A Metric Hybrid Planning Approach to Solving Pandemic Planning Problems with Simple SIR Models

Read original: arXiv:2409.11631 - Published 9/19/2024 by Ari Gestetner, Buser Say
Total Score

0

A Metric Hybrid Planning Approach to Solving Pandemic Planning Problems with Simple SIR Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Introduces a metric hybrid planning approach to solve pandemic planning problems using simple SIR (Susceptible-Infected-Recovered) models
  • Combines the strengths of different planning techniques to address the complexities of pandemic management

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new way to tackle the challenges of planning for pandemics. It combines different planning methods, called a "metric hybrid planning approach," to find the best strategies for managing the spread of a disease like COVID-19.

The researchers used simple SIR models to simulate the progress of a pandemic. These models track how many people are susceptible, infected, and recovered over time. The researchers then applied their hybrid planning approach to find the most effective interventions, such as lockdowns or vaccine rollouts, to control the outbreak.

The key idea is to leverage the strengths of various planning techniques, like optimization and heuristic search, to navigate the complex trade-offs involved in pandemic management. This allows the approach to identify strategies that balance factors like reducing infections, minimizing economic disruption, and protecting vulnerable populations.

Technical Explanation

The paper describes a metric hybrid planning approach that combines optimization and heuristic search to address pandemic planning problems. The researchers use simple SIR models to simulate the progression of a disease outbreak and then apply their hybrid planning method to find effective intervention strategies.

The optimization component of the approach seeks to minimize a weighted combination of infections, economic impact, and other relevant metrics. The heuristic search component leverages domain knowledge to efficiently explore the space of possible interventions, such as lockdowns, vaccine rollouts, and testing policies.

By integrating these complementary planning techniques, the researchers are able to tackle the complexities of pandemic management, which often involve competing objectives and constraints. The hybrid approach can identify strategies that balance the trade-offs between public health, economic considerations, and other factors.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to pandemic planning, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the simple SIR models used in the study may not fully capture the nuances of real-world disease dynamics, and the researchers suggest exploring more sophisticated epidemiological models in future work.

Additionally, the paper notes that the effectiveness of the hybrid planning approach may depend on the specific objectives and constraints defined in the problem formulation. Careful consideration of these factors is crucial for obtaining meaningful and actionable insights.

Further research could also explore the scalability of the approach, as well as its applicability to different types of pandemics or other complex planning problems. Validating the approach with real-world data and simulations would also help to assess its practical utility.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a metric hybrid planning approach that combines optimization and heuristic search techniques to address the challenges of pandemic planning. By leveraging the strengths of these complementary methods, the approach can identify intervention strategies that balance multiple, often competing objectives, such as reducing infections, minimizing economic impact, and protecting vulnerable populations.

While the study has some limitations, it represents a valuable contribution to the field of pandemic management and decision-making. As the world continues to grapple with the complexities of public health crises, innovative planning approaches like the one presented in this paper could play a crucial role in informing more effective and holistic pandemic response strategies.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Metric Hybrid Planning Approach to Solving Pandemic Planning Problems with Simple SIR Models
Total Score

0

New!A Metric Hybrid Planning Approach to Solving Pandemic Planning Problems with Simple SIR Models

Ari Gestetner, Buser Say

A pandemic is the spread of a disease across large regions, and can have devastating costs to the society in terms of health, economic and social. As such, the study of effective pandemic mitigation strategies can yield significant positive impact on the society. A pandemic can be mathematically described using a compartmental model, such as the Susceptible Infected Removed (SIR) model. In this paper, we extend the solution equations of the SIR model to a state transition model with lockdowns. We formalize a metric hybrid planning problem based on this state transition model, and solve it using a metric hybrid planner. We improve the runtime effectiveness of the metric hybrid planner with the addition of valid inequalities, and demonstrate the success of our approach both theoretically and experimentally under various challenging settings.

