions. This property, known as "marginal fairness," can be important in applications where fairness and balance are desired.

The researchers in this paper noticed that the typical uniform weighting used in SWB may not be the best way to achieve marginal fairness, as the original distributions can have very different structures. To address this, they defined a new problem called the "marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter" (MFSWB), which explicitly tries to minimize the distances between the barycenter and the individual distributions.

Since the formal definition of MFSWB has some computational challenges, the paper proposes three alternative "surrogate" formulations that are more tractable to optimize. These surrogate problems still aim to encourage marginal fairness, but in slightly different ways. One of the key innovations is the introduction of a new slicing distribution that focuses more on directions where the marginals are unfair.

The paper then explores the relationships between these three surrogate MFSWB problems and discusses their connections to other related concepts in the field, such as the sliced multi-marginal Wasserstein distance.

Technical Explanation

The authors start by defining the marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter (MFSWB) as a constrained optimization problem, where the goal is to find a barycenter distribution that minimizes the sum of the distances to the marginal distributions, while also ensuring that these distances are approximately equal.

However, this formal definition of MFSWB suffers from computational disadvantages. To address this, the paper proposes three surrogate MFSWB formulations that are more tractable to optimize:

1. Surrogate MFSWB I: Introduces a penalty term that encourages marginal fairness, while still minimizing the overall distance to the marginals.
2. Surrogate MFSWB II: Formulates the problem as a min-max optimization, where the goal is to find a barycenter that minimizes the maximum distance to any marginal.
3. Surrogate MFSWB III: Builds upon Surrogate MFSWB II, but introduces a new slicing distribution that focuses more on directions where the marginals are unfair, further improving the efficiency.

The paper explores the relationships between these three surrogate MFSWB problems and discusses their connections to the sliced multi-marginal Wasserstein distance.

Finally, the authors conduct experiments on 3D point cloud averaging, color harmonization, and training of a sliced Wasserstein autoencoder with class-fairness representation. The results demonstrate the favorable performance of the proposed surrogate MFSWB problems compared to the standard SWB approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and interesting problem, the marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter (MFSWB), which aims to address a limitation of the standard sliced Wasserstein barycenter (SWB) method. The authors acknowledge that the formal definition of MFSWB has computational challenges and propose three surrogate formulations to make the problem more tractable.

One potential limitation of the research is that the paper does not provide a detailed theoretical analysis of the properties and relationships between the three surrogate MFSWB problems. While the authors discuss these connections, a more rigorous mathematical treatment could further strengthen the theoretical foundations of the work.

Additionally, the experimental validation, while promising, could be expanded to include a wider range of applications and more comprehensive comparisons to alternative fairness-aware methods. This could help readers better understand the practical advantages and limitations of the proposed MFSWB approach.

Overall, the paper introduces an important problem and presents innovative surrogate formulations to address it. The research could inspire further work on incorporating fairness considerations into Wasserstein-based methods, potentially leading to new applications and advancements in the field.

Conclusion

This paper tackles the problem of achieving marginal fairness in the sliced Wasserstein barycenter (SWB), a widely used method for averaging probability distributions. The authors define the marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter (MFSWB) and propose three surrogate formulations to address the computational challenges of the formal definition.

The surrogate MFSWB problems aim to minimize the distances between the barycenter and the individual marginal distributions, while also encouraging approximate equality of these distances. The paper explores the relationships between the proposed formulations and discusses their connections to related concepts in the field.

Experiments on 3D point cloud averaging, color harmonization, and sliced Wasserstein autoencoder training demonstrate the favorable performance of the surrogate MFSWB problems compared to the standard SWB approach. This research contributes to the growing body of work on incorporating fairness considerations into Wasserstein-based methods, which could lead to new applications and advancements in areas such as computer vision, machine learning, and data analysis.