MVMR: A New Framework for Evaluating Faithfulness of Video Moment Retrieval against Multiple Distractors

Overview

• The paper proposes a new task called Massive Videos Moment Retrieval (MVMR) to evaluate the faithfulness of video moment retrieval (VMR) models.
• The MVMR task requires models to retrieve relevant video moments from a large pool of videos, including distractors, to assess whether the models are truly recognizing the correct moments.
• The authors introduce an automated framework to construct MVMR datasets by categorizing negative (distractors) and positive (false-negative) video sets using textual and visual semantic distance verification methods.
• They also propose a new model called CroCs, which uses two contrastive learning mechanisms to improve performance on the MVMR task.

Plain English Explanation

With the growing amount of video content online, the task of Video Moment Retrieval (VMR) has become increasingly important. VMR aims to find the video moment that best matches a given text query. However, the existing VMR evaluation framework may not reveal whether the models are truly recognizing the correct moments or are being misled by distracting videos.

To address this, the researchers propose a new task called Massive Videos Moment Retrieval (MVMR). In MVMR, the models must retrieve relevant video moments from a large pool of videos, including many distractors. This allows the researchers to assess the faithfulness of the VMR models - whether they can distinguish the true relevant moments from misleading distractors.

The authors develop an automated framework to create MVMR datasets by categorizing negative (distractors) and positive (false-negative) video sets using textual and visual semantic distance verification methods. They then extend existing VMR datasets using this approach and create three new MVMR datasets.

To solve the MVMR task, the researchers propose a new model called CroCs, which uses two contrastive learning mechanisms: weakly-supervised potential negative learning and cross-directional hard-negative learning. These techniques help the model better distinguish the true relevant moments from distractors.

The experiments show that existing VMR models are easily distracted by misinformation (distractors), while CroCs demonstrates significantly more robust performance on the MVMR task. This suggests that contrastive learning approaches like those used in CroCs are essential for VMR models to accurately identify the correct video moments.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the Massive Videos Moment Retrieval (MVMR) task, which aims to evaluate the faithfulness of video moment retrieval (VMR) models. In the MVMR task, models must retrieve relevant video moments from a large pool of videos, including many distractors, rather than a single given video.

To create MVMR datasets, the authors propose an automated framework that categorizes negative (distractors) and positive (false-negative) video sets using textual and visual semantic distance verification methods. They extend existing VMR datasets using this approach and construct three new MVMR datasets.

To address the MVMR task, the researchers propose a model called CroCs, which employs two contrastive learning mechanisms:

1. Weakly-supervised Potential Negative Learning: CroCs learns to distinguish true relevant moments from potential negatives (distractors) by leveraging weak supervision from the text query.

2. Cross-directional Hard-negative Learning: CroCs also learns to differentiate true relevant moments from hard negatives (visually similar distractors) using a cross-directional contrastive loss.

The experimental results on the MVMR datasets show that existing VMR models are easily distracted by misinformation (distractors), while CroCs demonstrates significantly more robust performance. This suggests that the contrastive learning approaches used in CroCs are crucial for VMR models to accurately identify the correct video moments in the presence of distractors.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents an important step forward in evaluating the faithfulness of VMR models by introducing the MVMR task and dataset construction framework. The use of textual and visual semantic distance verification methods to categorize negative and positive video sets is a thoughtful approach to create realistic and challenging MVMR datasets.

One potential limitation is that the MVMR datasets are still relatively small (the largest contains around 50,000 videos), and scaling to truly massive video pools may require further advancements in the dataset construction process. Additionally, the authors do not discuss potential biases or artifacts in the MVMR datasets, which could influence the generalization of the proposed CroCs model.

Further research could explore the applicability of the MVMR task and CroCs model to other video understanding tasks, such as video question answering or video captioning, where faithfulness and robustness to distractors are also crucial. Investigating the transferability of the contrastive learning techniques used in CroCs to these related domains could lead to more reliable and trustworthy video understanding systems.

Conclusion

The paper proposes the Massive Videos Moment Retrieval (MVMR) task to evaluate the faithfulness of video moment retrieval (VMR) models, addressing a key limitation of existing VMR evaluation frameworks. The authors introduce an automated dataset construction process and a new model called CroCs, which uses contrastive learning techniques to improve performance on the MVMR task.

The experimental results demonstrate that existing VMR models are easily distracted by misinformation (distractors), while CroCs shows significantly more robust performance. This suggests that contrastive learning approaches like those used in CroCs are essential for VMR models to accurately identify the correct video moments, even in the presence of a large number of distractors.

The MVMR task and the CroCs model represent important advances in the field of video understanding, paving the way for the development of more faithful and trustworthy video retrieval and analysis systems that can reliably operate in real-world, noisy environments.