A Method of Moments Embedding Constraint and its Application to Semi-Supervised Learning

Read original: arXiv:2404.17978 - Published 4/30/2024 by Michael Majurski, Sumeet Menon, Parniyan Farvardin, David Chapman

📶

Overview

Discriminative deep learning models with a linear+softmax final layer have a problem: the latent space only predicts the conditional probabilities p(Y|X) but not the full joint distribution p(Y,X), necessitating a generative approach.
The conditional probability cannot detect outliers, causing outlier sensitivity in softmax networks, which exacerbates model over-confidence impacting many problems.
To address this, the paper introduces a novel embedding constraint based on the Method of Moments (MoM) and uses this to train an Axis-Aligned Gaussian Mixture Model (AAGMM) final layer.

Plain English Explanation

Discriminative deep learning models, like those used for image classification, often use a linear layer followed by a softmax activation to predict the probability of different classes. However, this approach has a significant limitation: it only learns the conditional probability of the classes given the input (p(Y|X)), but not the full joint distribution of the classes and inputs (p(Y,X)). This means the model cannot effectively detect outliers, which can lead to overconfident predictions and issues like hallucinations, biases, and dependence on large datasets.

To address this, the researchers in this paper propose a new technique that incorporates information about the joint distribution of the data. They do this by adding a constraint to the model's embedding layer based on the Method of Moments (MoM), which looks at the statistical moments (or averages) of the data up to the 4th order. This allows the model to learn not just the conditional probabilities, but also the full joint distribution of the data.

The researchers then use this MoM-constrained embedding to train a special type of generative model called an Axis-Aligned Gaussian Mixture Model (AAGMM) as the final layer of the network. This AAGMM layer can model the joint distribution of the data, giving the model the ability to better detect outliers and avoid the issues that come with overconfident softmax-based predictions.

The paper demonstrates this technique in the context of semi-supervised image classification, where it is able to match the performance of a state-of-the-art method while also modeling the joint distribution of the data. The researchers also discuss preliminary strategies for using this joint distribution information for outlier detection.

Technical Explanation

The paper addresses a fundamental limitation of discriminative deep learning models that use a linear layer followed by a softmax activation as the final layer. These models only learn to predict the conditional probability p(Y|X), rather than the full joint distribution p(Y,X). This means they cannot effectively detect outliers, as the conditional probability alone is not sufficient for this task.

To overcome this, the researchers introduce a novel embedding constraint based on the Method of Moments (MoM). They investigate the use of polynomial moments ranging from 1st through 4th order, which are encoded into hyper-covariance matrices. This MoM constraint is then used to train an Axis-Aligned Gaussian Mixture Model (AAGMM) as the final layer of the network.

The AAGMM layer learns not only the conditional distribution, but also the full joint distribution of the latent space. This joint distribution modeling allows the network to better detect outliers, which can help address issues like hallucinations, confounding biases, and dependence on large datasets that are common in overconfident softmax-based predictions.

The paper applies this MoM-constrained AAGMM approach to the domain of semi-supervised image classification, extending the FlexMatch method. The results show that the proposed technique can match the reported FlexMatch accuracy, while also modeling the joint distribution and reducing outlier sensitivity.

The paper also presents a preliminary outlier detection strategy based on Mahalanobis distance, and discusses potential future improvements to this strategy.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and compelling approach to address the limitations of discriminative deep learning models with softmax-based final layers. The introduction of the MoM constraint and the use of the AAGMM layer to model the joint distribution is a promising direction that could have significant implications for improving the robustness and reliability of deep learning systems.

One potential limitation of the approach is the computational complexity and training stability of the AAGMM layer, especially as the number of mixture components or the dimensionality of the latent space increases. The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the scalability of this approach, which could be an area for further research.

Additionally, the paper's focus on semi-supervised image classification may limit the generalization of the findings to other domains and tasks. It would be valuable to see the MoM-constrained AAGMM approach applied to a wider range of problems, such as unsupervised image segmentation or parameter estimation, to better understand its broader applicability and limitations.

The preliminary outlier detection strategy based on Mahalanobis distance is an interesting starting point, but the paper does not provide a comprehensive evaluation of its effectiveness. Further research is needed to develop more robust and reliable outlier detection mechanisms that can leverage the joint distribution modeling capabilities of the AAGMM layer.

Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of deep learning by introducing a novel technique that can address critical limitations of discriminative models. The ideas presented here could inspire further research into generative models and adaptive optimization methods that can enhance the reliability and robustness of deep learning systems.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel approach to address the limitations of discriminative deep learning models with softmax-based final layers. By incorporating a Method of Moments (MoM) constraint into the model's embedding layer and using an Axis-Aligned Gaussian Mixture Model (AAGMM) as the final layer, the researchers are able to model the full joint distribution of the data, rather than just the conditional probabilities.

