Procrastination Is All You Need: Exponent Indexed Accumulators for Floating Point, Posits and Logarithmic Numbers

Read original: arXiv:2406.05866 - Published 6/11/2024 by Vincenzo Liguori

🤖

Overview

Presents a simple and effective method for efficiently summing long sequences of floating-point numbers
Involves two phases: accumulation and reconstruction
Optimized for both FPGAs and ASICs, including techniques like fusing with a multiplier and creating efficient MACs
Demonstrates performance results, including a tensor core capable of high-throughput matrix multiplication and accumulation
Extends the method to posits and logarithmic number systems

Plain English Explanation

This paper describes a clever way to quickly add up long lists of decimal numbers represented in floating-point format. The key idea is to break the process into two steps:

Accumulation: First, the decimal parts (called "mantissas") of the floating-point numbers are added to different "buckets" or accumulators, depending on the exponents (the part that represents the decimal place value). This allows the additions to be done in parallel.
Reconstruction: Then, in the second step, the final summation result is calculated by combining the values in the different accumulators, taking the exponents into account.

The authors show how this technique can be efficiently implemented in hardware, both in FPGAs and application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs). They describe ways to integrate it with other arithmetic operations, like multiplication, to create high-performance "multiply-accumulate" units.

The paper presents some impressive performance numbers, including a tensor core that can multiply and accumulate two 4x4 matrices of 16-bit floating-point numbers (called "bfloat16") incredibly fast - over 700 million operations per second using just 6,400 lookup tables and 64 digital signal processing blocks on an AMD FPGA.

The authors also extend their method to handle other number formats like posits and logarithmic numbers, demonstrating its versatility.

Technical Explanation

The paper describes a two-phase approach for efficiently summing long sequences of floating-point numbers:

Accumulation Phase: In this phase, the mantissas of the input floating-point numbers are added to accumulators indexed by the exponents. This allows the additions to be performed in parallel, exploiting the fact that the exponents determine the decimal place value of each number.
Reconstruction Phase: In the second phase, the final summation result is reconstructed by combining the values in the different accumulators, taking the exponents into account.

The authors provide architectural details for implementing this method on both FPGAs and ASICs. Key optimizations include:

Fused Multiply-Accumulate (MAC): The floating-point addition can be fused with a multiplier to create an efficient MAC unit, leveraging the GPU implementations for integer addition and multiplication.
Exponent Tracking: The exponent tracking logic is designed to be compact and efficient, enabling high-performance implementations.

The paper presents results for FPGA implementations, including a tensor core capable of multiplying and accumulating two 4x4 matrices of bfloat16 values every clock cycle. This tensor core uses around 6,400 lookup tables (LUTs) and 64 digital signal processing (DSP) blocks on an AMD FPGA, operating at over 700 MHz.

Furthermore, the authors extend their method to work with posit and logarithmic number systems, demonstrating the versatility of their approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and effective method for efficiently summing long sequences of floating-point numbers. The two-phase approach, with the accumulation and reconstruction phases, is a clever way to leverage the structure of floating-point representations to achieve high performance.

The authors provide a thorough exploration of the architectural details, including the integration with multiply-accumulate units, which is essential for practical implementation. The performance results, particularly the tensor core example, are impressive and demonstrate the potential of this technique.

One potential limitation is the reliance on specialized hardware, such as FPGAs and ASICs, which may limit the widespread adoption of this method. However, the authors' extension to posits and logarithmic numbers suggests that the underlying principles could be applied more broadly, potentially inspiring efficient numerically-tailored computations in other domains.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the numerical accuracy implications of the proposed method, which could be an area for further research. Exploring the dynamic adaptation of floating-point containers or enabling 4-bit fixed-point accuracy in this context could provide valuable insights.

Overall, this paper presents a compelling and practical solution for a common computational challenge, and the authors' attention to hardware-efficient implementation is commendable.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a simple and effective method for efficiently summing long sequences of floating-point numbers. By breaking the process into two phases - accumulation and reconstruction - the technique leverages the structure of floating-point representations to achieve high performance, especially in specialized hardware like FPGAs and ASICs.

The authors demonstrate impressive results, including a tensor core capable of high-throughput matrix multiplication and accumulation. They also show the versatility of their approach by extending it to work with posit and logarithmic number systems.

While the reliance on specialized hardware may limit the immediate widespread adoption of this method, the underlying principles could inspire further research and development in the area of efficient numerically-tailored computations. Exploring the accuracy implications and potential integration with dynamic adaptation of floating-point containers or 4-bit fixed-point accuracy could also be fruitful areas for future research.

