Negative as Positive: Enhancing Out-of-distribution Generalization for Graph Contrastive Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach called "Negative as Positive" (NaP) to enhance the out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization capabilities of graph contrastive learning models.
- The key idea is to leverage negative samples, which are typically discarded, as positive samples during training to improve the model's ability to generalize to unseen graph distributions.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of NaP on various graph classification benchmarks, showing significant improvements in OOD performance compared to standard contrastive learning approaches.
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you are training a machine learning model to recognize different types of animals in images. During training, you would typically show the model many positive examples (images of animals) and negative examples (images of non-animals) to help it learn the differences.
Similarly, when training a machine learning model to work with graph-structured data (like social networks or molecular structures), the model needs to learn to distinguish between "positive" and "negative" examples of graph structures. The "positive" examples are the graph structures the model is supposed to recognize, and the "negative" examples are everything else.
In this paper, the researchers had an interesting idea: instead of just discarding the "negative" examples, they decided to treat them as "positive" examples too. The reasoning is that by exposing the model to a greater diversity of graph structures, even those that are not the target of the task, the model can learn more robust and generalizable features.
This approach, called "Negative as Positive" (NaP), helps the model better understand the overall structure and patterns in graph data, rather than just memorizing the specific graphs it was trained on. As a result, the model becomes better able to generalize and perform well on new, previously unseen graph structures - a critical capability for many real-world applications.
The researchers show that NaP significantly improves the out-of-distribution (OOD) performance of graph contrastive learning models across various benchmarks. This means the models trained with NaP are better able to handle graph data that is quite different from the training data, which is an important practical advantage.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel method called "Negative as Positive" (NaP) to enhance the out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization capabilities of graph contrastive learning models.
In standard graph contrastive learning, the model is trained to maximize the similarity between "positive" graph samples (i.e., graphs from the same class) and minimize the similarity between "negative" samples (i.e., graphs from different classes). The key insight of NaP is to leverage these negative samples as additional "positive" examples during training.
Specifically, the authors propose to randomly sample a subset of negative graph pairs and treat them as positive pairs during the contrastive loss computation. This encourages the model to learn more robust and generalizable representations by exposing it to a greater diversity of graph structures, including those that are not the target of the specific task.
The authors evaluate NaP on several graph classification benchmarks, including TOWARDS GRAPH CONTRASTIVE LEARNING: A SURVEY AND BEYOND, PERFECT ALIGNMENT MAY BE POISONOUS TO GRAPH, and PROVABLE TRAINING OF GRAPH CONTRASTIVE LEARNING. They demonstrate that models trained with NaP significantly outperform standard contrastive learning approaches in terms of OOD generalization, achieving state-of-the-art results on these tasks.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough evaluation of NaP and its effectiveness in improving OOD generalization for graph contrastive learning models. However, the paper does not explicitly discuss the potential limitations or drawbacks of this approach.
One potential concern is that by treating negative samples as positive, the model may learn spurious correlations or be misled by noisy graph structures, which could negatively impact its in-distribution performance. The authors could have explored the tradeoffs between OOD and in-distribution performance more extensively.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational and memory overhead of NaP compared to standard contrastive learning. Applying NaP may require additional computational resources, which could be a practical consideration for deployment in real-world scenarios.
Furthermore, the paper could have delved deeper into the underlying reasons why NaP improves OOD generalization. A more thorough theoretical analysis or ablation studies could have provided more insights into the mechanisms driving the observed performance gains.
Despite these minor limitations, the NaP approach presented in this paper represents a promising direction for enhancing the out-of-distribution capabilities of graph contrastive learning models, which is a crucial requirement for their widespread adoption in real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel method called "Negative as Positive" (NaP) that leverages negative graph samples as positive examples during contrastive learning to improve the out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization of graph representation learning models.
The key idea behind NaP is to expose the model to a greater diversity of graph structures, including those that are not the target of the specific task, to learn more robust and generalizable features. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of NaP on various graph classification benchmarks, showing significant improvements in OOD performance compared to standard contrastive learning approaches.
The NaP method represents an important step forward in enhancing the practical applicability of graph contrastive learning models, which are increasingly important for a wide range of real-world applications, such as social network analysis, drug discovery, and recommendation systems. By improving OOD generalization, NaP helps these models better handle the inherent diversity and complexity of graph-structured data encountered in the wild.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Negative as Positive: Enhancing Out-of-distribution Generalization for Graph Contrastive Learning
Zixu Wang, Bingbing Xu, Yige Yuan, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
Graph contrastive learning (GCL), standing as the dominant paradigm in the realm of graph pre-training, has yielded considerable progress. Nonetheless, its capacity for out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization has been relatively underexplored. In this work, we point out that the traditional optimization of InfoNCE in GCL restricts the cross-domain pairs only to be negative samples, which inevitably enlarges the distribution gap between different domains. This violates the requirement of domain invariance under OOD scenario and consequently impairs the model's OOD generalization performance. To address this issue, we propose a novel strategy Negative as Positive, where the most semantically similar cross-domain negative pairs are treated as positive during GCL. Our experimental results, spanning a wide array of datasets, confirm that this method substantially improves the OOD generalization performance of GCL.
