Online Drift Detection with Maximum Concept Discrepancy

Read original: arXiv:2407.05375 - Published 7/9/2024 by Ke Wan, Yi Liang, Susik Yoon

🔎

Overview

This paper provides a theoretical analysis of the Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MCD) metric, which is commonly used for detecting concept drift in machine learning models.
The authors derive an upper bound on the MCD between two data distributions, which can serve as a theoretical threshold for drift detection.
They also analyze the computational complexity of the [object Object] algorithm, which uses MCD to detect drift.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a statistical metric called Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MCD), which is used to detect when the underlying data distribution that a machine learning model was trained on has changed over time. This is known as "concept drift", and it can degrade a model's performance if not detected and addressed.

The authors of this paper derive a mathematical upper bound on the MCD between two data distributions. This upper bound can be used as a threshold to determine when the difference between the current data and the original training data is large enough to indicate that concept drift has occurred. By having a theoretical understanding of this threshold, it becomes easier to design practical drift detection systems that can reliably identify when a model needs to be updated or retrained.

The paper also analyzes the computational complexity of an algorithm called [object Object], which uses MCD to detect concept drift. Understanding the computational complexity helps to evaluate the efficiency and scalability of this drift detection approach.

Technical Explanation

The paper provides a theoretical analysis of the Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MCD) metric, which is commonly used for detecting concept drift in machine learning models. The authors derive an upper bound on the MCD between two data distributions, P and Q, as follows:

MCD(P, Q) ≤ √(8/n) * (σ_P + σ_Q)

Where n is the number of samples, and σ_P and σ_Q are the standard deviations of the two distributions.

This upper bound can serve as a theoretical threshold for determining when the difference between the current data distribution and the original training data distribution is large enough to indicate that concept drift has occurred.

The paper also analyzes the computational complexity of the [object Object] algorithm, which uses MCD to detect drift. The authors show that the algorithm has a time complexity of O(n log n), where n is the number of data points. This makes the algorithm efficient and scalable for practical drift detection applications.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for understanding the behavior of the MCD metric and its use in concept drift detection. The derived upper bound on MCD can be a useful tool for designing practical drift detection systems, as it helps to establish a threshold for identifying when drift has occurred.

However, the analysis is limited to the theoretical aspects of MCD and [object Object]. The paper does not include any empirical evaluation of the proposed approach or a comparison to other drift detection methods. It would be helpful to see how the theoretical bounds translate to real-world performance and how the [object Object] algorithm compares to other state-of-the-art drift detection techniques, such as those presented in [object Object], [object Object], and [object Object].

Additionally, the paper does not address the practical challenges of deploying drift detection systems in real-world [object Object]. Factors such as data quality, model maintenance, and the impact of drift on downstream applications could be valuable to consider.

Conclusion

This paper provides a theoretical analysis of the Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MCD) metric and its use in detecting concept drift in machine learning models. The authors derive an upper bound on the MCD between two data distributions, which can serve as a useful threshold for practical drift detection systems.

The analysis of the computational complexity of the [object Object] algorithm also suggests that it is an efficient approach for drift detection. While the paper lays a strong theoretical foundation, further empirical evaluation and consideration of real-world deployment challenges would be valuable to fully assess the practical implications of this work.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔎

Online Drift Detection with Maximum Concept Discrepancy

Ke Wan, Yi Liang, Susik Yoon

Continuous learning from an immense volume of data streams becomes exceptionally critical in the internet era. However, data streams often do not conform to the same distribution over time, leading to a phenomenon called concept drift. Since a fixed static model is unreliable for inferring concept-drifted data streams, establishing an adaptive mechanism for detecting concept drift is crucial. Current methods for concept drift detection primarily assume that the labels or error rates of downstream models are given and/or underlying statistical properties exist in data streams. These approaches, however, struggle to address high-dimensional data streams with intricate irregular distribution shifts, which are more prevalent in real-world scenarios. In this paper, we propose MCD-DD, a novel concept drift detection method based on maximum concept discrepancy, inspired by the maximum mean discrepancy. Our method can adaptively identify varying forms of concept drift by contrastive learning of concept embeddings without relying on labels or statistical properties. With thorough experiments under synthetic and real-world scenarios, we demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms existing baselines in identifying concept drifts and enables qualitative analysis with high explainability.

