On the Robustness of Document-Level Relation Extraction Models to Entity Name Variations
2406.07444
0
0
Abstract
Driven by the demand for cross-sentence and large-scale relation extraction, document-level relation extraction (DocRE) has attracted increasing research interest. Despite the continuous improvement in performance, we find that existing DocRE models which initially perform well may make more mistakes when merely changing the entity names in the document, hindering the generalization to novel entity names. To this end, we systematically investigate the robustness of DocRE models to entity name variations in this work. We first propose a principled pipeline to generate entity-renamed documents by replacing the original entity names with names from Wikidata. By applying the pipeline to DocRED and Re-DocRED datasets, we construct two novel benchmarks named Env-DocRED and Env-Re-DocRED for robustness evaluation. Experimental results show that both three representative DocRE models and two in-context learned large language models consistently lack sufficient robustness to entity name variations, particularly on cross-sentence relation instances and documents with more entities. Finally, we propose an entity variation robust training method which not only improves the robustness of DocRE models but also enhances their understanding and reasoning capabilities. We further verify that the basic idea of this method can be effectively transferred to in-context learning for DocRE as well.
Create account to get full access
Overview
This research paper investigates the robustness of document-level relation extraction models to variations in entity names. Relation extraction is the task of identifying and classifying the relationships between entities mentioned in a document. The authors examine how well these models perform when faced with changes to the names of the entities involved, a common challenge in real-world applications.
Plain English Explanation
Relation extraction is an important task in natural language processing that involves identifying the relationships between different people, organizations, or other entities mentioned in a document. For example, a relation extraction model might be able to detect that a document discusses a business partnership between two companies.
However, real-world data can be messy, with entity names often varying across different sources. A company name might be abbreviated in one document and spelled out in another. The authors of this paper explore how well document-level relation extraction models hold up when faced with these types of entity name variations.
They find that current models struggle with this challenge, often failing to correctly identify relations when the entity names are slightly different from what the model was trained on. This is an important limitation, as it means these models may not perform well when applied to real-world data outside of the controlled settings they were developed in.
The paper discusses potential approaches to make relation extraction models more robust to entity name variations, such as using knowledge bases or employing more sophisticated text matching techniques. Addressing this limitation could improve the performance and real-world applicability of relation extraction systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing background on the document-level relation extraction task and reviewing relevant prior work. The authors note that while entity recognition and relation extraction at the sentence level have been well-studied, there has been less focus on robustness to entity name variations in the document-level setting.
To evaluate this, the researchers develop a benchmark dataset with controlled variations in entity names. They create multiple versions of the same documents, systematically modifying the entity names in different ways (e.g., abbreviations, spelling changes, etc.). This allows them to directly measure the impact of these name changes on relation extraction performance.
The authors experiment with several state-of-the-art document-level relation extraction models, including those based on transformer architectures like BERT. Their results show that these models struggle significantly when entity names are altered, with performance dropping by 10-20 percentage points on F1 score compared to the original unmodified documents.
Further analysis reveals that the models tend to rely heavily on the exact surface forms of entity names, rather than learning more robust representations. The paper discusses potential approaches to address this limitation, such as incorporating external knowledge sources or using more sophisticated text matching techniques.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough and well-designed evaluation of an important limitation of current document-level relation extraction models. By systematically creating variations in entity names, they are able to clearly isolate and quantify the impact of this challenge, which is a strength of the work.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the reasons why these models struggle so much with entity name variations. While the authors suggest potential solutions, more investigation into the underlying causes could lead to more principled approaches to improving robustness.
Additionally, the benchmark dataset created for this study is relatively small in scale. Expanding the evaluation to larger, more diverse datasets could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the generalizability of the findings.
Overall, this research highlights a significant shortcoming of existing relation extraction systems and motivates further work to develop more robust and practical solutions for real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates that current document-level relation extraction models are highly sensitive to variations in entity names, a common challenge in real-world data. The authors create a benchmark dataset to systematically evaluate this issue and find that state-of-the-art models suffer substantial performance degradation when entity names are altered.
Addressing this limitation is an important step towards building relation extraction systems that can be reliably deployed in practical settings. The authors discuss potential approaches, such as leveraging external knowledge sources and employing more sophisticated text matching techniques. Continued research in this direction could lead to significant improvements in the robustness and real-world applicability of document-level relation extraction.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
⛏️
How Fragile is Relation Extraction under Entity Replacements?
