Relighting from a Single Image: Datasets and Deep Intrinsic-based Architecture

Overview

• Single image scene relighting aims to generate a realistic new version of an input image under a different lighting condition.
• Existing methods have limitations, and related datasets are scarce.
• This work addresses the problem from both dataset and methodological perspectives.
• Two new datasets are proposed: a synthetic dataset with ground truth intrinsic components and a real dataset collected in a laboratory.
• A two-stage network based on intrinsic decomposition is established to incorporate physical consistency in the relighting pipeline.
• An unsupervised module is introduced to ensure satisfactory intrinsic outputs when ground truth is unavailable.
• The proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art and can produce animated results under arbitrary lighting conditions.

Plain English Explanation

The goal of single image scene relighting is to take an existing image and generate a new version of that image that appears to be lit by a different lighting condition. For example, you could take a photo taken during the day and generate a version of that photo that looks like it was taken at night or under different lighting.

While there has been some previous work on this problem, it remains very challenging, and there is a lack of high-quality datasets to train and test these techniques. This paper aims to address these challenges from two perspectives:

1. Datasets: The authors propose two new datasets - one a synthetic dataset with ground truth information about the underlying properties of the scene, and one a real-world dataset captured in a controlled laboratory setting. These new datasets help overcome the scarcity of existing options.

2. Methodology: The authors develop a new two-stage network that is designed to be more physically consistent. It uses an intrinsic image decomposition approach, which means it tries to separate the input image into its underlying components like surface reflectance, shading, and lighting. This helps the network generate more realistic relit images.

When the training data doesn't have ground truth information about these intrinsic components, the method uses an unsupervised approach to ensure the intrinsic outputs are still reasonable.

The end result is a method that outperforms previous state-of-the-art approaches, and can even be used to generate animated sequences with changing lighting conditions. The authors have made the datasets, code, and example videos publicly available.

Technical Explanation

To address the limitations of existing single image scene relighting methods, this work makes several key contributions:

Datasets: The authors propose two new datasets for this task. The first is a synthetic dataset with ground truth information about the intrinsic components of the scenes, such as surface reflectance, shading, and illumination. The second is a real-world dataset captured in a laboratory setting, providing real images with known lighting conditions. These new datasets help overcome the scarcity of existing options for training and evaluating relighting methods.

Methodology: The authors establish a two-stage network architecture based on intrinsic image decomposition. This approach aims to explicitly model the physical properties of the scene, which can help generate more realistic relit images. The first stage decomposes the input image into its intrinsic components, and the second stage uses these components to generate the final relit image.

When ground truth intrinsic decomposition information is not available in the training data, the authors introduce an unsupervised module to ensure the intrinsic outputs are satisfactory.

Results: The authors show that their method outperforms existing state-of-the-art single image scene relighting approaches when tested on both the new and existing datasets. Furthermore, they demonstrate that pretraining their method or other prior methods using their synthetic dataset can enhance performance on other datasets.

Since the proposed method can accommodate arbitrary lighting conditions, it is capable of producing animated results with changing lighting.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future research in their work:

• While the new synthetic and real-world datasets help address the scarcity of existing options, they are still relatively small in scale compared to datasets used in other computer vision tasks.
• The unsupervised intrinsic decomposition module introduced to handle cases where ground truth is unavailable may not be as accurate as a supervised approach.
• The authors do not provide a detailed analysis of failure cases or discuss potential biases in the datasets or model.
• The computational complexity and real-time performance of the method are not thoroughly evaluated, which could be important for some application scenarios.

Additionally, one could question whether the animated results produced by the method are truly realistic or just visually pleasing. Further user studies or perceptual evaluations may be needed to assess the fidelity of the relit images and animations.

Conclusion

This work makes important contributions to the field of single image scene relighting by introducing new datasets and a novel two-stage network architecture based on intrinsic decomposition. The proposed method outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches and can generate realistic relit images and even animated sequences under arbitrary lighting conditions.

The new datasets and the authors' willingness to share their code and results publicly are particularly valuable, as they can accelerate further research and development in this area. While the method has some limitations, it represents a significant step forward in addressing the challenge of single image scene relighting, which has important applications in fields like computational photography, visual effects, and augmented reality.