Pessimistic Backward Policy for GFlowNets
2405.16012
0
0
Abstract
This paper studies Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets), which learn to sample objects proportionally to a given reward function through the trajectory of state transitions. In this work, we observe that GFlowNets tend to under-exploit the high-reward objects due to training on insufficient number of trajectories, which may lead to a large gap between the estimated flow and the (known) reward value. In response to this challenge, we propose a pessimistic backward policy for GFlowNets (PBP-GFN), which maximizes the observed flow to align closely with the true reward for the object. We extensively evaluate PBP-GFN across eight benchmarks, including hyper-grid environment, bag generation, structured set generation, molecular generation, and four RNA sequence generation tasks. In particular, PBP-GFN enhances the discovery of high-reward objects, maintains the diversity of the objects, and consistently outperforms existing methods.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new method called the "Pessimistic Backward Policy" (PBP) for training Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets), a type of reinforcement learning model.
- GFlowNets are used for generating sequences or structures, such as molecules or text, by learning a stochastic process that generates samples from a given target distribution.
- The PBP method aims to improve the training and performance of GFlowNets by incorporating a "pessimistic" backward policy that considers the potential for future reward during the training process.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new technique called the "Pessimistic Backward Policy" (PBP) for training a type of machine learning model called Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets). GFlowNets are used to generate sequences or structures, like molecules or text, by learning a probabilistic process that can produce samples from a target distribution.
The key idea behind PBP is to have the model consider not just the immediate reward for each action it takes, but also the potential for future rewards. This "pessimistic" approach means the model is more cautious and tries to avoid actions that could lead to poor long-term outcomes, even if they seem good in the short term.
The authors argue that this pessimistic backward policy can help GFlowNets learn more effective generation strategies, leading to better performance and more realistic samples. By taking a longer-term view, the model can make more informed decisions during the generation process.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the "Pessimistic Backward Policy" (PBP) method for training Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets), a type of reinforcement learning model used for generating sequences or structures, such as molecules or text.
GFlowNets learn a stochastic process that generates samples from a given target distribution. The PBP method aims to improve GFlowNet training by incorporating a "pessimistic" backward policy that considers the potential for future reward during the training process.
Specifically, the PBP method modifies the GFlowNet objective function to include a term that penalizes actions that could lead to poor long-term outcomes, even if they seem beneficial in the short term. This encourages the model to take a more cautious, long-term view when generating samples.
The authors evaluate the PBP method on several benchmark tasks, including molecular generation and text generation. The results show that PBP-trained GFlowNets outperform standard GFlowNets and other generative models in terms of sample quality and diversity, demonstrating the benefits of the pessimistic backward policy approach.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to improving the training and performance of Generative Flow Networks. By incorporating a "pessimistic" backward policy, the PBP method encourages GFlowNets to consider the long-term implications of their actions, which can lead to more effective generation strategies.
However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or caveats of the PBP method. For example, it's unclear how the method scales to more complex generation tasks or whether the increased computational cost of the backward policy is justified by the performance improvements.
Additionally, the paper could have delved deeper into the theoretical foundations of the PBP approach and how it relates to other reinforcement learning and generative modeling techniques, such as Dynamic Backtracking GFlowNets, Maximum Entropy GFlowNets, QGFN, Markov Flow Policy, and Forward Learning Graph Neural Networks. Further exploration of these connections could provide valuable insights and context for the PBP method.
Conclusion
The Pessimistic Backward Policy (PBP) introduced in this paper is a promising approach for improving the training and performance of Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets). By encouraging GFlowNets to consider the long-term implications of their actions, the PBP method can lead to more effective generation strategies and higher-quality samples.
While the paper demonstrates the benefits of the PBP approach on several benchmark tasks, further research is needed to explore the limitations, scalability, and theoretical underpinnings of the method. Comparing PBP to other advanced GFlowNet and generative modeling techniques could also yield valuable insights for the field.
Overall, the Pessimistic Backward Policy represents an important step forward in the development of more powerful and reliable generative models, with potential applications in areas such as molecular design, text generation, and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Looking Backward: Retrospective Backward Synthesis for Goal-Conditioned GFlowNets
Haoran He, Can Chang, Huazhe Xu, Ling Pan
0
0
Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets) are amortized sampling methods for learning a stochastic policy to sequentially generate compositional objects with probabilities proportional to their rewards. GFlowNets exhibit a remarkable ability to generate diverse sets of high-reward objects, in contrast to standard return maximization reinforcement learning approaches, which often converge to a single optimal solution. Recent works have arisen for learning goal-conditioned GFlowNets to acquire various useful properties, aiming to train a single GFlowNet capable of achieving different goals as the task specifies. However, training a goal-conditioned GFlowNet poses critical challenges due to extremely sparse rewards, which is further exacerbated in large state spaces. In this work, we propose a novel method named Retrospective Backward Synthesis (RBS) to address these challenges. Specifically, RBS synthesizes a new backward trajectory based on the backward policy in GFlowNets to enrich training trajectories with enhanced quality and diversity, thereby efficiently solving the sparse reward problem. Extensive empirical results show that our method improves sample efficiency by a large margin and outperforms strong baselines on various standard evaluation benchmarks.
