How Fragile is Relation Extraction under Entity Replacements?
2305.13551
0
0
⛏️
Abstract
Relation extraction (RE) aims to extract the relations between entity names from the textual context. In principle, textual context determines the ground-truth relation and the RE models should be able to correctly identify the relations reflected by the textual context. However, existing work has found that the RE models memorize the entity name patterns to make RE predictions while ignoring the textual context. This motivates us to raise the question: ``are RE models robust to the entity replacements?'' In this work, we operate the random and type-constrained entity replacements over the RE instances in TACRED and evaluate the state-of-the-art RE models under the entity replacements. We observe the 30% - 50% F1 score drops on the state-of-the-art RE models under entity replacements. These results suggest that we need more efforts to develop effective RE models robust to entity replacements. We release the source code at https://github.com/wangywUST/RobustRE.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the robustness of relation extraction (RE) models to entity replacements in the textual context.
- Existing RE models have been found to memorize entity name patterns rather than truly understanding the textual context.
- The authors conduct experiments with random and type-constrained entity replacements on the TACRED dataset to evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art RE models.
- The results show a substantial drop in F1 scores, suggesting that current RE models are not robust to entity replacements.
- The authors conclude that more research is needed to develop effective RE models that can handle entity replacements.
Plain English Explanation
Relation extraction (RE) is the task of identifying the relationships between named entities (like people, organizations, or locations) in a text. For example, if a text mentions "John" and "Microsoft," an RE model should be able to determine the relationship between them, such as "John works at Microsoft."
The authors of this paper found that existing RE models often rely on patterns in the entity names themselves, rather than truly understanding the meaning of the text. This means the models may perform well on certain datasets, but they can't generalize well to situations where the entities are changed.
To test this, the researchers took the TACRED dataset, which is commonly used to evaluate RE models, and randomly replaced the entity names with other names. They also replaced the entities with names of the same type (e.g., replacing a person name with a different person name).
When the researchers ran state-of-the-art RE models on the modified TACRED dataset, the models' performance dropped significantly, by 30-50% in F1 score. This suggests that current RE models are not very robust to changes in the entity names, and they don't really understand the underlying meaning of the text.
The authors conclude that more research is needed to develop RE models that can truly comprehend the textual context, rather than just memorizing patterns in the entity names. This would make the models more robust to relation extraction and better able to generalize to real-world situations.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the robustness of relation extraction (RE) models to entity replacements in the textual context. Relation extraction aims to identify the relationships between named entities in text, such as "John works at Microsoft." However, the authors note that existing RE models have been found to memorize entity name patterns rather than fully understanding the textual context.
To evaluate the robustness of RE models, the researchers conduct experiments on the TACRED dataset, a widely used benchmark for RE. They perform two types of entity replacements: random replacements and type-constrained replacements (e.g., replacing a person name with another person name). The authors then evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art RE models, including retrieval-augmented generation-based relation extraction, recall-retrieve-reason, and others, under these entity replacement conditions.
The results show a significant drop in F1 scores, ranging from 30% to 50%, for the state-of-the-art RE models when evaluated on the entity-replaced TACRED dataset. These findings suggest that current RE models are not robust to changes in entity names and do not truly understand the underlying textual context.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution by highlighting the limitations of current RE models in their ability to handle entity replacements. The authors' experiments reveal that state-of-the-art RE models rely heavily on entity name patterns, rather than truly comprehending the textual context, which is a critical flaw for real-world applications.
One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses only on the TACRED dataset, which may not fully represent the diversity of textual contexts and entity types encountered in practical scenarios. It would be interesting to see the authors extend their analysis to other RE datasets or even cross-domain evaluations to further explore the generalizability of their findings.
Additionally, the paper does not provide in-depth insights into the specific weaknesses of the evaluated RE models or suggest potential directions for improving their robustness. Exploring the underlying causes of the models' vulnerability to entity replacements and proposing novel techniques to address this issue could be a valuable next step.
