No Imputation Needed: A Switch Approach to Irregularly Sampled Time Series
0
🎲
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Modeling irregularly-sampled time series (ISTS) is challenging due to missing values.
- Existing methods focus on converting irregularly sampled data into regularly sampled data via imputation, which can lead to unwanted bias and sub-optimal performance.
- The research paper presents SLAN (Switch LSTM Aggregate Network), which models ISTS without imputation, eliminating the assumption of any underlying missing process.
Plain English Explanation
ISTS refers to data collected at irregular intervals, which is common in many real-world applications like healthcare monitoring. Modeling this type of data is challenging because there are often missing values that need to be accounted for.
Most existing methods try to solve this problem by converting the irregularly sampled data into regularly sampled data through a process called imputation. This means filling in the missing values based on assumptions about the underlying data-generating process. However, these assumptions may not always be accurate, leading to biased and suboptimal results.
The researchers introduce SLAN, a novel approach that can model ISTS without relying on imputation. SLAN uses a group of Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks, which are a type of neural network well-suited for handling sequential data like time series.
The key innovation in SLAN is that it dynamically adapts its architecture based on the available sensor data at each time step. This allows it to explicitly capture the local summary of each sensor's irregularity and maintain a global summary state throughout the entire observational period. By doing so, SLAN can effectively model ISTS without making any assumptions about the underlying missing data process.
Technical Explanation
The SLAN architecture consists of three main components:
-
Switch Mechanism: This component dynamically selects the appropriate LSTM model to process the data from each sensor based on the current time step. This allows SLAN to adapt its structure to the irregularity of the input data.
-
Local Summary: Each LSTM model in SLAN is responsible for capturing the local summary of a single sensor's data, including its irregular sampling pattern.
-
Global Summary: SLAN maintains a global summary state that aggregates the local summaries from all sensors, enabling it to model the overall dynamics of the ISTS.
The researchers evaluated SLAN on two public datasets: MIMIC-III, a healthcare monitoring dataset, and Physionet 2012, a dataset of heart rate measurements. The results showed that SLAN outperformed existing methods that rely on imputation, demonstrating its ability to effectively model ISTS without making assumptions about the underlying missing data process.
Critical Analysis
The research paper provides a novel and promising approach to modeling ISTS by eliminating the need for imputation. This is a significant contribution, as imputation-based methods can introduce unwanted bias and sub-optimal performance.
However, the paper does not extensively discuss the potential limitations of SLAN. For example, it is unclear how SLAN would perform in scenarios with extremely sparse or highly irregular data, or how sensitive it is to the choice of hyperparameters. Additionally, the paper does not explore the computational complexity of SLAN compared to other methods, which could be an important consideration in real-world applications.
Further research could also investigate the interpretability of SLAN's internal mechanisms, as understanding how the model arrives at its predictions can be crucial in domains like healthcare, where transparency and explainability are highly valued.
