QAGCN: Answering Multi-Relation Questions via Single-Step Implicit Reasoning over Knowledge Graphs
2206.01818
0
0
🔮
Abstract
Multi-relation question answering (QA) is a challenging task, where given questions usually require long reasoning chains in KGs that consist of multiple relations. Recently, methods with explicit multi-step reasoning over KGs have been prominently used in this task and have demonstrated promising performance. Examples include methods that perform stepwise label propagation through KG triples and methods that navigate over KG triples based on reinforcement learning. A main weakness of these methods is that their reasoning mechanisms are usually complex and difficult to implement or train. In this paper, we argue that multi-relation QA can be achieved via end-to-end single-step implicit reasoning, which is simpler, more efficient, and easier to adopt. We propose QAGCN -- a Question-Aware Graph Convolutional Network (GCN)-based method that includes a novel GCN architecture with controlled question-dependent message propagation for the implicit reasoning. Extensive experiments have been conducted, where QAGCN achieved competitive and even superior performance compared to state-of-the-art explicit-reasoning methods. Our code and pre-trained models are available in the repository: https://github.com/ruijie-wang-uzh/QAGCN
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Multi-relation question answering (QA) is a challenging task that requires long reasoning chains in knowledge graphs (KGs) with multiple relations.
- Recently, methods with explicit multi-step reasoning over KGs have shown promising performance, but their reasoning mechanisms are often complex and difficult to implement or train.
- The paper proposes QAGCN - a Question-Aware Graph Convolutional Network (GCN)-based method that achieves multi-relation QA via end-to-end single-step implicit reasoning, which is simpler, more efficient, and easier to adopt.
Plain English Explanation
Knowledge graphs are like databases that store information as a network of connected facts. For example, a knowledge graph might contain information that "Paris is the capital of France" and "France is in Europe." To answer questions that require reasoning across multiple connections in the knowledge graph, such as "What is the capital of the country that France is in?", previous methods have used complex, multi-step reasoning processes.
The paper argues that this type of multi-relation question answering can actually be achieved through a simpler, single-step reasoning process. The proposed QAGCN method uses a novel graph convolutional network (GCN) architecture that can implicitly reason about the question and the knowledge graph to find the answer, without the need for an explicit, multi-step reasoning process.
The key advantage of this approach is that it is simpler to implement and train, while still achieving competitive or even superior performance compared to the more complex, multi-step reasoning methods. This makes it easier for researchers and developers to apply this technique to real-world knowledge-based question answering tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a Question-Aware Graph Convolutional Network (QAGCN) method for multi-relation question answering. QAGCN uses a novel GCN architecture that incorporates a question-dependent message propagation mechanism to enable implicit, single-step reasoning over the knowledge graph.
The key elements of the QAGCN method include:
-
Question-Aware GCN: The GCN layers in QAGCN are designed to propagate information from the knowledge graph nodes to the question representation, allowing the model to learn how the question relates to the relevant entities and relations in the graph.
-
Controlled Message Propagation: QAGCN uses a gating mechanism to control the flow of information during the message propagation process, ensuring that the question representation can selectively attend to the most relevant parts of the knowledge graph.
-
End-to-End Training: QAGCN is trained end-to-end, directly optimizing the question answering performance without the need for explicit multi-step reasoning or intermediate supervision signals.
The authors conduct extensive experiments on benchmark multi-relation QA datasets, comparing QAGCN to state-of-the-art explicit reasoning methods, such as those that perform stepwise label propagation or reinforcement learning-based navigation. The results show that QAGCN can achieve competitive or even superior performance, while being simpler and more efficient to implement and train.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling argument for the benefits of implicit, single-step reasoning for multi-relation question answering. By avoiding the complexity of explicit, multi-step reasoning methods, the QAGCN approach can be more easily adopted and applied to real-world knowledge-based QA tasks.
However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of the proposed method. For example, it is unclear how QAGCN would perform on more challenging or ambiguous questions that require deeper, more nuanced reasoning. The authors also do not discuss the interpretability of the QAGCN model, which is an important consideration for many real-world applications.
Additionally, the paper could have provided more insight into the specific mechanisms and architectural choices that enable the implicit reasoning capabilities of QAGCN. A deeper dive into the inner workings of the model would help readers better understand the key innovations and their significance.
Overall, the paper presents a promising approach to multi-relation question answering, but further research and analysis would be needed to fully assess its strengths, limitations, and potential areas for improvement.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a novel Question-Aware Graph Convolutional Network (QAGCN) method that can perform multi-relation question answering through a simpler, end-to-end single-step implicit reasoning process. By avoiding the complexity of explicit, multi-step reasoning approaches, QAGCN demonstrates competitive or even superior performance while being more efficient and easier to implement.
