Retrieval-Augmented Mining of Temporal Logic Specifications from Data

Read original: arXiv:2405.14355 - Published 5/24/2024 by Gaia Saveri, Luca Bortolussi

📊

Overview

The paper focuses on the critical issue of ensuring the safety and reliability of cyber-physical systems (CPS) as they become more integrated into our daily lives.
A key step in this process is "requirement mining" - inferring formally specified system properties from observed behaviors to gain insights about the system.
The paper presents a novel framework that combines Bayesian Optimization and Information Retrieval techniques to learn both the structure and parameters of Signal Temporal Logic (STL) formulae from observed system behaviors.
The goal is to discover properties that can discriminate between regular and anomalous behavior, serving as both classifiers and monitors for CPS compliance.

Plain English Explanation

Cyber-physical systems (CPS) are technologies that combine digital components with physical devices, like self-driving cars or smart home systems. As these CPS become more common in our lives, it's critical to ensure they operate safely and reliably.

One way to do this is "requirement mining" - analyzing the system's observed behaviors to uncover formal rules or properties that describe how it should function. These formally specified requirements can then be used to monitor the system and detect any anomalies or problems.

The researchers in this paper focused on using a language called Signal Temporal Logic (STL) to express these system requirements. STL allows you to concisely describe complex patterns in the system's sensor data or other time-series measurements.

The key innovation in this paper is a new framework that combines two powerful AI techniques - Bayesian Optimization and Information Retrieval - to automatically learn the STL requirements from observational data. This allows the system to discover the formal rules that best distinguish normal operation from abnormal or problematic behavior.

The researchers demonstrate this approach on several signal classification tasks, showing it can efficiently extract interpretable insights about the system while also advancing the state-of-the-art in CPS requirement mining.

Technical Explanation

The paper addresses the challenge of requirement mining for cyber-physical systems (CPS), where behaviors are typically represented as time-series data. The authors propose a novel framework that integrates Bayesian Optimization and Information Retrieval techniques to simultaneously learn both the structure and parameters of Signal Temporal Logic (STL) formulae from observed system behaviors.

The key innovation is the use of a dense vector database containing semantic-preserving continuous representations of millions of STL formulae. This database is queried within a Bayesian Optimization loop to facilitate the mining of requirements that can discriminate between regular and anomalous behavior. The learned STL formulae serve as both classifiers and monitors for ensuring CPS compliance with desirable specifications.

The effectiveness of the proposed framework is demonstrated on several signal classification applications, showcasing its ability to extract interpretable insights from system executions and advance the state-of-the-art in requirement mining for CPS. The approach is able to discover STL properties without restrictions on the grammar, making it a flexible and powerful tool for this task.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to the important problem of requirement mining for cyber-physical systems. By combining Bayesian Optimization and Information Retrieval techniques, the framework is able to efficiently learn both the structure and parameters of STL formulae that can effectively discriminate between normal and anomalous system behaviors.

One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the reliance on a pre-existing database of STL formulae. While this allows the system to leverage a wealth of semantic knowledge, it may limit the ability to discover truly novel requirements that fall outside the scope of the database. Further research could explore methods to dynamically expand or generate STL formulae as part of the optimization process.

Additionally, the paper focuses on binary classification tasks, where the goal is to identify anomalous behavior. An interesting avenue for future work could be extending the approach to handle more nuanced requirement mining, such as discovering the full range of normal and abnormal behaviors, or inferring causal relationships between system components.

Overall, the research presented in this paper represents an important step forward in the field of requirement mining for cyber-physical systems. The novel framework demonstrates the potential of combining advanced AI techniques to extract meaningful, interpretable insights from complex system behaviors.

Conclusion

This paper addresses the critical challenge of ensuring the safety and reliability of cyber-physical systems as they become more integrated into our daily lives. By proposing a novel framework that integrates Bayesian Optimization and Information Retrieval techniques, the researchers have developed a powerful approach for requirement mining - inferring formally specified system properties from observed behaviors.