Overall, this paper presents a compelling and practical solution to a common computational challenge, with a strong focus on hardware-efficient implementation.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤖

Procrastination Is All You Need: Exponent Indexed Accumulators for Floating Point, Posits and Logarithmic Numbers

Vincenzo Liguori

This paper discusses a simple and effective method for the summation of long sequences of floating point numbers. The method comprises two phases: an accumulation phase where the mantissas of the floating point numbers are added to accumulators indexed by the exponents and a reconstruction phase where the actual summation result is finalised. Various architectural details are given for both FPGAs and ASICs including fusing the operation with a multiplier, creating efficient MACs. Some results are presented for FPGAs, including a tensor core capable of multiplying and accumulating two 4x4 matrices of bfloat16 values every clock cycle using ~6,400 LUTs + 64 DSP48 in AMD FPGAs at 700+ MHz. The method is then extended to posits and logarithmic numbers.

6/11/2024

🤿

Schrodinger's FP: Dynamic Adaptation of Floating-Point Containers for Deep Learning Training

Milov{s} Nikoli'c, Enrique Torres Sanchez, Jiahui Wang, Ali Hadi Zadeh, Mostafa Mahmoud, Ameer Abdelhadi, Kareem Ibrahim, Andreas Moshovos

The transfer of tensors from/to memory during neural network training dominates time and energy. To improve energy efficiency and performance, research has been exploring ways to use narrower data representations. So far, these attempts relied on user-directed trial-and-error to achieve convergence. We present methods that relieve users from this responsibility. Our methods dynamically adjust the size and format of the floating-point containers used for activations and weights during training, achieving adaptivity across three dimensions: i) which datatype to use, ii) on which tensor, and iii) how it changes over time. The different meanings and distributions of exponent and mantissas lead us to tailored approaches for each. We present two lossy pairs of methods to eliminate as many mantissa and exponent bits as possible without affecting accuracy. Quantum Mantissa and Quantum Exponent are machine learning compression methods that tap into the gradient descent algorithm to learn the minimal mantissa and exponent bitlengths on a per-layer granularity. They automatically learn that many tensors can use just 1 or 2 mantissa bits and 3 or 4 exponent bits. Overall, the two machine learning methods reduce the footprint by $4.74times$. Alternatively, BitWave observes changes in the loss function during training to adjust mantissa and exponent bitlengths network-wide, yielding a $3.19times$ reduction in footprint. Finally, we present an optional method, Gecko, to exploit the naturally emerging, lop-sided exponent distribution to losslessly compress resulting exponents from Quantum Exponent or BitWave and, on average, improve compression rates to $5.64times$ and $4.56times$.

5/20/2024

🔗

Fast multiplication by two's complement addition of numbers represented as a set of polynomial radix 2 indexes, stored as an integer list for massively parallel computation

Mark Stocks

We demonstrate a multiplication method based on numbers represented as set of polynomial radix 2 indices stored as an integer list. The 'polynomial integer index multiplication' method is a set of algorithms implemented in python code. We demonstrate the method to be faster than both the Number Theoretic Transform (NTT) and Karatsuba for multiplication within a certain bit range. Also implemented in python code for comparison purposes with the polynomial radix 2 integer method. We demonstrate that it is possible to express any integer or real number as a list of integer indices, representing a finite series in base two. The finite series of integer index representation of a number can then be stored and distributed across multiple CPUs / GPUs. We show that operations of addition and multiplication can be applied as two's complement additions operating on the index integer representations and can be fully distributed across a given CPU / GPU architecture. We demonstrate fully distributed arithmetic operations such that the 'polynomial integer index multiplication' method overcomes the current limitation of parallel multiplication methods. Ie, the need to share common core memory and common disk for the calculation of results and intermediate results.

7/30/2024

🎯

Accuracy Booster: Enabling 4-bit Fixed-point Arithmetic for DNN Training

Simla Burcu Harma, Ayan Chakraborty, Nicholas Sperry, Babak Falsafi, Martin Jaggi, Yunho Oh

The unprecedented demand for computing resources to train DNN models has led to a search for minimal numerical encoding. Recent state-of-the-art (SOTA) proposals advocate for multi-level scaled narrow bitwidth numerical formats. In this paper, we show that single-level scaling is sufficient to maintain training accuracy while maximizing arithmetic density. We identify a previously proposed single-level scaled format for 8-bit training, Hybrid Block Floating Point (HBFP), as the optimal candidate to minimize. We perform a full-scale exploration of the HBFP design space using mathematical tools to study the interplay among various parameters and identify opportunities for even smaller encodings across layers and epochs. Based on our findings, we propose Accuracy Booster, a mixed-mantissa HBFP technique that uses 4-bit mantissas for over 99% of all arithmetic operations in training and 6-bit mantissas only in the last epoch and first/last layers. We show Accuracy Booster enables increasing arithmetic density over all other SOTA formats by at least 2.3x while achieving state-of-the-art accuracies in 4-bit training.

6/3/2024