Conversational Question Answering with Reformulations over Knowledge Graph

Overview

• Conversational question answering (ConvQA) involves answering natural language questions about information in a knowledge graph (KG), with a focus on questions that require understanding conversation history.
• Current state-of-the-art ConvQA methods often struggle with questions that are not directly explicit, which are easy for humans to understand but difficult for machines.
• The researchers propose a reinforcement learning-based model called CornNet to address this problem by using question reformulations generated by large language models to improve ConvQA performance.

Plain English Explanation

Conversational question answering is the task of answering questions about information in a knowledge graph, where the questions are asked in natural language and may require understanding the context of a conversation. Current advanced models for this task often have trouble with questions that are not straightforward or directly stated, even though humans can typically understand these types of questions given the conversation history.

To address this issue, the researchers developed a model called CornNet that uses reinforcement learning and takes advantage of rephrased versions of the questions generated by large language models. The idea is that these rephrased questions can help the model better grasp the intent behind the original, more indirect question. CornNet has a "teacher" component that learns to represent the questions using the human-written reformulations, and a "student" component that tries to mimic the teacher's output using the machine-generated reformulations. This learned question representation is then used by the reinforcement learning part of the model to locate the correct answer in the knowledge graph.

The researchers show through extensive experiments that CornNet outperforms other state-of-the-art conversational question answering models, especially on the more challenging, indirectly stated questions.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose a reinforcement learning-based model called CornNet to address the challenge of conversational question answering (ConvQA) over knowledge graphs (KGs). ConvQA involves answering natural language questions about information contained in a KG, with a focus on questions that require understanding the context of a conversation.

CornNet utilizes question reformulations generated by large language models (LLMs) to improve ConvQA performance. The model adopts a teacher-student architecture, where the teacher model learns question representations using human-written reformulations, and the student model tries to mimic the teacher's output using LLM-generated reformulations. The learned question representation is then used by a reinforcement learning (RL) model to locate the correct answer in the KG.

The key insight is that the question reformulations, both human-written and LLM-generated, can help the model better understand the intent behind the original, potentially inexplicit question, which is a common challenge in ConvQA. The teacher-student setup allows the model to leverage the human-written reformulations to learn effective question representations, while the student model's ability to generate similar reformulations using LLMs enables the RL component to locate the correct answer in the KG.

Extensive experimental results on benchmark ConvQA datasets show that CornNet outperforms state-of-the-art ConvQA models, particularly on questions that are harder due to their implicit nature.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that CornNet relies on the availability of LLMs to generate the question reformulations, which may not always be feasible in practice. They also note that the performance of CornNet is dependent on the quality of the reformulations produced by the LLMs, which could be a potential limitation.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the types of questions or conversational contexts where CornNet excels or struggles the most. It would be helpful to understand the specific characteristics of the questions that benefit the most from the question reformulation approach.

Further research could explore ways to make CornNet more robust to variations in LLM quality or availability, or to investigate alternative methods for generating useful question reformulations. Exploring the integration of CornNet with other ConvQA techniques, such as multi-hop reasoning or knowledge graph expansion, could also be a fruitful direction.

Conclusion

The CornNet model proposed in this paper represents an innovative approach to addressing the challenges of conversational question answering over knowledge graphs. By leveraging question reformulations generated by large language models, CornNet is able to outperform other state-of-the-art ConvQA models, particularly on questions that are more indirectly stated and require a deeper understanding of the conversational context.

While the model relies on the availability of high-quality language models, the core idea of using reformulations to enhance question representation and reasoning is a promising direction for advancing the field of conversational question answering. As language models continue to improve and become more widely accessible, the impact of CornNet-like approaches could become increasingly significant, leading to better conversational AI systems that can more effectively interact with and answer questions about the wealth of information stored in knowledge graphs.