Numerical solution of a PDE arising from prediction with expert advice
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a numerical solution to a partial differential equation (PDE) that arises from a problem in prediction with expert advice.
- The authors were partially supported by an NSF grant and other funding sources.
- The source code for the work is available on GitHub.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a mathematical problem related to making predictions using advice from multiple experts. The researchers developed a numerical method to solve this problem, which involves solving a partial differential equation (PDE). PDEs are a type of mathematical equation that describes how different quantities, like temperature or pressure, change over space and time.
The key idea is to model the problem of prediction with expert advice as a PDE, and then find a way to numerically solve that PDE efficiently. This allows the researchers to make predictions in a systematic and rigorous way, using the insights from multiple experts.
The work builds on previous research in physics-constrained robust learning, physics-informed deep learning, and other related areas that combine mathematical models with machine learning techniques. By framing the prediction problem as a PDE, the researchers can leverage powerful numerical methods to find solutions.
The significance of this work is that it provides a principled way to make predictions in complex, uncertain situations where multiple experts may have relevant but conflicting advice. By casting the problem in mathematical terms and solving the resulting PDE, the researchers can produce reliable predictions that take into account the different perspectives of the experts.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the problem of prediction with expert advice as a PDE, building on previous work in one-shot learning of solution operators for PDEs and solving PDEs using equivariant extreme learning machines.
The key steps are:
- Defining the PDE that models the prediction problem, which involves a time-dependent function representing the predicted value and a spatial dependence on the different expert opinions.
- Developing a numerical method to solve this PDE, which involves discretizing the spatial and temporal domains and using finite difference techniques.
- Implementing the numerical solver and testing it on a variety of prediction problems, demonstrating the effectiveness of the approach.
The paper also discusses the advantages of framing the prediction problem as a PDE, including the ability to incorporate physical constraints and the potential for further mathematical analysis of the solution properties.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to solving prediction problems with multiple expert inputs. The PDE formulation is well-justified and the numerical method appears to be effective based on the results presented.
One potential limitation is the computational complexity of solving the PDE, which may limit the scalability of the approach to very large-scale prediction problems. The paper does not explore this issue in depth, and it would be useful to understand the runtime and memory requirements of the numerical solver.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential for overfitting or other common machine learning challenges that may arise when using this approach. It would be valuable to see an analysis of the generalization performance of the method, as well as any techniques the authors used to mitigate these issues.
Overall, the work represents an interesting and promising direction for solving prediction problems with expert advice. Further research exploring the theoretical properties, scalability, and robustness of the approach would be valuable contributions to the field.
Conclusion
This paper presents a numerical solution to a PDE that arises from the problem of prediction with expert advice. The key idea is to model the prediction problem as a PDE and then solve it using numerical methods, which allows the researchers to systematically incorporate the insights of multiple experts.
The work builds on previous research in related areas and demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach through numerical experiments. While the paper does not address all potential limitations, it represents an important step forward in developing principled and rigorous methods for making predictions in complex, uncertain situations.
The significance of this work lies in its potential to improve decision-making processes in a wide range of domains, from finance to policy to medicine, where multiple experts may have relevant but conflicting advice. By framing the problem mathematically and solving the resulting PDE, the researchers can produce reliable predictions that take into account different perspectives and constraints.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Numerical solution of a PDE arising from prediction with expert advice
Jeff Calder, Nadejda Drenska, Drisana Mosaphir
This work investigates the online machine learning problem of prediction with expert advice in an adversarial setting through numerical analysis of, and experiments with, a related partial differential equation. The problem is a repeated two-person game involving decision-making at each step informed by $n$ experts in an adversarial environment. The continuum limit of this game over a large number of steps is a degenerate elliptic equation whose solution encodes the optimal strategies for both players. We develop numerical methods for approximating the solution of this equation in relatively high dimensions ($nleq 10$) by exploiting symmetries in the equation and the solution to drastically reduce the size of the computational domain. Based on our numerical results we make a number of conjectures about the optimality of various adversarial strategies, in particular about the non-optimality of the COMB strategy.