Read more5/28/2024
❗
0
Topology Reorganized Graph Contrastive Learning with Mitigating Semantic Drift
Jiaqiang Zhang, Songcan Chen
Graph contrastive learning (GCL) is an effective paradigm for node representation learning in graphs. The key components hidden behind GCL are data augmentation and positive-negative pair selection. Typical data augmentations in GCL, such as uniform deletion of edges, are generally blind and resort to local perturbation, which is prone to producing under-diversity views. Additionally, there is a risk of making the augmented data traverse to other classes. Moreover, most methods always treat all other samples as negatives. Such a negative pairing naturally results in sampling bias and likewise may make the learned representation suffer from semantic drift. Therefore, to increase the diversity of the contrastive view, we propose two simple and effective global topological augmentations to compensate current GCL. One is to mine the semantic correlation between nodes in the feature space. The other is to utilize the algebraic properties of the adjacency matrix to characterize the topology by eigen-decomposition. With the help of both, we can retain important edges to build a better view. To reduce the risk of semantic drift, a prototype-based negative pair selection is further designed which can filter false negative samples. Extensive experiments on various tasks demonstrate the advantages of the model compared to the state-of-the-art methods.
Read more7/25/2024
0
Dual-perspective Cross Contrastive Learning in Graph Transformers
Zelin Yao, Chuang Liu, Xueqi Ma, Mukun Chen, Jia Wu, Xiantao Cai, Bo Du, Wenbin Hu
Graph contrastive learning (GCL) is a popular method for leaning graph representations by maximizing the consistency of features across augmented views. Traditional GCL methods utilize single-perspective i.e. data or model-perspective) augmentation to generate positive samples, restraining the diversity of positive samples. In addition, these positive samples may be unreliable due to uncontrollable augmentation strategies that potentially alter the semantic information. To address these challenges, this paper proposed a innovative framework termed dual-perspective cross graph contrastive learning (DC-GCL), which incorporates three modifications designed to enhance positive sample diversity and reliability: 1) We propose dual-perspective augmentation strategy that provide the model with more diverse training data, enabling the model effective learning of feature consistency across different views. 2) From the data perspective, we slightly perturb the original graphs using controllable data augmentation, effectively preserving their semantic information. 3) From the model perspective, we enhance the encoder by utilizing more powerful graph transformers instead of graph neural networks. Based on the model's architecture, we propose three pruning-based strategies to slightly perturb the encoder, providing more reliable positive samples. These modifications collectively form the DC-GCL's foundation and provide more diverse and reliable training inputs, offering significant improvements over traditional GCL methods. Extensive experiments on various benchmarks demonstrate that DC-GCL consistently outperforms different baselines on various datasets and tasks.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Graph Out-of-Distribution Generalization via Causal Intervention
Qitian Wu, Fan Nie, Chenxiao Yang, Tianyi Bao, Junchi Yan
Out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization has gained increasing attentions for learning on graphs, as graph neural networks (GNNs) often exhibit performance degradation with distribution shifts. The challenge is that distribution shifts on graphs involve intricate interconnections between nodes, and the environment labels are often absent in data. In this paper, we adopt a bottom-up data-generative perspective and reveal a key observation through causal analysis: the crux of GNNs' failure in OOD generalization lies in the latent confounding bias from the environment. The latter misguides the model to leverage environment-sensitive correlations between ego-graph features and target nodes' labels, resulting in undesirable generalization on new unseen nodes. Built upon this analysis, we introduce a conceptually simple yet principled approach for training robust GNNs under node-level distribution shifts, without prior knowledge of environment labels. Our method resorts to a new learning objective derived from causal inference that coordinates an environment estimator and a mixture-of-expert GNN predictor. The new approach can counteract the confounding bias in training data and facilitate learning generalizable predictive relations. Extensive experiment demonstrates that our model can effectively enhance generalization with various types of distribution shifts and yield up to 27.4% accuracy improvement over state-of-the-arts on graph OOD generalization benchmarks. Source codes are available at https://github.com/fannie1208/CaNet.
Read more8/19/2024