Modelling Global Trade with Optimal Transport

Read original: arXiv:2409.06554 - Published 9/11/2024 by Thomas Gaskin, Marie-Therese Wolfram, Andrew Duncan, Guven Demirel
Total Score

0

Modelling Global Trade with Optimal Transport

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a new model for understanding global trade using optimal transport theory.
  • The model aims to capture the complex dynamics of international trade flows and provide insights into the global economic system.
  • Key results include a novel approach to modeling trade costs, predictions of trade patterns, and implications for economic policy.

Plain English Explanation

The paper introduces a new way to model global trade using a mathematical framework called optimal transport theory. Optimal transport theory is a powerful tool for understanding how resources are distributed between different locations.

In the context of global trade, the model treats countries as locations that exchange goods and services. The goal is to understand the complex patterns of trade that emerge from the interactions between countries, taking into account factors like transportation costs, tariffs, and other trade barriers.

By using optimal transport theory, the researchers were able to make predictions about trade flows that aligned well with real-world data. This suggests that the model could be a valuable tool for economic forecasting and policy analysis.

The model also provides a new way to think about the "cost" of trade, which goes beyond just monetary factors. By incorporating more general cost functions, the researchers were able to capture other important considerations, such as environmental impact or social factors.

Overall, this work represents an important step forward in our understanding of the global economy and the complex dynamics that shape international trade.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new framework for modeling global trade using optimal transport theory. Optimal transport is a mathematical concept that describes the optimal way to move resources from one location to another, taking into account various costs or constraints.

In the context of trade, the model treats countries as locations that exchange goods and services. The goal is to find the optimal allocation of trade flows between countries, given factors like transportation costs, tariffs, and other trade barriers.

To achieve this, the researchers formulate the trade problem as an optimal transport problem, with countries as the locations and trade flows as the resources being transported. They introduce a novel way to define the trade cost function, which goes beyond just monetary factors and can incorporate other considerations like environmental impact or social factors.

By solving this optimal transport problem, the model is able to make predictions about trade patterns that align well with real-world data. The researchers also use the model to explore the implications of different trade policies, such as tariffs or subsidies, and how they might affect the global economy.

One key insight from the model is that trade costs can have a significant impact on the overall structure of the global trade network. Small changes in trade costs can lead to large shifts in trade patterns, highlighting the importance of understanding and managing these costs.

The paper also demonstrates how optimal transport theory can be a powerful tool for economic modeling and policy analysis, providing a new way to think about the complexities of the global economy.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling and innovative approach to modeling global trade using optimal transport theory. The researchers have developed a flexible framework that can incorporate a wide range of factors beyond just monetary costs, which is a strength of the model.

However, it's important to note that the model is still a simplification of the real-world global economy, and there may be additional factors or dynamics that are not fully captured. For example, the model does not explicitly consider the role of multinational corporations, global value chains, or the political and geopolitical considerations that can shape trade flows.

Furthermore, the paper acknowledges that the optimal transport formulation may not be able to fully capture the strategic interactions and bargaining that can occur in international trade negotiations. There may be a need for complementary approaches or further refinements to the model to address these limitations.

Despite these caveats, the paper represents an important contribution to the field of economic modeling and policy analysis. The insights from this work could have significant implications for how we understand and manage the global economy, particularly in the face of evolving challenges like climate change, technological disruption, and geopolitical tensions.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel approach to modeling global trade using optimal transport theory. The model provides a flexible and powerful framework for understanding the complex dynamics of international trade flows, with the potential to inform economic policymaking and contribute to our broader understanding of the global economy.

The key strengths of the model include its ability to incorporate a wide range of cost factors beyond just monetary considerations, as well as its capacity to make predictions that align with real-world data. While the model has some limitations, the insights it provides could be valuable for policymakers, researchers, and others working to address the challenges and opportunities of the global economic system.

