QREChem: Quantum Resource Estimation Software for Chemistry Applications
0
๐งช
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- As quantum hardware continues to improve, more scientists are working on quantum computing applications.
- Even with recent advancements, quantum devices still struggle to outperform classical computers for certain quantum chemistry problems.
- It's important to have a systematic way to estimate the resources needed to tackle specific quantum chemistry problems.
- The paper introduces QREChem, a tool to provide logical resource estimates for ground state energy estimation in quantum chemistry.
Plain English Explanation
Quantum computers are getting better and better, and more and more scientists are starting to work on using them for real-world applications. However, even with all the progress in the last few years, quantum devices, especially for quantum chemistry problems, still can't do calculations that regular computers can't already do.
Since quantum computers can't quite overtake classical computers yet, it's important to have a way to figure out how much time, energy, and other resources would be needed to use a quantum computer to solve specific chemistry problems. The standard ways of thinking about computational complexity give hope that quantum computers will be useful for quantum chemistry, but they don't show the full picture of all the practical challenges involved.
To help address this, the researchers developed a tool called QREChem. QREChem can estimate the resources needed to use a quantum computer to calculate the ground state energy of molecules, which is an important problem in quantum chemistry. QREChem does this by taking into account specific challenges involved in quantum chemistry problems, like how many times the quantum computer needs to repeat a calculation and how many extra "helper" qubits are required. This allows for more accurate estimates of the total number of operations the quantum computer would need to perform.
The researchers used QREChem to estimate the resources required for a variety of small molecules, getting numbers ranging from 10 million to 1 quintillion total quantum logic gates. They also looked at a larger, more complex molecule called FeMoco and compared their estimates to other resource estimation tools.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces QREChem, a tool to provide logical resource estimates for ground state energy estimation in quantum chemistry using a Trotter-based quantum phase estimation approach. QREChem incorporates heuristic estimates of the number of Trotter steps and necessary ancilla qubits to provide more accurate overall gate count estimates, taking into account the specific overheads inherent to quantum chemistry problems.
The researchers utilize QREChem to generate resource estimates for a variety of small molecules in different basis sets, obtaining total T gate counts ranging from 10^7 to 10^15. They also provide resource estimates for the more complex FeMoco molecule and compare their results to other quantum resource estimation tools.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution by introducing a systematic approach to estimating the resources required for quantum chemistry calculations on near-term quantum hardware. The inclusion of heuristic estimates for Trotter steps and ancilla qubits is an important advancement over previous complexity-based resource estimates, which can overlook practical implementation details.
However, the accuracy of the QREChem estimates ultimately relies on the validity of the heuristic models used, which are not thoroughly validated in the paper. Further research would be needed to test the robustness of these heuristics across a wider range of molecules and quantum chemistry problems.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential sources of error or noise in the quantum computations, which could significantly impact the resources required for fault-tolerant implementations. Incorporating error models into the resource estimation framework could provide a more comprehensive assessment of the challenges facing near-term quantum chemistry applications.
Conclusion
The QREChem tool introduced in this paper represents an important step forward in quantifying the practical resources needed to tackle quantum chemistry problems on near-term quantum hardware. By accounting for implementation-specific overheads, QREChem provides more realistic estimates than previous complexity-based approaches. While further research is needed to validate the heuristic models, this work highlights the value of systematic resource estimation in guiding the development of useful quantum chemistry applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐งช
0
QREChem: Quantum Resource Estimation Software for Chemistry Applications
Matthew Otten, Byeol Kang, Dmitry Fedorov, Anouar Benali, Salman Habib, Yuri Alexeev, Stephen K. Gray
As quantum hardware continues to improve, more and more application scientists have entered the field of quantum computing. However, even with the rapid improvements in the last few years, quantum devices, especially for quantum chemistry applications, still struggle to perform calculations that classical computers could not calculate. In lieu of being able to perform specific calculations, it is important have a systematic way of estimating the resources necessary to tackle specific problems. Standard arguments about computational complexity provide hope that quantum computers will be useful for problems in quantum chemistry but obscure the true impact of many algorithmic overheads. These overheads will ultimately determine the precise point when quantum computers will perform better than classical computers. We have developed QREChem to provide logical resource estimates for ground state energy estimation in quantum chemistry through a Trotter-based quantum phase estimation approach. QREChem provides resource estimates which include the specific overheads inherent to problems in quantum chemistry by including heuristic estimates of the number of Trotter steps and number of necessary ancilla, allowing for more accurate estimates of the total number of gates. We utilize QREChem to provide logical resource estimates for a variety of small molecules in various basis sets, obtaining estimates in the range of $10^7-10^{15}$ for total number of T gates. We also determine estimates for the FeMoco molecule and compare all estimates to other resource estimation tools.
