Multi-Objective Genetic Algorithm for Materialized View Optimization in Data Warehouses
2403.19906
0
0
🔍
Abstract
Materialized views can significantly improve database query performance but identifying the optimal set of views to materialize is challenging. Prior work on automating and optimizing materialized view selection has limitations in execution time and total cost. In this paper, we present a novel genetic algorithm based approach to materialized view selection that aims to minimize execution time and total cost. Our technique encodes materialized view configurations as chromosomes and evolves the population over generations to discover high quality solutions. We employ an adaptive mutation rate, multi-objective fitness function, and lexicase selection to enhance genetic search. Comprehensive experiments on the TPC-H benchmark demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithm. Compared to stateof-the-art methods, our approach improves average execution time by 11% and reduces total materialized view costs by an average of 16 million. These gains highlight the benefits of a datadriven evolutionary approach. Our genetic algorithm framework significantly outperforms current materialized view selection techniques in both efficiency and total cost reduction. This work represents an important advance in enabling performant and cost-effective utilization of materialized views in enterprise systems.
Create account to get full access
Introduction
The paper discusses materialized views, which are database objects that store pre-computed query results to improve performance in data warehouses. Materialized views enhance data retrieval speeds by caching expensive query outputs, reducing computational burdens in large-scale data operations. However, maintaining the currency of materialized views as data evolves is a key challenge, requiring periodic refreshes that introduce overhead.
The selection of an optimal set of materialized views is a complex optimization problem, shown to be NP-hard. Common approaches include greedy algorithms, genetic algorithms, and colony optimization techniques. Greedy algorithms are prone to getting stuck in local optima, while colony optimization algorithms converge slowly on large problems.
In contrast, genetic algorithms provide an effective metaheuristic search technique to navigate large and complex solution spaces, offering faster convergence than colony algorithms in finding globally optimal materialized view selections.
The paper proposes enhancements to genetic algorithms by incorporating adaptive selection operators and multi-objective composite fitness functions to improve performance and avoid local optima pitfalls. A comprehensive performance evaluation is conducted using the TPC-H benchmark dataset.
The paper is structured into five sections, covering related work, the proposed approach, experimental evaluation, and conclusions, with promising areas for further research identified.
Related Work
The text discusses recent studies that have developed innovative techniques using bio-inspired algorithms to enhance the utilization of materialized views in data warehousing scenarios. These techniques aim to optimize the selection and management of materialized views to improve query performance and reduce costs.
Several studies are mentioned, each proposing a different approach based on nature-inspired algorithms such as cuckoo search, monarch butterfly optimization, bees algorithm, genetic algorithms, Ebola optimization, coot optimization, and coral reefs optimization. These algorithms are used to intelligently select and manage materialized views, considering factors such as query workloads, infrastructure constraints, maintenance costs, and storage requirements.
The studies demonstrate the potential of these AI-based metaheuristic procedures to overcome limitations of greedy constructive heuristics, such as getting trapped in local optima. The adaptive and explorative nature of these techniques helps in finding better-quality materialized view configurations that harmonize performance and infrastructure requirements.
Experimental results from the studies show improvements over state-of-the-art techniques, with reductions in costs, query response times, and better coverage of materialized views. However, some studies mention slightly higher computational complexity and execution times as limitations, especially for larger dataset sizes.
Overall, the text highlights the promise of nature-inspired techniques for addressing various challenges related to materialized views in data warehousing environments, and their potential to become integral for next-generation data platforms as data complexity increases.
Proposed Approach
The paper proposes an automated approach to select an optimal set of materialized views that maximize database performance while satisfying given constraints. Key components include:
A view selection algorithm that analyzes query workloads and recommends candidate views based on response time, maintenance cost, and memory usage.
Constraint analysis to ensure recommended view sets meet user-specified limits like total storage space or maximum query response times.
The algorithm explores the large space of possible materialized view configurations using a genetic algorithm (GA) approach.
Candidate views are encoded as bits in a binary string, enabling efficient crossover and mutation operations.
The initial GA population is seeded with promising view sets identified through a pilot study of random configurations.
Lexicase selection is used to maintain population diversity by selecting parents based on performance on individual test queries.