This work has the potential to significantly impact the field of knowledge-based question answering, as the simpler and more scalable nature of the QAGCN approach could enable its wider adoption and application in real-world scenarios. Further research into the interpretability and robustness of the model could help unlock its full potential and address any remaining limitations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
GNN-RAG: Graph Neural Retrieval for Large Language Model Reasoning
Costas Mavromatis, George Karypis
0
0
Knowledge Graphs (KGs) represent human-crafted factual knowledge in the form of triplets (head, relation, tail), which collectively form a graph. Question Answering over KGs (KGQA) is the task of answering natural questions grounding the reasoning to the information provided by the KG. Large Language Models (LLMs) are the state-of-the-art models for QA tasks due to their remarkable ability to understand natural language. On the other hand, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have been widely used for KGQA as they can handle the complex graph information stored in the KG. In this work, we introduce GNN-RAG, a novel method for combining language understanding abilities of LLMs with the reasoning abilities of GNNs in a retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) style. First, a GNN reasons over a dense KG subgraph to retrieve answer candidates for a given question. Second, the shortest paths in the KG that connect question entities and answer candidates are extracted to represent KG reasoning paths. The extracted paths are verbalized and given as input for LLM reasoning with RAG. In our GNN-RAG framework, the GNN acts as a dense subgraph reasoner to extract useful graph information, while the LLM leverages its natural language processing ability for ultimate KGQA. Furthermore, we develop a retrieval augmentation (RA) technique to further boost KGQA performance with GNN-RAG. Experimental results show that GNN-RAG achieves state-of-the-art performance in two widely used KGQA benchmarks (WebQSP and CWQ), outperforming or matching GPT-4 performance with a 7B tuned LLM. In addition, GNN-RAG excels on multi-hop and multi-entity questions outperforming competing approaches by 8.9--15.5% points at answer F1.
5/31/2024
CuriousLLM: Elevating Multi-Document QA with Reasoning-Infused Knowledge Graph Prompting
Zukang Yang, Zixuan Zhu
0
0
In the field of Question Answering (QA), unifying large language models (LLMs) with external databases has shown great success. However, these methods often fall short in providing the advanced reasoning needed for complex QA tasks. To address these issues, we improve over a novel approach called Knowledge Graph Prompting (KGP), which combines knowledge graphs with a LLM-based agent to improve reasoning and search accuracy. Nevertheless, the original KGP framework necessitates costly fine-tuning with large datasets yet still suffers from LLM hallucination. Therefore, we propose a reasoning-infused LLM agent to enhance this framework. This agent mimics human curiosity to ask follow-up questions to more efficiently navigate the search. This simple modification significantly boosts the LLM performance in QA tasks without the high costs and latency associated with the initial KGP framework. Our ultimate goal is to further develop this approach, leading to more accurate, faster, and cost-effective solutions in the QA domain.
4/16/2024
Move Beyond Triples: Contextual Knowledge Graph Representation and Reasoning
Chengjin Xu, Muzhi Li, Cehao Yang, Xuhui Jiang, Lumingyuan Tang, Yiyan Qi, Jian Guo
0
0
Knowledge Graphs (KGs) are foundational structures in many AI applications, representing entities and their interrelations through triples. However, triple-based KGs lack the contextual information of relational knowledge, like temporal dynamics and provenance details, which are crucial for comprehensive knowledge representation and effective reasoning. Instead, textbf{Context Graphs} (CGs) expand upon the conventional structure by incorporating additional information such as time validity, geographic location, and source provenance. This integration provides a more nuanced and accurate understanding of knowledge, enabling KGs to offer richer insights and support more sophisticated reasoning processes. In this work, we first discuss the inherent limitations of triple-based KGs and introduce the concept of CGs, highlighting their advantages in knowledge representation and reasoning. We then present a context graph reasoning textbf{CGR$^3$} paradigm that leverages large language models (LLMs) to retrieve candidate entities and related contexts, rank them based on the retrieved information, and reason whether sufficient information has been obtained to answer a query. Our experimental results demonstrate that CGR$^3$ significantly improves performance on KG completion (KGC) and KG question answering (KGQA) tasks, validating the effectiveness of incorporating contextual information on KG representation and reasoning.
7/1/2024
Improving Multi-hop Logical Reasoning in Knowledge Graphs with Context-Aware Query Representation Learning
Jeonghoon Kim, Heesoo Jung, Hyeju Jang, Hogun Park
0
0
Multi-hop logical reasoning on knowledge graphs is a pivotal task in natural language processing, with numerous approaches aiming to answer First-Order Logic (FOL) queries. Recent geometry (e.g., box, cone) and probability (e.g., beta distribution)-based methodologies have effectively addressed complex FOL queries. However, a common challenge across these methods lies in determining accurate geometric bounds or probability parameters for these queries. The challenge arises because existing methods rely on linear sequential operations within their computation graphs, overlooking the logical structure of the query and the relation-induced information that can be gleaned from the relations of the query, which we call the context of the query. To address the problem, we propose a model-agnostic methodology that enhances the effectiveness of existing multi-hop logical reasoning approaches by fully integrating the context of the FOL query graph. Our approach distinctively discerns (1) the structural context inherent to the query structure and (2) the relation-induced context unique to each node in the query graph as delineated in the corresponding knowledge graph. This dual-context paradigm helps nodes within a query graph attain refined internal representations throughout the multi-hop reasoning steps. Through experiments on two datasets, our method consistently enhances the three multi-hop reasoning foundation models, achieving performance improvements of up to 19.5%. Our code is available at https://github.com/kjh9503/caqr.
6/12/2024