Online Optimization and Ambiguity-based Learning of Distributionally Uncertain Dynamic Systems

Overview

• This paper proposes a new approach to solve optimization problems under uncertainty in dynamic systems.
• It combines machine learning techniques and distributionally robust optimization to learn the uncertainty in the system and make online decisions with probabilistic guarantees.
• The key ideas are using a control-dependent ambiguity set to capture uncertainty, and developing an accelerated gradient algorithm to efficiently solve the resulting optimization problems.

Plain English Explanation

The paper tackles the challenge of making decisions in situations with uncertainty. For example, imagine a robot navigating through an environment with obstacles whose locations are not precisely known. The researchers developed a framework that allows the robot to:

1. Learn the Uncertainty: Using past data about the environment, the robot can learn a "distribution" or pattern of where obstacles are likely to be. This distribution captures the uncertainty in the system.

2. Make Robust Decisions: With the learned uncertainty distribution, the robot can then make decisions about how to move through the environment in a way that hedges against the uncertainty. This results in decisions that are less conservative than standard approaches.

3. Provide Performance Guarantees: The framework also provides mathematical guarantees on the performance of the robot's decisions, bounding the potential "regret" or difference from the ideal outcome.

The key innovation is that the uncertainty distribution can depend on the robot's actions, allowing more nuanced modeling of real-world systems. The researchers also developed a specialized optimization algorithm to efficiently compute these robust decisions in an online setting, as needed for cyber-physical and robotic systems.

Overall, this work advances the state-of-the-art in decision-making under uncertainty, with applications in areas like robotics, resource allocation, and control systems.

Technical Explanation

The core technical approach is to model the optimization problem (P) under a class of distributionally uncertain dynamical systems. This means the system evolves over time in a way that is not precisely known, but can be described by a family or "ambiguity set" of possible probability distributions.

To handle this uncertainty, the paper leverages the theory of Distributionally Robust Optimization (DRO). DRO seeks decisions that perform well across the entire ambiguity set, providing probabilistic guarantees on performance.

A key novelty is that the ambiguity set is parameterized and control-dependent. This allows the uncertainty to adapt based on the decisions being made, better capturing real-world dynamics. The paper presents a tractable reformulation of the DRO problem in this setting, maintaining the probabilistic guarantees.

The paper then specializes this framework to two problem classes:

1. Optimal one-stage control of distributionally uncertain nonlinear systems
2. Resource allocation under distributional uncertainty

For solving these problems, the paper introduces an online version of Nesterov's accelerated gradient algorithm, and analyzes its performance using dissipativity theory.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes several significant contributions, but also has some limitations:

Strengths:

• Develops a flexible DRO framework that can model complex, control-dependent uncertainties
• Provides tractable optimization formulations and performance guarantees
• Introduces an efficient online optimization algorithm tailored to the problem structure

Limitations:

• The assumed class of ambiguity sets may not capture all real-world uncertainty distributions
• The analysis focuses on asymptotic performance, but more finite-time guarantees would be useful
• Experimental validation is limited, and challenges around real-world deployment are not discussed

Overall, this work advances the state-of-the-art in decision-making under uncertainty, but further research is needed to fully address the practical challenges in deploying such techniques in complex, dynamic environments.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to optimization under uncertainty, combining machine learning and distributionally robust optimization. By learning a control-dependent uncertainty model and using an efficient online optimization algorithm, the framework can make robust decisions with performance guarantees.

While there are some limitations, this work represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of decision-making in the face of uncertainty, with applications in areas like robotics, resource allocation, and control systems. Continued research in this direction has the potential to enable more reliable and adaptive decision-making in a wide range of real-world settings.