Read more4/26/2024
0
Integrating Quantum Computing Resources into Scientific HPC Ecosystems
Thomas Beck, Alessandro Baroni, Ryan Bennink, Gilles Buchs, Eduardo Antonio Coello Perez, Markus Eisenbach, Rafael Ferreira da Silva, Muralikrishnan Gopalakrishnan Meena, Kalyan Gottiparthi, Peter Groszkowski, Travis S. Humble, Ryan Landfield, Ketan Maheshwari, Sarp Oral, Michael A. Sandoval, Amir Shehata, In-Saeng Suh, Christopher Zimmer
Quantum Computing (QC) offers significant potential to enhance scientific discovery in fields such as quantum chemistry, optimization, and artificial intelligence. Yet QC faces challenges due to the noisy intermediate-scale quantum era's inherent external noise issues. This paper discusses the integration of QC as a computational accelerator within classical scientific high-performance computing (HPC) systems. By leveraging a broad spectrum of simulators and hardware technologies, we propose a hardware-agnostic framework for augmenting classical HPC with QC capabilities. Drawing on the HPC expertise of the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and the HPC lifecycle management of the Department of Energy (DOE), our approach focuses on the strategic incorporation of QC capabilities and acceleration into existing scientific HPC workflows. This includes detailed analyses, benchmarks, and code optimization driven by the needs of the DOE and ORNL missions. Our comprehensive framework integrates hardware, software, workflows, and user interfaces to foster a synergistic environment for quantum and classical computing research. This paper outlines plans to unlock new computational possibilities, driving forward scientific inquiry and innovation in a wide array of research domains.
Read more8/30/2024
๐ฏ
0
Resource-Efficient and Self-Adaptive Quantum Search in a Quantum-Classical Hybrid System
Zihao Jiang, Zefan Du, Shaolun Ruan, Juntao Chen, Yong Wang, Long Cheng, Rajkumar Buyya, Ying Mao
Over the past decade, the rapid advancement of deep learning and big data applications has been driven by vast datasets and high-performance computing systems. However, as we approach the physical limits of semiconductor fabrication in the post-Moore's Law era, questions arise about the future of these applications. In parallel, quantum computing has made significant progress with the potential to break limits. Major companies like IBM, Google, and Microsoft provide access to noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. Despite the theoretical promise of Shor's and Grover's algorithms, practical implementation on current quantum devices faces challenges, such as demanding additional resources and a high number of controlled operations. To tackle these challenges and optimize the utilization of limited onboard qubits, we introduce ReSaQuS, a resource-efficient index-value searching system within a quantum-classical hybrid framework. Building on Grover's algorithm, ReSaQuS employs an automatically managed iterative search approach. This method analyzes problem size, filters fewer probable data points, and progressively reduces the dataset with decreasing qubit requirements. Implemented using Qiskit and evaluated through extensive experiments, ReSaQuS has demonstrated a substantial reduction, up to 86.36% in cumulative qubit consumption and 72.72% in active periods, reinforcing its potential in optimizing quantum computing application deployment.
Read more5/8/2024
๐ฟ
0
Resource Optimized Quantum Squaring Circuit
Afrin Sultana, Edgard Mu~noz-Coreas
Quantum squaring operation is a useful building block in implementing quantum algorithms such as linear regression, regularized least squares algorithm, order-finding algorithm, quantum search algorithm, Newton Raphson division, Euclidean distance calculation, cryptography, and in finding roots and reciprocals. Quantum circuits could be made fault-tolerant by using error correcting codes and fault-tolerant quantum gates (such as the Clifford + T-gates). However, the T-gate is very costly to implement. Two qubit gates (such as the CNOT-gate) are more prone to noise errors than single qubit gates. Consequently, in order to realize reliable quantum algorithms, the quantum circuits should have a low T-count and CNOT-count. In this paper, we present a novel quantum integer squaring architecture optimized for T-count, CNOT-count, T-depth, CNOT-depth, and $KQ_T$ that produces no garbage outputs. To reduce costs, we use a novel approach for arranging the generated partial products that allows us to reduce the number of adders by 50%. We also use the resource efficient logical-AND gate and uncomputation gate shown in [1] to further save resources. The proposed quantum squaring circuit sees an asymptotic reduction of 66.67% in T-count, 50% in T-depth, 29.41% in CNOT-count, 42.86% in CNOT-depth, and 25% in KQ T with respect to Thapliyal et al. [2]. With respect to Nagamani et al. [3] the design sees an asymptotic reduction of 77.27% in T-count, 68.75% in T-depth, 50% in CNOT-count, 61.90% in CNOT-depth, and 6.25% in the $KQ_T$.
Read more6/5/2024