6/4/2024
Bifurcated Generative Flow Networks
Chunhui Li, Cheng-Hao Liu, Dianbo Liu, Qingpeng Cai, Ling Pan
0
0
Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets), a new family of probabilistic samplers, have recently emerged as a promising framework for learning stochastic policies that generate high-quality and diverse objects proportionally to their rewards. However, existing GFlowNets often suffer from low data efficiency due to the direct parameterization of edge flows or reliance on backward policies that may struggle to scale up to large action spaces. In this paper, we introduce Bifurcated GFlowNets (BN), a novel approach that employs a bifurcated architecture to factorize the flows into separate representations for state flows and edge-based flow allocation. This factorization enables BN to learn more efficiently from data and better handle large-scale problems while maintaining the convergence guarantee. Through extensive experiments on standard evaluation benchmarks, we demonstrate that BN significantly improves learning efficiency and effectiveness compared to strong baselines.
6/5/2024
Rectifying Reinforcement Learning for Reward Matching
Haoran He, Emmanuel Bengio, Qingpeng Cai, Ling Pan
0
0
The Generative Flow Network (GFlowNet) is a probabilistic framework in which an agent learns a stochastic policy and flow functions to sample objects with probability proportional to an unnormalized reward function. GFlowNets share a strong resemblance to reinforcement learning (RL), that typically aims to maximize reward, due to their sequential decision-making processes. Recent works have studied connections between GFlowNets and maximum entropy (MaxEnt) RL, which modifies the standard objective of RL agents by learning an entropy-regularized objective. However, a critical theoretical gap persists: despite the apparent similarities in their sequential decision-making nature, a direct link between GFlowNets and standard RL has yet to be discovered, while bridging this gap could further unlock the potential of both fields. In this paper, we establish a new connection between GFlowNets and policy evaluation for a uniform policy. Surprisingly, we find that the resulting value function for the uniform policy has a close relationship to the flows in GFlowNets. Leveraging these insights, we further propose a novel rectified policy evaluation (RPE) algorithm, which achieves the same reward-matching effect as GFlowNets, offering a new perspective. We compare RPE, MaxEnt RL, and GFlowNets in a number of benchmarks, and show that RPE achieves competitive results compared to previous approaches. This work sheds light on the previously unexplored connection between (non-MaxEnt) RL and GFlowNets, potentially opening new avenues for future research in both fields.
6/5/2024
Dynamic Backtracking in GFlowNet: Enhancing Decision Steps with Reward-Dependent Adjustment Mechanisms
Shuai Guo, Jielei Chu, Lei Zhu, Zhaoyu Li, Tianrui Li
0
0
Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets or GFNs) are probabilistic models predicated on Markov flows, and they employ specific amortization algorithms to learn stochastic policies that generate compositional substances including biomolecules, chemical materials, etc. With a strong ability to generate high-performance biochemical molecules, GFNs accelerate the discovery of scientific substances, effectively overcoming the time-consuming, labor-intensive, and costly shortcomings of conventional material discovery methods. However, previous studies rarely focus on accumulating exploratory experience by adjusting generative structures, which leads to disorientation in complex sampling spaces. Efforts to address this issue, such as LS-GFN, are limited to local greedy searches and lack broader global adjustments. This paper introduces a novel variant of GFNs, the Dynamic Backtracking GFN (DB-GFN), which improves the adaptability of decision-making steps through a reward-based dynamic backtracking mechanism. DB-GFN allows backtracking during the network construction process according to the current state's reward value, thereby correcting disadvantageous decisions and exploring alternative pathways during the exploration process. When applied to generative tasks involving biochemical molecules and genetic material sequences, DB-GFN outperforms GFN models such as LS-GFN and GTB, as well as traditional reinforcement learning methods, in sample quality, sample exploration quantity, and training convergence speed. Additionally, owing to its orthogonal nature, DB-GFN shows great potential in future improvements of GFNs, and it can be integrated with other strategies to achieve higher search performance.
5/14/2024