Overall, this work represents an important step forward in the application of advanced mathematical and computational techniques to the study of international trade and the global economy.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Modelling Global Trade with Optimal Transport
Total Score

0

Modelling Global Trade with Optimal Transport

Thomas Gaskin, Marie-Therese Wolfram, Andrew Duncan, Guven Demirel

Global trade is shaped by a complex mix of factors beyond supply and demand, including tangible variables like transport costs and tariffs, as well as less quantifiable influences such as political and economic relations. Traditionally, economists model trade using gravity models, which rely on explicit covariates but often struggle to capture these subtler drivers of trade. In this work, we employ optimal transport and a deep neural network to learn a time-dependent cost function from data, without imposing a specific functional form. This approach consistently outperforms traditional gravity models in accuracy while providing natural uncertainty quantification. Applying our framework to global food and agricultural trade, we show that the global South suffered disproportionately from the war in Ukraine's impact on wheat markets. We also analyze the effects of free-trade agreements and trade disputes with China, as well as Brexit's impact on British trade with Europe, uncovering hidden patterns that trade volumes alone cannot reveal.

Read more

9/11/2024

Optimal Trade and Industrial Policies in the Global Economy: A Deep Learning Framework
Total Score

0

Optimal Trade and Industrial Policies in the Global Economy: A Deep Learning Framework

Zi Wang, Xingcheng Xu, Yanqing Yang, Xiaodong Zhu

We propose a deep learning framework, DL-opt, designed to efficiently solve for optimal policies in quantifiable general equilibrium trade models. DL-opt integrates (i) a nested fixed point (NFXP) formulation of the optimization problem, (ii) automatic implicit differentiation to enhance gradient descent for solving unilateral optimal policies, and (iii) a best-response dynamics approach for finding Nash equilibria. Utilizing DL-opt, we solve for non-cooperative tariffs and industrial subsidies across 7 economies and 44 sectors, incorporating sectoral external economies of scale. Our quantitative analysis reveals significant sectoral heterogeneity in Nash policies: Nash industrial subsidies increase with scale elasticities, whereas Nash tariffs decrease with trade elasticities. Moreover, we show that global dual competition, involving both tariffs and industrial subsidies, results in lower tariffs and higher welfare outcomes compared to a global tariff war. These findings highlight the importance of considering sectoral heterogeneity and policy combinations in understanding global economic competition.

Read more

7/26/2024

Recent Advances in Optimal Transport for Machine Learning
Total Score

0

Recent Advances in Optimal Transport for Machine Learning

Eduardo Fernandes Montesuma, Fred Ngol`e Mboula, Antoine Souloumiac

Recently, Optimal Transport has been proposed as a probabilistic framework in Machine Learning for comparing and manipulating probability distributions. This is rooted in its rich history and theory, and has offered new solutions to different problems in machine learning, such as generative modeling and transfer learning. In this survey we explore contributions of Optimal Transport for Machine Learning over the period 2012 -- 2023, focusing on four sub-fields of Machine Learning: supervised, unsupervised, transfer and reinforcement learning. We further highlight the recent development in computational Optimal Transport and its extensions, such as partial, unbalanced, Gromov and Neural Optimal Transport, and its interplay with Machine Learning practice.

Read more

8/22/2024

Machine learning and economic forecasting: the role of international trade networks
Total Score

0

Machine learning and economic forecasting: the role of international trade networks

Thiago C. Silva, Paulo V. B. Wilhelm, Diego R. Amancio

This study examines the effects of de-globalization trends on international trade networks and their role in improving forecasts for economic growth. Using section-level trade data from nearly 200 countries from 2010 to 2022, we identify significant shifts in the network topology driven by rising trade policy uncertainty. Our analysis highlights key global players through centrality rankings, with the United States, China, and Germany maintaining consistent dominance. Using a horse race of supervised regressors, we find that network topology descriptors evaluated from section-specific trade networks substantially enhance the quality of a country's GDP growth forecast. We also find that non-linear models, such as Random Forest, XGBoost, and LightGBM, outperform traditional linear models used in the economics literature. Using SHAP values to interpret these non-linear model's predictions, we find that about half of most important features originate from the network descriptors, underscoring their vital role in refining forecasts. Moreover, this study emphasizes the significance of recent economic performance, population growth, and the primary sector's influence in shaping economic growth predictions, offering novel insights into the intricacies of economic growth forecasting.

Read more

4/16/2024