Conclusion
The SLAN model presented in this research paper offers a novel and promising approach to modeling irregularly-sampled time series without relying on imputation. By dynamically adapting its architecture and maintaining local and global summaries of the data, SLAN can effectively capture the irregularity of the input without making assumptions about the underlying missing data process. The promising results on public datasets suggest that SLAN could have significant implications for a wide range of applications that involve time series data with irregular sampling.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🎲
0
No Imputation Needed: A Switch Approach to Irregularly Sampled Time Series
Rohit Agarwal, Aman Sinha, Ayan Vishwakarma, Xavier Coubez, Marianne Clausel, Mathieu Constant, Alexander Horsch, Dilip K. Prasad
Modeling irregularly-sampled time series (ISTS) is challenging because of missing values. Most existing methods focus on handling ISTS by converting irregularly sampled data into regularly sampled data via imputation. These models assume an underlying missing mechanism, which may lead to unwanted bias and sub-optimal performance. We present SLAN (Switch LSTM Aggregate Network), which utilizes a group of LSTMs to model ISTS without imputation, eliminating the assumption of any underlying process. It dynamically adapts its architecture on the fly based on the measured sensors using switches. SLAN exploits the irregularity information to explicitly capture each sensor's local summary and maintains a global summary state throughout the observational period. We demonstrate the efficacy of SLAN on two public datasets, namely, MIMIC-III, and Physionet 2012.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Unleash The Power of Pre-Trained Language Models for Irregularly Sampled Time Series
Weijia Zhang, Chenlong Yin, Hao Liu, Hui Xiong
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), such as ChatGPT, have significantly advanced the field of natural language processing. This progress has inspired a series of innovative studies that explore the adaptation of PLMs to time series analysis, intending to create a unified foundation model that addresses various time series analytical tasks. However, these efforts predominantly focus on Regularly Sampled Time Series (RSTS), neglecting the unique challenges posed by Irregularly Sampled Time Series (ISTS), which are characterized by non-uniform sampling intervals and prevalent missing data. To bridge this gap, this work explores the potential of PLMs for ISTS analysis. We begin by investigating the effect of various methods for representing ISTS, aiming to maximize the efficacy of PLMs in this under-explored area. Furthermore, we present a unified PLM-based framework, ISTS-PLM, which integrates time-aware and variable-aware PLMs tailored for comprehensive intra and inter-time series modeling and includes a learnable input embedding layer and a task-specific output layer to tackle diverse ISTS analytical tasks. Extensive experiments on a comprehensive benchmark demonstrate that the ISTS-PLM, utilizing a simple yet effective series-based representation for ISTS, consistently achieves state-of-the-art performance across various analytical tasks, such as classification, interpolation, and extrapolation, as well as few-shot and zero-shot learning scenarios, spanning scientific domains like healthcare and biomechanics.
Read more8/19/2024
0
New!Mining of Switching Sparse Networks for Missing Value Imputation in Multivariate Time Series
Kohei Obata, Koki Kawabata, Yasuko Matsubara, Yasushi Sakurai
Multivariate time series data suffer from the problem of missing values, which hinders the application of many analytical methods. To achieve the accurate imputation of these missing values, exploiting inter-correlation by employing the relationships between sequences (i.e., a network) is as important as the use of temporal dependency, since a sequence normally correlates with other sequences. Moreover, exploiting an adequate network depending on time is also necessary since the network varies over time. However, in real-world scenarios, we normally know neither the network structure nor when the network changes beforehand. Here, we propose a missing value imputation method for multivariate time series, namely MissNet, that is designed to exploit temporal dependency with a state-space model and inter-correlation by switching sparse networks. The network encodes conditional independence between features, which helps us understand the important relationships for imputation visually. Our algorithm, which scales linearly with reference to the length of the data, alternatively infers networks and fills in missing values using the networks while discovering the switching of the networks. Extensive experiments demonstrate that MissNet outperforms the state-of-the-art algorithms for multivariate time series imputation and provides interpretable results.
Read more9/17/2024
🧠
0
Time Series Continuous Modeling for Imputation and Forecasting with Implicit Neural Representations
Etienne Le Naour, Louis Serrano, L'eon Migus, Yuan Yin, Ghislain Agoua, Nicolas Baskiotis, Patrick Gallinari, Vincent Guigue
We introduce a novel modeling approach for time series imputation and forecasting, tailored to address the challenges often encountered in real-world data, such as irregular samples, missing data, or unaligned measurements from multiple sensors. Our method relies on a continuous-time-dependent model of the series' evolution dynamics. It leverages adaptations of conditional, implicit neural representations for sequential data. A modulation mechanism, driven by a meta-learning algorithm, allows adaptation to unseen samples and extrapolation beyond observed time-windows for long-term predictions. The model provides a highly flexible and unified framework for imputation and forecasting tasks across a wide range of challenging scenarios. It achieves state-of-the-art performance on classical benchmarks and outperforms alternative time-continuous models.
Read more4/23/2024