Recommender Systems Algorithm Selection for Ranking Prediction on Implicit Feedback Datasets
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Recommender systems are algorithms that provide personalized product or content recommendations to users.
- Selecting the most appropriate algorithm for a given dataset and task is critical for optimizing performance.
- This paper presents an automated algorithm selection framework for ranking prediction on implicit feedback datasets.
Plain English Explanation
Recommender systems are tools that suggest products or content to users based on their preferences and behavior. Choosing the right algorithm for a specific dataset and task is crucial for ensuring these systems perform well.
This paper introduces an automated framework to help select the most suitable algorithm for ranking prediction on datasets with implicit feedback, such as viewing or purchasing history. The goal is to streamline the process of finding the best-performing algorithm without extensive manual testing.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose an AutoRecSys framework that automatically evaluates and selects the most appropriate recommender system algorithm for a given dataset and task. The framework includes the following key components:
- Dataset Characterization: It analyzes the input dataset to extract relevant features, such as sparsity, user/item statistics, and interaction patterns.
- Algorithm Selection: It uses the dataset features to select the most promising algorithms from a pool of candidates, based on their historical performance on similar datasets.
- Hyperparameter Optimization: It optimizes the hyperparameters of the selected algorithms to further improve their performance on the target dataset.
- Performance Evaluation: It evaluates the optimized algorithms and selects the best-performing one for the given task and dataset.
The authors validate their approach on several publicly available implicit feedback datasets, demonstrating its effectiveness in selecting high-performing recommender system algorithms.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive and well-designed framework for automating the algorithm selection process for recommender systems. However, the authors acknowledge that the framework's performance may be sensitive to the initial pool of algorithms and the quality of the dataset characterization features.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential biases or fairness implications of the selected algorithms, which is an important consideration in real-world recommender systems. Further research could investigate these aspects to ensure the framework produces ethical and unbiased recommendations.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an automated recommender system algorithm selection framework that can help optimize the performance of ranking prediction tasks on implicit feedback datasets. By automating the algorithm selection and hyperparameter optimization process, the framework has the potential to streamline the development of effective recommender systems and reduce the burden on researchers and practitioners. The approach demonstrates the value of combining dataset analysis, algorithm selection, and optimization to enhance recommender system performance.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Recommender Systems Algorithm Selection for Ranking Prediction on Implicit Feedback Datasets
Lukas Wegmeth, Tobias Vente, Joeran Beel
The recommender systems algorithm selection problem for ranking prediction on implicit feedback datasets is under-explored. Traditional approaches in recommender systems algorithm selection focus predominantly on rating prediction on explicit feedback datasets, leaving a research gap for ranking prediction on implicit feedback datasets. Algorithm selection is a critical challenge for nearly every practitioner in recommender systems. In this work, we take the first steps toward addressing this research gap. We evaluate the NDCG@10 of 24 recommender systems algorithms, each with two hyperparameter configurations, on 72 recommender systems datasets. We train four optimized machine-learning meta-models and one automated machine-learning meta-model with three different settings on the resulting meta-dataset. Our results show that the predictions of all tested meta-models exhibit a median Spearman correlation ranging from 0.857 to 0.918 with the ground truth. We show that the median Spearman correlation between meta-model predictions and the ground truth increases by an average of 0.124 when the meta-model is optimized to predict the ranking of algorithms instead of their performance. Furthermore, in terms of predicting the best algorithm for an unknown dataset, we demonstrate that the best optimized traditional meta-model, e.g., XGBoost, achieves a recall of 48.6%, outperforming the best tested automated machine learning meta-model, e.g., AutoGluon, which achieves a recall of 47.2%.
Read more9/10/2024
0
Rethinking Recommender Systems: Cluster-based Algorithm Selection
Andreas Lizenberger, Ferdinand Pfeifer, Bastian Polewka
Cluster-based algorithm selection deals with selecting recommendation algorithms on clusters of users to obtain performance gains. No studies have been attempted for many combinations of clustering approaches and recommendation algorithms. We want to show that clustering users prior to algorithm selection increases the performance of recommendation algorithms. Our study covers eight datasets, four clustering approaches, and eight recommendation algorithms. We select the best performing recommendation algorithm for each cluster. Our work shows that cluster-based algorithm selection is an effective technique for optimizing recommendation algorithm performance. For five out of eight datasets, we report an increase in nDCG@10 between 19.28% (0.032) and 360.38% (0.191) compared to algorithm selection without prior clustering.
Read more5/29/2024
🎯
0
Predictive accuracy of recommender algorithms
William Noffsinger
Recommender systems present a customized list of items based upon user or item characteristics with the objective of reducing a large number of possible choices to a smaller ranked set most likely to appeal to the user. A variety of algorithms for recommender systems have been developed and refined including applications of deep learning neural networks. Recent research reports point to a need to perform carefully controlled experiments to gain insights about the relative accuracy of different recommender algorithms, because studies evaluating different methods have not used a common set of benchmark data sets, baseline models, and evaluation metrics. This investigation used publicly available sources of ratings data with a suite of three conventional recommender algorithms and two deep learning (DL) algorithms in controlled experiments to assess their comparative accuracy. Results for the non-DL algorithms conformed well to published results and benchmarks. The two DL algorithms did not perform as well and illuminated known challenges implementing DL recommender algorithms as reported in the literature. Model overfitting is discussed as a potential explanation for the weaker performance of the DL algorithms and several regularization strategies are reviewed as possible approaches to improve predictive error. Findings justify the need for further research in the use of deep learning models for recommender systems.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Towards Fair and Rigorous Evaluations: Hyperparameter Optimization for Top-N Recommendation Task with Implicit Feedback
Hui Fang, Xu Feng, Lu Qin, Zhu Sun
The widespread use of the internet has led to an overwhelming amount of data, which has resulted in the problem of information overload. Recommender systems have emerged as a solution to this problem by providing personalized recommendations to users based on their preferences and historical data. However, as recommendation models become increasingly complex, finding the best hyperparameter combination for different models has become a challenge. The high-dimensional hyperparameter search space poses numerous challenges for researchers, and failure to disclose hyperparameter settings may impede the reproducibility of research results. In this paper, we investigate the Top-N implicit recommendation problem and focus on optimizing the benchmark recommendation algorithm commonly used in comparative experiments using hyperparameter optimization algorithms. We propose a research methodology that follows the principles of a fair comparison, employing seven types of hyperparameter search algorithms to fine-tune six common recommendation algorithms on three datasets. We have identified the most suitable hyperparameter search algorithms for various recommendation algorithms on different types of datasets as a reference for later study. This study contributes to algorithmic research in recommender systems based on hyperparameter optimization, providing a fair basis for comparison.
Read more8/15/2024