Robust Stochastic Shortest-Path Planning via Risk-Sensitive Incremental Sampling

Read original: arXiv:2408.08668 - Published 8/19/2024 by Clinton Enwerem, Erfaun Noorani, John S. Baras, Brian M. Sadler
Total Score

0

Robust Stochastic Shortest-Path Planning via Risk-Sensitive Incremental Sampling

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a new approach for robust stochastic shortest-path planning that can handle uncertainty in the environment.
  • The method uses a risk-sensitive incremental sampling technique to find paths that are resilient to environmental changes.
  • Experiments show the approach outperforms traditional planning methods in uncertain environments.

Plain English Explanation

When planning a path from one point to another, there is often uncertainty about the environment - for example, the terrain or obstacles may not be fully known. Robust Stochastic Shortest-Path Planning via Risk-Sensitive Incremental Sampling presents a new technique to find paths that are resilient to this type of uncertainty.

The key idea is to use a "risk-sensitive" approach when sampling possible paths. Rather than just looking for the shortest path, the algorithm considers the potential downside risk if something unexpected happens along the way. It incrementally builds up a plan that tries to minimize this risk, leading to paths that are more reliable and less likely to encounter problems.

Experiments show this risk-aware planning approach outperforms traditional methods, especially in environments with a lot of uncertainty. By anticipating potential issues, it can find paths that are more robust and less likely to run into trouble.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new algorithm for stochastic shortest-path planning in uncertain environments. It builds on the concept of incremental sampling, where a plan is gradually constructed by randomly sampling possible actions.

However, rather than just optimizing for the shortest path, the proposed method incorporates a risk-sensitive objective. This means it considers the potential downside if something goes wrong, not just the expected cost. The algorithm uses a Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR) metric to quantify this risk.

Through extensive simulation experiments, the authors demonstrate that this risk-aware planning approach outperforms traditional methods in uncertain environments. The resulting paths are more robust and resilient to unexpected changes or disturbances.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thoughtful and technically sound approach to dealing with uncertainty in path planning. The use of CVaR to capture risk sensitivity is a well-established technique in finance and operations research, and applying it to robotics and planning problems is a clever extension.

That said, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the approach. For example, the risk metric relies on a specific probability distribution for the environmental uncertainty, which may not always be known or easy to estimate in practice. There could also be computational challenges in scaling the risk-sensitive sampling to large, complex environments.

Additionally, while the experiments demonstrate the advantages of the proposed method, they are largely simulation-based. More real-world validation and testing would help to further assess the algorithm's performance and identify any practical challenges that may arise.

Overall, this is a promising piece of research that advances the state of the art in robust planning under uncertainty. However, as with any new technique, there are opportunities for further refinement and exploration of its boundaries and limitations.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to stochastic shortest-path planning that incorporates risk sensitivity to handle uncertainty in the environment. By using a risk-aware objective function and incremental sampling, the algorithm is able to find paths that are more robust and resilient to unexpected changes.

The technical insights and experimental results suggest this risk-sensitive planning method could be a valuable tool for a variety of robotics and autonomous systems applications where operating in uncertain environments is a key challenge. Further research to address potential limitations and real-world deployment scenarios would help to fully realize the benefits of this approach.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Robust Stochastic Shortest-Path Planning via Risk-Sensitive Incremental Sampling
Total Score