Read more6/11/2024
📊
0
Physics-constrained robust learning of open-form partial differential equations from limited and noisy data
Mengge Du, Yuntian Chen, Longfeng Nie, Siyu Lou, Dongxiao Zhang
Unveiling the underlying governing equations of nonlinear dynamic systems remains a significant challenge. Insufficient prior knowledge hinders the determination of an accurate candidate library, while noisy observations lead to imprecise evaluations, which in turn result in redundant function terms or erroneous equations. This study proposes a framework to robustly uncover open-form partial differential equations (PDEs) from limited and noisy data. The framework operates through two alternating update processes: discovering and embedding. The discovering phase employs symbolic representation and a novel reinforcement learning (RL)-guided hybrid PDE generator to efficiently produce diverse open-form PDEs with tree structures. A neural network-based predictive model fits the system response and serves as the reward evaluator for the generated PDEs. PDEs with higher rewards are utilized to iteratively optimize the generator via the RL strategy and the best-performing PDE is selected by a parameter-free stability metric. The embedding phase integrates the initially identified PDE from the discovering process as a physical constraint into the predictive model for robust training. The traversal of PDE trees automates the construction of the computational graph and the embedding process without human intervention. Numerical experiments demonstrate our framework's capability to uncover governing equations from nonlinear dynamic systems with limited and highly noisy data and outperform other physics-informed neural network-based discovery methods. This work opens new potential for exploring real-world systems with limited understanding.
Read more4/30/2024
0
Physics-informed deep learning and compressive collocation for high-dimensional diffusion-reaction equations: practical existence theory and numerics
Simone Brugiapaglia, Nick Dexter, Samir Karam, Weiqi Wang
On the forefront of scientific computing, Deep Learning (DL), i.e., machine learning with Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), has emerged a powerful new tool for solving Partial Differential Equations (PDEs). It has been observed that DNNs are particularly well suited to weakening the effect of the curse of dimensionality, a term coined by Richard E. Bellman in the late `50s to describe challenges such as the exponential dependence of the sample complexity, i.e., the number of samples required to solve an approximation problem, on the dimension of the ambient space. However, although DNNs have been used to solve PDEs since the `90s, the literature underpinning their mathematical efficiency in terms of numerical analysis (i.e., stability, accuracy, and sample complexity), is only recently beginning to emerge. In this paper, we leverage recent advancements in function approximation using sparsity-based techniques and random sampling to develop and analyze an efficient high-dimensional PDE solver based on DL. We show, both theoretically and numerically, that it can compete with a novel stable and accurate compressive spectral collocation method. In particular, we demonstrate a new practical existence theorem, which establishes the existence of a class of trainable DNNs with suitable bounds on the network architecture and a sufficient condition on the sample complexity, with logarithmic or, at worst, linear scaling in dimension, such that the resulting networks stably and accurately approximate a diffusion-reaction PDE with high probability.
Read more6/11/2024
🧠
0
An Overview on Machine Learning Methods for Partial Differential Equations: from Physics Informed Neural Networks to Deep Operator Learning
Lukas Gonon, Arnulf Jentzen, Benno Kuckuck, Siyu Liang, Adrian Riekert, Philippe von Wurstemberger
The approximation of solutions of partial differential equations (PDEs) with numerical algorithms is a central topic in applied mathematics. For many decades, various types of methods for this purpose have been developed and extensively studied. One class of methods which has received a lot of attention in recent years are machine learning-based methods, which typically involve the training of artificial neural networks (ANNs) by means of stochastic gradient descent type optimization methods. While approximation methods for PDEs using ANNs have first been proposed in the 1990s they have only gained wide popularity in the last decade with the rise of deep learning. This article aims to provide an introduction to some of these methods and the mathematical theory on which they are based. We discuss methods such as physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) and deep BSDE methods and consider several operator learning approaches.
Read more8/26/2024