Not Only the Last-Layer Features for Spurious Correlations: All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a novel approach called "All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting" to address the issue of spurious correlations in deep learning models.
- It demonstrates that focusing solely on the last layer features is not sufficient, and that reweighting features across all layers can lead to improved robustness.
- The method is evaluated on several datasets and shows superior performance compared to existing techniques.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models can sometimes learn to rely on "shortcuts" or spurious correlations in the data, which can lead to poor generalization and vulnerability to distributional shift. The authors of this paper argue that simply focusing on the features from the last layer of the model is not enough to address this issue.
Instead, they propose a method called "All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting" that adjusts the importance, or "weights," of features from all the layers of the deep neural network. By doing this, the model can learn to rely less on the spurious correlations and more on the truly relevant features, leading to improved robustness and generalization.
The researchers evaluated their approach on several different datasets and found that it outperformed existing techniques for addressing spurious correlations, such as data augmentation and fine-tuning.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind the "All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting" method is to learn a set of weights that adjust the importance of features from each layer of the deep neural network, rather than just focusing on the last layer. This is motivated by the observation that spurious correlations can manifest at different levels of the network, and addressing them requires a more holistic approach.
The authors formulate this as an optimization problem, where they learn the reweighting factors for each layer by minimizing a loss function that encourages the model to rely less on the spurious correlations and more on the truly relevant features. They evaluate their approach on several benchmark datasets and show that it outperforms existing techniques, such as data augmentation and fine-tuning, in terms of both accuracy and robustness to distributional shift.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge that their method relies on the availability of a validation set that is representative of the target distribution, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. Additionally, the reweighting factors are learned in an unsupervised manner, which could lead to suboptimal solutions in some cases.
It would be interesting to explore ways of incorporating additional supervision or inductive biases to further improve the performance of the method, perhaps by leveraging group robustness or other approaches.
Conclusion
The "All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting" method proposed in this paper represents an important step forward in addressing the issue of spurious correlations in deep learning. By considering features from all layers of the network, rather than just the last layer, the approach can learn more robust representations and improve the generalization capabilities of deep learning models. The results are promising, and the proposed technique could have significant implications for a wide range of applications where model robustness is crucial.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Not Only the Last-Layer Features for Spurious Correlations: All Layer Deep Feature Reweighting
Humza Wajid Hameed, Geraldin Nanfack, Eugene Belilovsky
Spurious correlations are a major source of errors for machine learning models, in particular when aiming for group-level fairness. It has been recently shown that a powerful approach to combat spurious correlations is to re-train the last layer on a balanced validation dataset, isolating robust features for the predictor. However, key attributes can sometimes be discarded by neural networks towards the last layer. In this work, we thus consider retraining a classifier on a set of features derived from all layers. We utilize a recently proposed feature selection strategy to select unbiased features from all the layers. We observe this approach gives significant improvements in worst-group accuracy on several standard benchmarks.
Read more9/24/2024
0
Out of spuriousity: Improving robustness to spurious correlations without group annotations
Phuong Quynh Le, Jorg Schlotterer, Christin Seifert
Machine learning models are known to learn spurious correlations, i.e., features having strong relations with class labels but no causal relation. Relying on those correlations leads to poor performance in the data groups without these correlations and poor generalization ability. To improve the robustness of machine learning models to spurious correlations, we propose an approach to extract a subnetwork from a fully trained network that does not rely on spurious correlations. The subnetwork is found by the assumption that data points with the same spurious attribute will be close to each other in the representation space when training with ERM, then we employ supervised contrastive loss in a novel way to force models to unlearn the spurious connections. The increase in the worst-group performance of our approach contributes to strengthening the hypothesis that there exists a subnetwork in a fully trained dense network that is responsible for using only invariant features in classification tasks, therefore erasing the influence of spurious features even in the setup of multi spurious attributes and no prior knowledge of attributes labels.
Read more7/23/2024
📊
0
Theoretical Guarantees of Data Augmented Last Layer Retraining Methods
Monica Welfert, Nathan Stromberg, Lalitha Sankar
Ensuring fair predictions across many distinct subpopulations in the training data can be prohibitive for large models. Recently, simple linear last layer retraining strategies, in combination with data augmentation methods such as upweighting, downsampling and mixup, have been shown to achieve state-of-the-art performance for worst-group accuracy, which quantifies accuracy for the least prevalent subpopulation. For linear last layer retraining and the abovementioned augmentations, we present the optimal worst-group accuracy when modeling the distribution of the latent representations (input to the last layer) as Gaussian for each subpopulation. We evaluate and verify our results for both synthetic and large publicly available datasets.
Read more5/10/2024
0
The Group Robustness is in the Details: Revisiting Finetuning under Spurious Correlations
Tyler LaBonte, John C. Hill, Xinchen Zhang, Vidya Muthukumar, Abhishek Kumar
Modern machine learning models are prone to over-reliance on spurious correlations, which can often lead to poor performance on minority groups. In this paper, we identify surprising and nuanced behavior of finetuned models on worst-group accuracy via comprehensive experiments on four well-established benchmarks across vision and language tasks. We first show that the commonly used class-balancing techniques of mini-batch upsampling and loss upweighting can induce a decrease in worst-group accuracy (WGA) with training epochs, leading to performance no better than without class-balancing. While in some scenarios, removing data to create a class-balanced subset is more effective, we show this depends on group structure and propose a mixture method which can outperform both techniques. Next, we show that scaling pretrained models is generally beneficial for worst-group accuracy, but only in conjuction with appropriate class-balancing. Finally, we identify spectral imbalance in finetuning features as a potential source of group disparities -- minority group covariance matrices incur a larger spectral norm than majority groups once conditioned on the classes. Our results show more nuanced interactions of modern finetuned models with group robustness than was previously known. Our code is available at https://github.com/tmlabonte/revisiting-finetuning.
Read more7/22/2024