Partial Gromov-Wasserstein Metric
0
↗️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is a metric used to compare data in different metric spaces.
- Researchers have explored using GW in unbalanced settings, but the resulting Unbalanced GW (UGW) is not a true metric.
- This paper proposes a new metric called Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW) that addresses the limitations of UGW.
- The paper establishes the theoretical properties of PGW and introduces algorithms for computing it.
- PGW is demonstrated to be effective for applications like shape matching and retrieval.
Plain English Explanation
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is a way to compare data that lives in different coordinate systems or "metric spaces." This is useful in machine learning, where you might have data from different sources that need to be analyzed together.
However, the traditional GW distance has some limitations - it requires that the data being compared have the same total "mass" or quantity. Researchers have tried to relax this constraint by introducing Unbalanced GW (UGW), but UGW isn't a true mathematical distance.
In this paper, the authors propose a new metric called Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW) that overcomes the limitations of UGW. PGW is a well-defined distance that allows for comparing data in different metric spaces, even if the total quantities don't match up.
The paper proves that PGW has good theoretical properties, like guaranteeing the existence of an optimal solution. The authors also develop efficient algorithms for computing PGW and show how it can be used for applications like shape matching and retrieval.
Overall, PGW provides a robust and flexible way to compare data across different coordinate systems, which has many potential applications in machine learning and data analysis.
Technical Explanation
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is a powerful tool for comparing data that lives in different metric spaces. However, the classical GW problem requires that the data being compared have equal total mass or quantity. To address this limitation, researchers have explored the use of Unbalanced GW (UGW), which allows for unequal masses.
Unfortunately, UGW can only be regarded as a discrepancy rather than a true metric or distance between metric measure spaces (mm-spaces). In this paper, the authors propose a particular case of the UGW problem, termed Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW), which they establish as a well-defined metric between mm-spaces.
The authors discuss the theoretical properties of PGW, including the existence of a minimizer for the PGW problem and the relationship between PGW and GW. They then propose two variants of the Frank-Wolfe algorithm for solving the PGW problem and show that they are mathematically and computationally equivalent.
Furthermore, the authors introduce the analogous concept of barycenters for mm-spaces based on their PGW metric. Finally, they validate the effectiveness of their PGW metric and related solvers in applications such as shape matching, shape retrieval, and shape interpolation, comparing them against existing baselines.
Critical Analysis
The authors of this paper have made a significant contribution by proposing the Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW) metric, which addresses the limitations of the existing Unbalanced Gromov-Wasserstein (UGW) approach. The theoretical analysis of PGW's properties is thorough and provides a solid foundation for understanding this new metric.
One potential limitation of the PGW approach is that it may still be computationally expensive to compute, especially for large-scale problems. The authors have proposed efficient algorithms, but the scalability of PGW compared to other distance measures could be an area for further investigation.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential biases or edge cases that may arise when using PGW in real-world applications. It would be valuable to see more extensive empirical evaluations of PGW's performance and robustness across a diverse set of datasets and scenarios.
Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in the field of optimal transport and metric learning. The PGW metric provides a flexible and well-defined way to compare data in different metric spaces, which has numerous potential applications in machine learning and beyond.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new metric called Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW) that allows for the comparison of data in different metric spaces, even when the total quantities of the data do not match. The authors have established the theoretical properties of PGW and developed efficient algorithms for computing it.
The significance of this work lies in its ability to overcome the limitations of the existing Unbalanced Gromov-Wasserstein (UGW) approach, which was not a true metric. PGW is a well-defined distance that can be used for a variety of applications, such as shape matching, retrieval, and interpolation.
The implementation and demonstration of PGW in practical scenarios suggests that it could have a transformative impact on fields that require the comparison of data across different coordinate systems or modalities. As the authors continue to explore the capabilities and limitations of PGW, it will be exciting to see how this new metric is adopted and applied in the broader machine learning community.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
↗️
0
Partial Gromov-Wasserstein Metric
Yikun Bai, Rocio Diaz Martin, Abihith Kothapalli, Hengrong Du, Xinran Liu, Soheil Kolouri
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance has gained increasing interest in the machine learning community in recent years, as it allows for the comparison of measures in different metric spaces. To overcome the limitations imposed by the equal mass requirements of the classical GW problem, researchers have begun exploring its application in unbalanced settings. However, Unbalanced GW (UGW) can only be regarded as a discrepancy rather than a rigorous metric/distance between two metric measure spaces (mm-spaces). In this paper, we propose a particular case of the UGW problem, termed Partial Gromov-Wasserstein (PGW). We establish that PGW is a well-defined metric between mm-spaces and discuss its theoretical properties, including the existence of a minimizer for the PGW problem and the relationship between PGW and GW, among others. We then propose two variants of the Frank-Wolfe algorithm for solving the PGW problem and show that they are mathematically and computationally equivalent. Moreover, based on our PGW metric, we introduce the analogous concept of barycenters for mm-spaces. Finally, we validate the effectiveness of our PGW metric and related solvers in applications such as shape matching, shape retrieval, and shape interpolation, comparing them against existing baselines.