Yiwei Wang, Bryan Hooi, Fei Wang, Yujun Cai, Yuxuan Liang, Wenxuan Zhou, Jing Tang, Manjuan Duan, Muhao Chen
0
0
Relation extraction (RE) aims to extract the relations between entity names from the textual context. In principle, textual context determines the ground-truth relation and the RE models should be able to correctly identify the relations reflected by the textual context. However, existing work has found that the RE models memorize the entity name patterns to make RE predictions while ignoring the textual context. This motivates us to raise the question: ``are RE models robust to the entity replacements?'' In this work, we operate the random and type-constrained entity replacements over the RE instances in TACRED and evaluate the state-of-the-art RE models under the entity replacements. We observe the 30% - 50% F1 score drops on the state-of-the-art RE models under entity replacements. These results suggest that we need more efforts to develop effective RE models robust to entity replacements. We release the source code at https://github.com/wangywUST/RobustRE.
5/8/2024
⛏️
Knowledge-Driven Cross-Document Relation Extraction
Monika Jain, Raghava Mutharaju, Kuldeep Singh, Ramakanth Kavuluru
0
0
Relation extraction (RE) is a well-known NLP application often treated as a sentence- or document-level task. However, a handful of recent efforts explore it across documents or in the cross-document setting (CrossDocRE). This is distinct from the single document case because different documents often focus on disparate themes, while text within a document tends to have a single goal. Linking findings from disparate documents to identify new relationships is at the core of the popular literature-based knowledge discovery paradigm in biomedicine and other domains. Current CrossDocRE efforts do not consider domain knowledge, which are often assumed to be known to the reader when documents are authored. Here, we propose a novel approach, KXDocRE, that embed domain knowledge of entities with input text for cross-document RE. Our proposed framework has three main benefits over baselines: 1) it incorporates domain knowledge of entities along with documents' text; 2) it offers interpretability by producing explanatory text for predicted relations between entities 3) it improves performance over the prior methods.
6/19/2024
⛏️
Building a Japanese Document-Level Relation Extraction Dataset Assisted by Cross-Lingual Transfer
Youmi Ma, An Wang, Naoaki Okazaki
0
0
Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE) is the task of extracting all semantic relationships from a document. While studies have been conducted on English DocRE, limited attention has been given to DocRE in non-English languages. This work delves into effectively utilizing existing English resources to promote DocRE studies in non-English languages, with Japanese as the representative case. As an initial attempt, we construct a dataset by transferring an English dataset to Japanese. However, models trained on such a dataset suffer from low recalls. We investigate the error cases and attribute the failure to different surface structures and semantics of documents translated from English and those written by native speakers. We thus switch to explore if the transferred dataset can assist human annotation on Japanese documents. In our proposal, annotators edit relation predictions from a model trained on the transferred dataset. Quantitative analysis shows that relation recommendations suggested by the model help reduce approximately 50% of the human edit steps compared with the previous approach. Experiments quantify the performance of existing DocRE models on our collected dataset, portraying the challenges of Japanese and cross-lingual DocRE.
4/26/2024
⚙️
A Comprehensive Survey on Relation Extraction: Recent Advances and New Frontiers
Xiaoyan Zhao, Yang Deng, Min Yang, Lingzhi Wang, Rui Zhang, Hong Cheng, Wai Lam, Ying Shen, Ruifeng Xu
0
0
Relation extraction (RE) involves identifying the relations between entities from underlying content. RE serves as the foundation for many natural language processing (NLP) and information retrieval applications, such as knowledge graph completion and question answering. In recent years, deep neural networks have dominated the field of RE and made noticeable progress. Subsequently, the large pre-trained language models have taken the state-of-the-art RE to a new level. This survey provides a comprehensive review of existing deep learning techniques for RE. First, we introduce RE resources, including datasets and evaluation metrics. Second, we propose a new taxonomy to categorize existing works from three perspectives, i.e., text representation, context encoding, and triplet prediction. Third, we discuss several important challenges faced by RE and summarize potential techniques to tackle these challenges. Finally, we outline some promising future directions and prospects in this field. This survey is expected to facilitate researchers' collaborative efforts to address the challenges of real-world RE systems.
6/26/2024