The ability to automatically learn Signal Temporal Logic (STL) formulae that can discriminate between regular and anomalous system operation represents a significant advancement in the field of CPS monitoring and compliance assurance. The demonstrated applications showcase the framework's effectiveness in extracting interpretable insights from complex time-series data, paving the way for more robust and trustworthy cyber-physical systems in the future.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📊

Retrieval-Augmented Mining of Temporal Logic Specifications from Data

Gaia Saveri, Luca Bortolussi

The integration of cyber-physical systems (CPS) into everyday life raises the critical necessity of ensuring their safety and reliability. An important step in this direction is requirement mining, i.e. inferring formally specified system properties from observed behaviors, in order to discover knowledge about the system. Signal Temporal Logic (STL) offers a concise yet expressive language for specifying requirements, particularly suited for CPS, where behaviors are typically represented as time series data. This work addresses the task of learning STL requirements from observed behaviors in a data-driven manner, focusing on binary classification, i.e. on inferring properties of the system which are able to discriminate between regular and anomalous behaviour, and that can be used both as classifiers and as monitors of the compliance of the CPS to desirable specifications. We present a novel framework that combines Bayesian Optimization (BO) and Information Retrieval (IR) techniques to simultaneously learn both the structure and the parameters of STL formulae, without restrictions on the STL grammar. Specifically, we propose a framework that leverages a dense vector database containing semantic-preserving continuous representations of millions of formulae, queried for facilitating the mining of requirements inside a BO loop. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in several signal classification applications, showing its ability to extract interpretable insights from system executions and advance the state-of-the-art in requirement mining for CPS.

5/24/2024

Learning to Estimate System Specifications in Linear Temporal Logic using Transformers and Mamba

.Ilker Ic{s}{i}k, Ebru Aydin Gol, Ramazan Gokberk Cinbis

Temporal logic is a framework for representing and reasoning about propositions that evolve over time. It is commonly used for specifying requirements in various domains, including hardware and software systems, as well as robotics. Specification mining or formula generation involves extracting temporal logic formulae from system traces and has numerous applications, such as detecting bugs and improving interpretability. Although there has been a surge of deep learning-based methods for temporal logic satisfiability checking in recent years, the specification mining literature has been lagging behind in adopting deep learning methods despite their many advantages, such as scalability. In this paper, we introduce autoregressive models that can generate linear temporal logic formulae from traces, towards addressing the specification mining problem. We propose multiple architectures for this task: transformer encoder-decoder, decoder-only transformer, and Mamba, which is an emerging alternative to transformer models. Additionally, we devise a metric for quantifying the distinctiveness of the generated formulae and a straightforward algorithm to enforce the syntax constraints. Our experiments show that the proposed architectures yield promising results, generating correct and distinct formulae at a fraction of the compute cost needed for the combinatorial baseline.

6/3/2024

TLINet: Differentiable Neural Network Temporal Logic Inference

Danyang Li, Mingyu Cai, Cristian-Ioan Vasile, Roberto Tron

There has been a growing interest in extracting formal descriptions of the system behaviors from data. Signal Temporal Logic (STL) is an expressive formal language used to describe spatial-temporal properties with interpretability. This paper introduces TLINet, a neural-symbolic framework for learning STL formulas. The computation in TLINet is differentiable, enabling the usage of off-the-shelf gradient-based tools during the learning process. In contrast to existing approaches, we introduce approximation methods for max operator designed specifically for temporal logic-based gradient techniques, ensuring the correctness of STL satisfaction evaluation. Our framework not only learns the structure but also the parameters of STL formulas, allowing flexible combinations of operators and various logical structures. We validate TLINet against state-of-the-art baselines, demonstrating that our approach outperforms these baselines in terms of interpretability, compactness, rich expressibility, and computational efficiency.

5/16/2024

Learning Optimal Signal Temporal Logic Decision Trees for Classification: A Max-Flow MILP Formulation

Kaier Liang, Gustavo A. Cardona, Disha Kamale, Cristian-Ioan Vasile

This paper presents a novel framework for inferring timed temporal logic properties from data. The dataset comprises pairs of finite-time system traces and corresponding labels, denoting whether the traces demonstrate specific desired behaviors, e.g. whether the ship follows a safe route or not. Our proposed approach leverages decision-tree-based methods to infer Signal Temporal Logic classifiers using primitive formulae. We formulate the inference process as a mixed integer linear programming optimization problem, recursively generating constraints to determine both data classification and tree structure. Applying a max-flow algorithm on the resultant tree transforms the problem into a global optimization challenge, leading to improved classification rates compared to prior methodologies. Moreover, we introduce a technique to reduce the number of constraints by exploiting the symmetry inherent in STL primitives, which enhances the algorithm's time performance and interpretability. To assess our algorithm's effectiveness and classification performance, we conduct three case studies involving two-class, multi-class, and complex formula classification scenarios.

8/15/2024