This joint distribution modeling allows the model to better detect outliers and address issues like hallucinations, confounding biases, and dependence on large datasets that are common in overconfident softmax-based predictions. The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach in the context of semi-supervised image classification, and also presents a preliminary outlier detection strategy based on Mahalanobis distance.

The ideas introduced in this paper have the potential to significantly improve the robustness and reliability of deep learning systems, and could inspire further research into generative models, adaptive optimization methods, and other techniques that can enhance the performance and trustworthiness of AI-powered applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📶

A Method of Moments Embedding Constraint and its Application to Semi-Supervised Learning

Michael Majurski, Sumeet Menon, Parniyan Farvardin, David Chapman

Discriminative deep learning models with a linear+softmax final layer have a problem: the latent space only predicts the conditional probabilities $p(Y|X)$ but not the full joint distribution $p(Y,X)$, which necessitates a generative approach. The conditional probability cannot detect outliers, causing outlier sensitivity in softmax networks. This exacerbates model over-confidence impacting many problems, such as hallucinations, confounding biases, and dependence on large datasets. To address this we introduce a novel embedding constraint based on the Method of Moments (MoM). We investigate the use of polynomial moments ranging from 1st through 4th order hyper-covariance matrices. Furthermore, we use this embedding constraint to train an Axis-Aligned Gaussian Mixture Model (AAGMM) final layer, which learns not only the conditional, but also the joint distribution of the latent space. We apply this method to the domain of semi-supervised image classification by extending FlexMatch with our technique. We find our MoM constraint with the AAGMM layer is able to match the reported FlexMatch accuracy, while also modeling the joint distribution, thereby reducing outlier sensitivity. We also present a preliminary outlier detection strategy based on Mahalanobis distance and discuss future improvements to this strategy. Code is available at: url{https://github.com/mmajurski/ssl-gmm}

4/30/2024

📊

Sketchy Moment Matching: Toward Fast and Provable Data Selection for Finetuning

Yijun Dong, Hoang Phan, Xiang Pan, Qi Lei

We revisit data selection in a modern context of finetuning from a fundamental perspective. Extending the classical wisdom of variance minimization in low dimensions to high-dimensional finetuning, our generalization analysis unveils the importance of additionally reducing bias induced by low-rank approximation. Inspired by the variance-bias tradeoff in high dimensions from the theory, we introduce Sketchy Moment Matching (SkMM), a scalable data selection scheme with two stages. (i) First, the bias is controlled using gradient sketching that explores the finetuning parameter space for an informative low-dimensional subspace $mathcal{S}$; (ii) then the variance is reduced over $mathcal{S}$ via moment matching between the original and selected datasets. Theoretically, we show that gradient sketching is fast and provably accurate: selecting $n$ samples by reducing variance over $mathcal{S}$ preserves the fast-rate generalization $O(dim(mathcal{S})/n)$, independent of the parameter dimension. Empirically, we concretize the variance-bias balance via synthetic experiments and demonstrate the effectiveness of SkMM for finetuning in real vision tasks.

7/9/2024

Conjugate-Gradient-like Based Adaptive Moment Estimation Optimization Algorithm for Deep Learning

Jiawu Tian, Liwei Xu, Xiaowei Zhang, Yongqi Li

Training deep neural networks is a challenging task. In order to speed up training and enhance the performance of deep neural networks, we rectify the vanilla conjugate gradient as conjugate-gradient-like and incorporate it into the generic Adam, and thus propose a new optimization algorithm named CG-like-Adam for deep learning. Specifically, both the first-order and the second-order moment estimation of generic Adam are replaced by the conjugate-gradient-like. Convergence analysis handles the cases where the exponential moving average coefficient of the first-order moment estimation is constant and the first-order moment estimation is unbiased. Numerical experiments show the superiority of the proposed algorithm based on the CIFAR10/100 dataset.

5/14/2024

🔍

Learning multi-modal generative models with permutation-invariant encoders and tighter variational bounds

Marcel Hirt, Domenico Campolo, Victoria Leong, Juan-Pablo Ortega

Devising deep latent variable models for multi-modal data has been a long-standing theme in machine learning research. Multi-modal Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) have been a popular generative model class that learns latent representations that jointly explain multiple modalities. Various objective functions for such models have been suggested, often motivated as lower bounds on the multi-modal data log-likelihood or from information-theoretic considerations. To encode latent variables from different modality subsets, Product-of-Experts (PoE) or Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) aggregation schemes have been routinely used and shown to yield different trade-offs, for instance, regarding their generative quality or consistency across multiple modalities. In this work, we consider a variational bound that can tightly approximate the data log-likelihood. We develop more flexible aggregation schemes that generalize PoE or MoE approaches by combining encoded features from different modalities based on permutation-invariant neural networks. Our numerical experiments illustrate trade-offs for multi-modal variational bounds and various aggregation schemes. We show that tighter variational bounds and more flexible aggregation models can become beneficial when one wants to approximate the true joint distribution over observed modalities and latent variables in identifiable models.

4/22/2024