Phrase-Level Adversarial Training for Mitigating Bias in Neural Network-based Automatic Essay Scoring

Overview

• The paper explores using phrase-level adversarial training to mitigate bias in neural network-based automatic essay scoring systems.
• The authors aim to reduce unwanted biases in essay scoring that could lead to unfair assessments for certain demographics.
• The proposed approach involves training the model to be invariant to sensitive attributes like gender and race while maintaining high scoring accuracy.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at a problem in automated essay scoring systems, where the models used to grade essays can sometimes be biased against certain groups of people. For example, the model might give lower scores to essays written by women or racial minorities, even if the content of the essay is equally strong.

To address this issue, the researchers developed a new training approach called phrase-level adversarial training. The idea is to train the model not just to accurately score the essays, but also to be "blind" to sensitive attributes like gender and race. That way, the model won't let those factors unfairly influence the score.

The key steps are:

1. Train the main essay scoring model as usual to predict high-quality scores.
2. Simultaneously train a separate "adversarial" model that tries to predict the sensitive attributes (like gender) from the essay text.
3. Encourage the main model to learn features that are useful for scoring, but not for predicting the sensitive attributes.

This adversarial training process helps the main model become more fair and unbiased in its essay assessments, without sacrificing too much accuracy. The researchers tested this approach on a dataset of essays and found it was effective at reducing demographic biases.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a phrase-level adversarial training approach to mitigate bias in neural network-based automatic essay scoring systems. The key technical components are:

1. Essay Scoring Model: This is the main model that takes an essay text as input and predicts a score for the essay quality. The authors use a BERT-based transformer model for this.

2. Adversarial Model: This is a separate model that takes the essay text as input and tries to predict sensitive demographic attributes like gender and race. The goal is to train the essay scoring model to be invariant to these sensitive attributes.

3. Adversarial Training: During training, the essay scoring model is optimized to both predict accurate essay scores and confuse the adversarial model's ability to predict the sensitive attributes. This is done by adding an adversarial loss term to the main scoring model's objective function.

The authors evaluate their approach on a dataset of essays written in Arabic. They find that the phrase-level adversarial training leads to significant reductions in demographic biases in the essay scoring, while maintaining competitive scoring accuracy compared to standard transformer-based models.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents an interesting and technically sound approach to addressing the important problem of bias mitigation in automated essay scoring systems. A few key points:

• Novelty: The use of phrase-level adversarial training to target bias is a novel contribution, building on prior work in adversarial debiasing.
• Scope: The evaluation is limited to a dataset of Arabic essays, so further work is needed to assess generalization across languages and domains.
• Limitations: The paper does not explore the potential tradeoffs between bias reduction and scoring accuracy. More analysis is needed on this front.
• Ethical Considerations: While the paper aims to reduce unfair biases, there are open questions around the ethical implications of such techniques and how to ensure they are deployed responsibly.

Overall, this is a valuable contribution to the field of fair and ethical AI systems, but more research is needed to fully understand the implications and limitations of the proposed approach.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel phrase-level adversarial training technique to mitigate demographic biases in neural network-based automatic essay scoring systems. By encouraging the scoring model to be invariant to sensitive attributes like gender and race, the approach can significantly reduce unwanted biases while maintaining competitive scoring performance.

The findings highlight the importance of addressing fairness and equity concerns in high-stakes AI applications like education assessment. Further research is needed to generalize the approach and fully characterize the tradeoffs involved. However, this work represents an important step towards more fair and inclusive automated essay scoring systems.