NeFL: Nested Model Scaling for Federated Learning with System Heterogeneous Clients

Overview

• Federated learning (FL) enables distributed training while preserving data privacy
• Stragglers (slow or incapable clients) can significantly slow down training time and degrade performance
• Previous studies have addressed system heterogeneity by splitting models into submodels, but with limited flexibility in model architecture design

Plain English Explanation

Federated learning is a way for many devices, like smartphones or IoT sensors, to collaborate on training a shared machine learning model without having to share their private data. This is useful for preserving privacy. However, some devices may be slower or less capable than others, which can slow down the overall training process and reduce the model's performance.

To address this issue, researchers have tried splitting the machine learning model into smaller "submodels" that can be trained separately on different devices. This helps account for differences in the devices' computing power and network speeds. However, the previous approaches had limitations in how the submodels could be designed, which could lead to inconsistencies when training the various submodels.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new approach called Nested Federated Learning (NeFL) that can efficiently divide deep neural networks into submodels using both depth-wise and width-wise scaling. This provides more flexibility in how the submodels are structured. To address the potential inconsistencies that can arise from training multiple submodel architectures, NeFL decouples a subset of parameters from those being trained for each submodel. An averaging method is then used to handle these decoupled parameters during the final aggregation step.

NeFL allows resource-constrained devices to effectively participate in the federated learning pipeline, which can lead to larger datasets being used for model training. Experiments show that NeFL achieves better performance, especially for the "worst-case" submodels, compared to baseline approaches (7.63% improvement on the CIFAR-100 dataset). NeFL also aligns with recent advances in federated learning, such as leveraging pre-trained models and accounting for statistical heterogeneity.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses an important challenge in federated learning - the impact of system heterogeneity and stragglers. The proposed NeFL framework provides a flexible and effective solution to this problem. However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or areas for further research in depth.

One potential concern is the complexity added by the parameter decoupling and averaging process. While this helps address inconsistencies, it may also introduce additional computational overhead, which could be a concern for resource-constrained devices. The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the computational and memory requirements of NeFL compared to other approaches.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the technical aspects of the NeFL framework, but does not delve into the broader implications or real-world applications of this research. Further exploration of the practical benefits and challenges of deploying NeFL in various domains would be valuable.

Conclusion

The Nested Federated Learning (NeFL) framework proposed in this paper represents a significant advancement in addressing the challenges of system heterogeneity and stragglers in federated learning. By providing a flexible submodel architecture design and a method to handle parameter inconsistencies, NeFL enables resource-constrained devices to effectively participate in the federated learning pipeline, leading to improved overall model performance.

This research aligns with and builds upon recent progress in the field of federated learning, and its potential impact extends beyond the technical details presented in the paper. As federated learning continues to gain traction in various applications, solutions like NeFL will play a crucial role in making this technology more robust, scalable, and accessible to a wider range of devices and users.