Localized multi-parent crossover reduces computational overhead by only blending genes that differ between parents.
A customizable multi-objective fitness function combines response time, maintenance cost, and memory usage objectives through tunable weights and shaping functions.
An adaptive mutation rate dynamically adjusts to maintain appropriate population diversity throughout evolution.
The proposed automated view selection system aims to significantly improve query speeds and reduce evaluation costs compared to manual approaches.
V Evaluation
The provided text focuses on evaluating the efficiency and effectiveness of the proposed approach for selecting materialized views using the TPC-H benchmark dataset. The TPC-H dataset is designed to simulate the workload of a retail product supplier's decision support system and includes 22 complex SQL queries representing various business analysis tasks.
The results section presents several key findings:
-
A figure illustrating the convergence of the genetic algorithm towards optimal solutions, with an initial period of rapid optimization followed by a more exploratory phase to avoid local optima.
-
A comparison of the proposed approach's computation time against three prior algorithms, demonstrating a significant reduction in runtime (10-13% faster) due to the multi-objective fitness function and adaptive mutation operator.
-
An analysis of the maintenance costs, showing that the proposed approach achieves the lowest cost, nearly 1 million less than the previous best method.
-
A comparison of the total costs, revealing that the proposed approach has the lowest overall cost, over 2 million lower than the previous best method and over 30 million less than another approach.
The text highlights the proposed genetic algorithm's ability to optimize materialized view selection for both query performance and long-term overhead, making it a state-of-the-art solution for automated materialized view selection in large real-world database workloads.
Conclusion
The paper presents a genetic algorithm approach to automate and optimize the selection of materialized views for database workloads. The algorithm combines an intelligent initial population generation strategy with specialized operators and multi-objective fitness functions to effectively search the space of possible materialized view configurations.
Key contributions include:
- A binary encoding scheme representing potential materialized views as genes, enabling the application of standard genetic operators.
- Novel parent selection methods like Lexicase selection to maintain diversity and avoid premature convergence to local optima.
- Custom crossover techniques, including multi-parent blend crossover, to strike a balance between exploration and exploitation.
- An adaptive mutation rate that self-tunes variation based on population diversity measurements, preventing stagnation.
- A customizable multi-objective fitness formulation that allows flexibly prioritizing performance, maintenance costs, and storage constraints.
Comprehensive experiments on the TPC-H benchmark dataset demonstrate that the genetic algorithm consistently finds optimal or near-optimal materialized view sets that maximize performance under the specified constraints. It outperforms current manual selection approaches and existing automated techniques by an average of 15-20% on key metrics, including query response time, storage overhead, and total cost.
The work provides an effective data-driven methodology for materialized view selection that requires minimal manual tuning. The genetic algorithm-based framework can be applied to a wide range of database configurations and workloads, making optimized materialized view usage more accessible and enabling significant performance improvements in enterprise database and analytics systems.
Future work involves exploring predictive and prescriptive analytics to recommend beneficial views based on query trends and patterns. Additionally, the fitness function and operators could be evolved dynamically at runtime to adapt to changing workloads.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Analyzing and Overcoming Local Optima in Complex Multi-Objective Optimization by Decomposition-Based Evolutionary Algorithms
Ting Dong, Haoxin Wang, Hengxi Zhang, Wenbo Ding
0
0
When addressing the challenge of complex multi-objective optimization problems, particularly those with non-convex and non-uniform Pareto fronts, Decomposition-based Multi-Objective Evolutionary Algorithms (MOEADs) often converge to local optima, thereby limiting solution diversity. Despite its significance, this issue has received limited theoretical exploration. Through a comprehensive geometric analysis, we identify that the traditional method of Reference Point (RP) selection fundamentally contributes to this challenge. In response, we introduce an innovative RP selection strategy, the Weight Vector-Guided and Gaussian-Hybrid method, designed to overcome the local optima issue. This approach employs a novel RP type that aligns with weight vector directions and integrates a Gaussian distribution to combine three distinct RP categories. Our research comprises two main experimental components: an ablation study involving 14 algorithms within the MOEADs framework, spanning from 2014 to 2022, to validate our theoretical framework, and a series of empirical tests to evaluate the effectiveness of our proposed method against both traditional and cutting-edge alternatives. Results demonstrate that our method achieves remarkable improvements in both population diversity and convergence.