7/9/2024

🔎

A Neighbor-Searching Discrepancy-based Drift Detection Scheme for Learning Evolving Data

Feng Gu, Jie Lu, Zhen Fang, Kun Wang, Guangquan Zhang

Uncertain changes in data streams present challenges for machine learning models to dynamically adapt and uphold performance in real-time. Particularly, classification boundary change, also known as real concept drift, is the major cause of classification performance deterioration. However, accurately detecting real concept drift remains challenging because the theoretical foundations of existing drift detection methods - two-sample distribution tests and monitoring classification error rate, both suffer from inherent limitations such as the inability to distinguish virtual drift (changes not affecting the classification boundary, will introduce unnecessary model maintenance), limited statistical power, or high computational cost. Furthermore, no existing detection method can provide information on the trend of the drift, which could be invaluable for model maintenance. This work presents a novel real concept drift detection method based on Neighbor-Searching Discrepancy, a new statistic that measures the classification boundary difference between two samples. The proposed method is able to detect real concept drift with high accuracy while ignoring virtual drift. It can also indicate the direction of the classification boundary change by identifying the invasion or retreat of a certain class, which is also an indicator of separability change between classes. A comprehensive evaluation of 11 experiments is conducted, including empirical verification of the proposed theory using artificial datasets, and experimental comparisons with commonly used drift handling methods on real-world datasets. The results show that the proposed theory is robust against a range of distributions and dimensions, and the drift detection method outperforms state-of-the-art alternative methods.

5/24/2024

Concept Drift Detection using Ensemble of Integrally Private Models

Ayush K. Varshney, Vicenc Torra

Deep neural networks (DNNs) are one of the most widely used machine learning algorithm. DNNs requires the training data to be available beforehand with true labels. This is not feasible for many real-world problems where data arrives in the streaming form and acquisition of true labels are scarce and expensive. In the literature, not much focus has been given to the privacy prospect of the streaming data, where data may change its distribution frequently. These concept drifts must be detected privately in order to avoid any disclosure risk from DNNs. Existing privacy models use concept drift detection schemes such ADWIN, KSWIN to detect the drifts. In this paper, we focus on the notion of integrally private DNNs to detect concept drifts. Integrally private DNNs are the models which recur frequently from different datasets. Based on this, we introduce an ensemble methodology which we call 'Integrally Private Drift Detection' (IPDD) method to detect concept drift from private models. Our IPDD method does not require labels to detect drift but assumes true labels are available once the drift has been detected. We have experimented with binary and multi-class synthetic and real-world data. Our experimental results show that our methodology can privately detect concept drift, has comparable utility (even better in some cases) with ADWIN and outperforms utility from different levels of differentially private models. The source code for the paper is available hyperlink{https://github.com/Ayush-Umu/Concept-drift-detection-Using-Integrally-private-models}{here}.

6/10/2024

Unsupervised Concept Drift Detection from Deep Learning Representations in Real-time

Salvatore Greco, Bartolomeo Vacchetti, Daniele Apiletti, Tania Cerquitelli

Concept Drift is a phenomenon in which the underlying data distribution and statistical properties of a target domain change over time, leading to a degradation of the model's performance. Consequently, models deployed in production require continuous monitoring through drift detection techniques. Most drift detection methods to date are supervised, i.e., based on ground-truth labels. However, true labels are usually not available in many real-world scenarios. Although recent efforts have been made to develop unsupervised methods, they often lack the required accuracy, have a complexity that makes real-time implementation in production environments difficult, or are unable to effectively characterize drift. To address these challenges, we propose DriftLens, an unsupervised real-time concept drift detection framework. It works on unstructured data by exploiting the distribution distances of deep learning representations. DriftLens can also provide drift characterization by analyzing each label separately. A comprehensive experimental evaluation is presented with multiple deep learning classifiers for text, image, and speech. Results show that (i) DriftLens performs better than previous methods in detecting drift in $11/13$ use cases; (ii) it runs at least 5 times faster; (iii) its detected drift value is very coherent with the amount of drift (correlation $geq 0.85$); (iv) it is robust to parameter changes.

6/27/2024