0

Robust Stochastic Shortest-Path Planning via Risk-Sensitive Incremental Sampling

Clinton Enwerem, Erfaun Noorani, John S. Baras, Brian M. Sadler

With the pervasiveness of Stochastic Shortest-Path (SSP) problems in high-risk industries, such as last-mile autonomous delivery and supply chain management, robust planning algorithms are crucial for ensuring successful task completion while mitigating hazardous outcomes. Mainstream chance-constrained incremental sampling techniques for solving SSP problems tend to be overly conservative and typically do not consider the likelihood of undesirable tail events. We propose an alternative risk-aware approach inspired by the asymptotically-optimal Rapidly-Exploring Random Trees (RRT*) planning algorithm, which selects nodes along path segments with minimal Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR). Our motivation rests on the step-wise coherence of the CVaR risk measure and the optimal substructure of the SSP problem. Thus, optimizing with respect to the CVaR at each sampling iteration necessarily leads to an optimal path in the limit of the sample size. We validate our approach via numerical path planning experiments in a two-dimensional grid world with obstacles and stochastic path-segment lengths. Our simulation results show that incorporating risk into the tree growth process yields paths with lengths that are significantly less sensitive to variations in the noise parameter, or equivalently, paths that are more robust to environmental uncertainty. Algorithmic analyses reveal similar query time and memory space complexity to the baseline RRT* procedure, with only a marginal increase in processing time. This increase is offset by significantly lower noise sensitivity and reduced planner failure rates.

Read more

8/19/2024

Learning-accelerated A* Search for Risk-aware Path Planning
Total Score

0

New!Learning-accelerated A* Search for Risk-aware Path Planning

Jun Xiang, Junfei Xie, Jun Chen

Safety is a critical concern for urban flights of autonomous Unmanned Aerial Vehicles. In populated environments, risk should be accounted for to produce an effective and safe path, known as risk-aware path planning. Risk-aware path planning can be modeled as a Constrained Shortest Path (CSP) problem, aiming to identify the shortest possible route that adheres to specified safety thresholds. CSP is NP-hard and poses significant computational challenges. Although many traditional methods can solve it accurately, all of them are very slow. Our method introduces an additional safety dimension to the traditional A* (called ASD A*), enabling A* to handle CSP. Furthermore, we develop a custom learning-based heuristic using transformer-based neural networks, which significantly reduces the computational load and improves the performance of the ASD A* algorithm. The proposed method is well-validated with both random and realistic simulation scenarios.

Read more

9/19/2024

Safe Interval RRT* for Scalable Multi-Robot Path Planning in Continuous Space
Total Score

0

Safe Interval RRT* for Scalable Multi-Robot Path Planning in Continuous Space

Joonyeol Sim, Joonkyung Kim, Changjoo Nam

In this paper, we consider the problem of Multi-Robot Path Planning (MRPP) in continuous space to find conflict-free paths. The difficulty of the problem arises from two primary factors. First, the involvement of multiple robots leads to combinatorial decision-making, which escalates the search space exponentially. Second, the continuous space presents potentially infinite states and actions. For this problem, we propose a two-level approach where the low level is a sampling-based planner Safe Interval RRT* (SI-RRT*) that finds a collision-free trajectory for individual robots. The high level can use any method that can resolve inter-robot conflicts where we employ two representative methods that are Prioritized Planning (SI-CPP) and Conflict Based Search (SI-CCBS). Experimental results show that SI-RRT* can find a high-quality solution quickly with a small number of samples. SI-CPP exhibits improved scalability while SI-CCBS produces higher-quality solutions compared to the state-of-the-art planners for continuous space. Compared to the most scalable existing algorithm, SI-CPP achieves a success rate that is up to 94% higher with 100 robots while maintaining solution quality (i.e., flowtime, the sum of travel times of all robots) without significant compromise. SI-CPP also decreases the makespan up to 45%. SI-CCBS decreases the flowtime by 9% compared to the competitor, albeit exhibiting a 14% lower success rate.

Read more

8/27/2024

📉

Total Score

0

Adaptive Hybrid Local-Global Sampling for Fast Informed Sampling-Based Optimal Path Planning

Marco Faroni, Nicola Pedrocchi, Manuel Beschi

This paper improves the performance of RRT$^*$-like sampling-based path planners by combining admissible informed sampling and local sampling (i.e., sampling the neighborhood of the current solution). An adaptive strategy regulates the trade-off between exploration (admissible informed sampling) and exploitation (local sampling) based on online rewards from previous samples. The paper demonstrates that the algorithm is asymptotically optimal and has a better convergence rate than state-of-the-art path planners (e.g., Informed-RRT*) in several simulated and real-world scenarios. An open-source, ROS-compatible implementation of the algorithm is publicly available.

Read more

4/16/2024