Read more5/30/2024
0
The Z-Gromov-Wasserstein Distance
Martin Bauer, Facundo M'emoli, Tom Needham, Mao Nishino
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is a powerful tool for comparing metric measure spaces which has found broad applications in data science and machine learning. Driven by the need to analyze datasets whose objects have increasingly complex structure (such as node and edge-attributed graphs), several variants of GW distance have been introduced in the recent literature. With a view toward establishing a general framework for the theory of GW-like distances, this paper considers a vast generalization of the notion of a metric measure space: for an arbitrary metric space $Z$, we define a $Z$-network to be a measure space endowed with a kernel valued in $Z$. We introduce a method for comparing $Z$-networks by defining a generalization of GW distance, which we refer to as $Z$-Gromov-Wasserstein ($Z$-GW) distance. This construction subsumes many previously known metrics and offers a unified approach to understanding their shared properties. The paper demonstrates that the $Z$-GW distance defines a metric on the space of $Z$-networks which retains desirable properties of $Z$, such as separability, completeness, and geodesicity. Many of these properties were unknown for existing variants of GW distance that fall under our framework. Our focus is on foundational theory, but our results also include computable lower bounds and approximations of the distance which will be useful for practical applications.
Read more8/16/2024
🤷
0
Gromov-Wassertein-like Distances in the Gaussian Mixture Models Space
Antoine Salmona, Julie Delon, Agn`es Desolneux
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is frequently used in machine learning to compare distributions across distinct metric spaces. Despite its utility, it remains computationally intensive, especially for large-scale problems. Recently, a novel Wasserstein distance specifically tailored for Gaussian mixture models and known as MW (mixture Wasserstein) has been introduced by several authors. In scenarios where data exhibit clustering, this approach simplifies to a small-scale discrete optimal transport problem, which complexity depends solely on the number of Gaussian components in the GMMs. This paper aims to extend MW by introducing new Gromov-type distances. These distances are designed to be isometry-invariant in Euclidean spaces and are applicable for comparing GMMs across different dimensional spaces. Our first contribution is the Mixture Gromov Wasserstein distance (MGW), which can be viewed as a Gromovized version of MW. This new distance has a straightforward discrete formulation, making it highly efficient for estimating distances between GMMs in practical applications. To facilitate the derivation of a transport plan between GMMs, we present a second distance, the Embedded Wasserstein distance (EW). This distance turns out to be closely related to several recent alternatives to Gromov-Wasserstein. We show that EW can be adapted to derive a distance as well as optimal transportation plans between GMMs. We demonstrate the efficiency of these newly proposed distances on medium to large-scale problems, including shape matching and hyperspectral image color transfer.
Read more4/1/2024
0
Fast Gradient Computation for Gromov-Wasserstein Distance
Wei Zhang, Zihao Wang, Jie Fan, Hao Wu, Yong Zhang
The Gromov-Wasserstein distance is a notable extension of optimal transport. In contrast to the classic Wasserstein distance, it solves a quadratic assignment problem that minimizes the pair-wise distance distortion under the transportation of distributions and thus could apply to distributions in different spaces. These properties make Gromov-Wasserstein widely applicable to many fields, such as computer graphics and machine learning. However, the computation of the Gromov-Wasserstein distance and transport plan is expensive. The well-known Entropic Gromov-Wasserstein approach has a cubic complexity since the matrix multiplication operations need to be repeated in computing the gradient of Gromov-Wasserstein loss. This becomes a key bottleneck of the method. Currently, existing methods accelerate the computation focus on sampling and approximation, which leads to low accuracy or incomplete transport plan. In this work, we propose a novel method to accelerate accurate gradient computation by dynamic programming techniques, reducing the complexity from cubic to quadratic. In this way, the original computational bottleneck is broken and the new entropic solution can be obtained with total quadratic time, which is almost optimal complexity. Furthermore, it can be extended to some variants easily. Extensive experiments validate the efficiency and effectiveness of our method.
Read more4/16/2024