4/15/2024
🔍
Fast Genetic Algorithm for feature selection -- A qualitative approximation approach
Mohammed Ghaith Altarabichi, S{l}awomir Nowaczyk, Sepideh Pashami, Peyman Sheikholharam Mashhadi
0
0
Evolutionary Algorithms (EAs) are often challenging to apply in real-world settings since evolutionary computations involve a large number of evaluations of a typically expensive fitness function. For example, an evaluation could involve training a new machine learning model. An approximation (also known as meta-model or a surrogate) of the true function can be used in such applications to alleviate the computation cost. In this paper, we propose a two-stage surrogate-assisted evolutionary approach to address the computational issues arising from using Genetic Algorithm (GA) for feature selection in a wrapper setting for large datasets. We define 'Approximation Usefulness' to capture the necessary conditions to ensure correctness of the EA computations when an approximation is used. Based on this definition, we propose a procedure to construct a lightweight qualitative meta-model by the active selection of data instances. We then use a meta-model to carry out the feature selection task. We apply this procedure to the GA-based algorithm CHC (Cross generational elitist selection, Heterogeneous recombination and Cataclysmic mutation) to create a Qualitative approXimations variant, CHCQX. We show that CHCQX converges faster to feature subset solutions of significantly higher accuracy (as compared to CHC), particularly for large datasets with over 100K instances. We also demonstrate the applicability of the thinking behind our approach more broadly to Swarm Intelligence (SI), another branch of the Evolutionary Computation (EC) paradigm with results of PSOQX, a qualitative approximation adaptation of the Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) method. A GitHub repository with the complete implementation is available.
4/8/2024
Multi-Objective Evolutionary Algorithms with Sliding Window Selection for the Dynamic Chance-Constrained Knapsack Problem
Kokila Kasuni Perera, Aneta Neumann
0
0
Evolutionary algorithms are particularly effective for optimisation problems with dynamic and stochastic components. We propose multi-objective evolutionary approaches for the knapsack problem with stochastic profits under static and dynamic weight constraints. The chance-constrained problem model allows us to effectively capture the stochastic profits and associate a confidence level to the solutions' profits. We consider a bi-objective formulation that maximises expected profit and minimises variance, which allows optimising the problem independent of a specific confidence level on the profit. We derive a three-objective formulation by relaxing the weight constraint into an additional objective. We consider the GSEMO algorithm with standard and a sliding window-based parent selection to evaluate the objective formulations. Moreover, we modify fitness formulations and algorithms for the dynamic problem variant to store some infeasible solutions to cater to future changes. We conduct experimental investigations on both problems using the proposed problem formulations and algorithms. Our results show that three-objective approaches outperform approaches that use bi-objective formulations, and they further improve when GSEMO uses sliding window selection.
4/15/2024
📊
A Survey of Decomposition-Based Evolutionary Multi-Objective Optimization: Part II -- A Data Science Perspective
Mingyu Huang, Ke Li
0
0
This paper presents the second part of the two-part survey series on decomposition-based evolutionary multi-objective optimization where we mainly focus on discussing the literature related to multi-objective evolutionary algorithms based on decomposition (MOEA/D). Complementary to the first part, here we employ a series of advanced data mining approaches to provide a comprehensive anatomy of the enormous landscape of MOEA/D research, which is far beyond the capacity of classic manual literature review protocol. In doing so, we construct a heterogeneous knowledge graph that encapsulates more than 5,400 papers, 10,000 authors, 400 venues, and 1,600 institutions for MOEA/D research. We start our analysis with basic descriptive statistics. Then we delve into prominent research/application topics pertaining to MOEA/D with state-of-the-art topic modeling techniques and interrogate their sptial-temporal and bilateral relationships. We also explored the collaboration and citation networks of MOEA/D, uncovering hidden patterns in the growth of literature as well as collaboration between researchers. Our data mining results here, combined with the expert review in Part I, together offer a holistic view of the MOEA/D research, and demonstrate the potential of an exciting new paradigm for conducting scientific surveys from a data science perspective.
4/23/2024