Projection-free Online Learning over Strongly Convex Sets

Overview

• The paper focuses on developing efficient projection-free algorithms for online learning with complicated constraints.
• Existing efficient projection-free algorithms, such as Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW) and its variants, have only achieved a regret bound of $O(T^{3/4})$, which is worse than projection-based algorithms.
• The paper studies the special case of online learning over strongly convex sets and proposes improvements to OFW to achieve better regret bounds.

Plain English Explanation

When faced with online optimization problems that have complex constraints, projection-free algorithms like Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW) have gained attention as an efficient solution. However, in general, these algorithms have only been able to achieve a regret bound of $O(T^{3/4})$, which means their performance is not as good as projection-based algorithms, where $T$ is the number of decision rounds.

The researchers in this paper look at a special case where the feasible set is strongly convex. For this setting, they show that by refining the step-size rule used in the original OFW algorithm, they can achieve a better regret bound of $O(T^{2/3})$ for general convex loss functions. Furthermore, they propose a strongly convex variant of OFW that can achieve an even better regret bound of $O(\sqrt{T})$ over strongly convex sets.

The key ideas are to use a simple line search rule to set the step-size in OFW and to redefine the surrogate loss function in a way that exploits the strong convexity of the feasible set. These modifications allow the algorithms to converge faster and achieve tighter regret bounds compared to the original OFW.

Technical Explanation

The paper studies the problem of online learning with complicated constraints, where projection-free algorithms like Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW) and its variants have shown promise. However, in the general case, the best regret bound achieved by these efficient projection-free algorithms is $O(T^{3/4})$, which is worse than the regret of projection-based algorithms.

To address this, the researchers focus on the special case of online learning over strongly convex sets. They first prove that by refining the decaying step-size rule in the original OFW algorithm, it can enjoy a better regret bound of $O(T^{2/3})$ for general convex loss functions.

Furthermore, the researchers propose a strongly convex variant of OFW, where they redefine the surrogate loss function used in the original OFW. This strongly convex variant achieves a regret bound of $O(T^{2/3})$ over general convex sets and an even better regret bound of $O(\sqrt{T})$ over strongly convex sets.

The key insights behind these improvements are:

1. Using a simple line search rule to set the step-size in OFW, rather than the original decaying step-size, can lead to faster convergence and tighter regret bounds.
2. Redefining the surrogate loss function in OFW to better exploit the strong convexity of the feasible set can further improve the regret bounds.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents an interesting approach to improving the performance of projection-free algorithms, like Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW), for online learning problems with complicated constraints. The researchers focus on the special case of strongly convex feasible sets, which is a reasonable assumption in many practical applications.

One potential limitation of the work is that it may not generalize well to more general, non-strongly convex feasible sets. The researchers acknowledge this and suggest that extending their techniques to the general case is an important direction for future research.

Additionally, the paper does not provide any experimental validation of the proposed algorithms. While the theoretical analysis is well-developed, it would be helpful to see how the algorithms perform in practice and how they compare to other state-of-the-art projection-free and projection-based algorithms.

Overall, the paper presents a solid theoretical contribution, but further empirical evaluation and exploration of the limitations of the proposed techniques would strengthen the work and provide a more complete picture of their potential impact on the field of online optimization.

Conclusion

This paper focuses on improving the performance of projection-free algorithms, such as Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW) and its variants, for online learning problems with complicated constraints. By studying the special case of online learning over strongly convex sets, the researchers were able to develop refinements to the OFW algorithm that achieve better regret bounds compared to the original OFW.

The key ideas include using a simple line search rule to set the step-size in OFW and redefining the surrogate loss function to better exploit the strong convexity of the feasible set. These modifications allow the algorithms to converge faster and achieve tighter regret bounds, with the strongly convex variant achieving an $O(\sqrt{T})$ regret bound over strongly convex sets.

While the theoretical contributions of this work are significant, further empirical evaluation and exploration of the limitations of the proposed techniques would help to fully assess their potential impact on the field of online optimization and their applicability to real-world problems.