Read more

9/19/2024

Evaluating Supply Chain Resilience During Pandemic Using Agent-based Simulation
Total Score

0

Evaluating Supply Chain Resilience During Pandemic Using Agent-based Simulation

Teddy Lazebnik

Recent pandemics have highlighted vulnerabilities in our global economic systems, especially supply chains. Possible future pandemic raises a dilemma for businesses owners between short-term profitability and long-term supply chain resilience planning. In this study, we propose a novel agent-based simulation model integrating extended Susceptible-Infected-Recovered (SIR) epidemiological model and supply and demand economic model to evaluate supply chain resilience strategies during pandemics. Using this model, we explore a range of supply chain resilience strategies under pandemic scenarios using in silico experiments. We find that a balanced approach to supply chain resilience performs better in both pandemic and non-pandemic times compared to extreme strategies, highlighting the importance of preparedness in the form of a better supply chain resilience. However, our analysis shows that the exact supply chain resilience strategy is hard to obtain for each firm and is relatively sensitive to the exact profile of the pandemic and economic state at the beginning of the pandemic. As such, we used a machine learning model that uses the agent-based simulation to estimate a near-optimal supply chain resilience strategy for a firm. The proposed model offers insights for policymakers and businesses to enhance supply chain resilience in the face of future pandemics, contributing to understanding the trade-offs between short-term gains and long-term sustainability in supply chain management before and during pandemics.

Read more

6/18/2024

SIR-RL: Reinforcement Learning for Optimized Policy Control during Epidemiological Outbreaks in Emerging Market and Developing Economies
Total Score

0

SIR-RL: Reinforcement Learning for Optimized Policy Control during Epidemiological Outbreaks in Emerging Market and Developing Economies

Maeghal Jain, Ziya Uddin, Wubshet Ibrahim

The outbreak of COVID-19 has highlighted the intricate interplay between public health and economic stability on a global scale. This study proposes a novel reinforcement learning framework designed to optimize health and economic outcomes during pandemics. The framework leverages the SIR model, integrating both lockdown measures (via a stringency index) and vaccination strategies to simulate disease dynamics. The stringency index, indicative of the severity of lockdown measures, influences both the spread of the disease and the economic health of a country. Developing nations, which bear a disproportionate economic burden under stringent lockdowns, are the primary focus of our study. By implementing reinforcement learning, we aim to optimize governmental responses and strike a balance between the competing costs associated with public health and economic stability. This approach also enhances transparency in governmental decision-making by establishing a well-defined reward function for the reinforcement learning agent. In essence, this study introduces an innovative and ethical strategy to navigate the challenge of balancing public health and economic stability amidst infectious disease outbreaks.

Read more

5/1/2024

PANDORA: Deep graph learning based COVID-19 infection risk level forecasting
Total Score

0

PANDORA: Deep graph learning based COVID-19 infection risk level forecasting

Shuo Yu, Feng Xia, Yueru Wang, Shihao Li, Falih Febrinanto, Madhu Chetty

COVID-19 as a global pandemic causes a massive disruption to social stability that threatens human life and the economy. Policymakers and all elements of society must deliver measurable actions based on the pandemic's severity to minimize the detrimental impact of COVID-19. A proper forecasting system is arguably important to provide an early signal of the risk of COVID-19 infection so that the authorities are ready to protect the people from the worst. However, making a good forecasting model for infection risks in different cities or regions is not an easy task, because it has a lot of influential factors that are difficult to be identified manually. To address the current limitations, we propose a deep graph learning model, called PANDORA, to predict the infection risks of COVID-19, by considering all essential factors and integrating them into a geographical network. The framework uses geographical position relations and transportation frequency as higher-order structural properties formulated by higher-order network structures (i.e., network motifs). Moreover, four significant node attributes (i.e., multiple features of a particular area, including climate, medical condition, economy, and human mobility) are also considered. We propose three different aggregators to better aggregate node attributes and structural features, namely, Hadamard, Summation, and Connection. Experimental results over real data show that PANDORA outperforms the baseline method with higher accuracy and faster convergence speed, no matter which aggregator is chosen. We believe that PANDORA using deep graph learning provides a promising approach to get superior performance in infection risk level forecasting and help humans battle the COVID-19 crisis.

Read more

6/12/2024