The authors' decision to release the source code for their experiments is commendable, as it allows other researchers to build upon this work and further investigate the relation extraction challenges in large language models.
Conclusion
This paper highlights a critical limitation of current relation extraction (RE) models: their vulnerability to entity replacements in the textual context. The authors' experiments demonstrate that state-of-the-art RE models rely heavily on entity name patterns, rather than truly understanding the underlying meaning of the text, leading to a substantial drop in performance when the entities are replaced.
These findings suggest that more research is needed to develop effective RE models that can robustly handle entity replacements and truly comprehend the textual context. Addressing this challenge could lead to significant improvements in the performance and real-world applicability of relation extraction systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
On the Robustness of Document-Level Relation Extraction Models to Entity Name Variations
Shiao Meng, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Fukun Ma, Yawen Yang, Shuang Li, Lijie Wen
0
0
Driven by the demand for cross-sentence and large-scale relation extraction, document-level relation extraction (DocRE) has attracted increasing research interest. Despite the continuous improvement in performance, we find that existing DocRE models which initially perform well may make more mistakes when merely changing the entity names in the document, hindering the generalization to novel entity names. To this end, we systematically investigate the robustness of DocRE models to entity name variations in this work. We first propose a principled pipeline to generate entity-renamed documents by replacing the original entity names with names from Wikidata. By applying the pipeline to DocRED and Re-DocRED datasets, we construct two novel benchmarks named Env-DocRED and Env-Re-DocRED for robustness evaluation. Experimental results show that both three representative DocRE models and two in-context learned large language models consistently lack sufficient robustness to entity name variations, particularly on cross-sentence relation instances and documents with more entities. Finally, we propose an entity variation robust training method which not only improves the robustness of DocRE models but also enhances their understanding and reasoning capabilities. We further verify that the basic idea of this method can be effectively transferred to in-context learning for DocRE as well.
6/12/2024
⚙️
A Comprehensive Survey on Relation Extraction: Recent Advances and New Frontiers
Xiaoyan Zhao, Yang Deng, Min Yang, Lingzhi Wang, Rui Zhang, Hong Cheng, Wai Lam, Ying Shen, Ruifeng Xu
0
0
Relation extraction (RE) involves identifying the relations between entities from underlying content. RE serves as the foundation for many natural language processing (NLP) and information retrieval applications, such as knowledge graph completion and question answering. In recent years, deep neural networks have dominated the field of RE and made noticeable progress. Subsequently, the large pre-trained language models have taken the state-of-the-art RE to a new level. This survey provides a comprehensive review of existing deep learning techniques for RE. First, we introduce RE resources, including datasets and evaluation metrics. Second, we propose a new taxonomy to categorize existing works from three perspectives, i.e., text representation, context encoding, and triplet prediction. Third, we discuss several important challenges faced by RE and summarize potential techniques to tackle these challenges. Finally, we outline some promising future directions and prospects in this field. This survey is expected to facilitate researchers' collaborative efforts to address the challenges of real-world RE systems.
6/26/2024
Relation Extraction with Fine-Tuned Large Language Models in Retrieval Augmented Generation Frameworks
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
0
0
Information Extraction (IE) is crucial for converting unstructured data into structured formats like Knowledge Graphs (KGs). A key task within IE is Relation Extraction (RE), which identifies relationships between entities in text. Various RE methods exist, including supervised, unsupervised, weakly supervised, and rule-based approaches. Recent studies leveraging pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown significant success in this area. In the current era dominated by Large Language Models (LLMs), fine-tuning these models can overcome limitations associated with zero-shot LLM prompting-based RE methods, especially regarding domain adaptation challenges and identifying implicit relations between entities in sentences. These implicit relations, which cannot be easily extracted from a sentence's dependency tree, require logical inference for accurate identification. This work explores the performance of fine-tuned LLMs and their integration into the Retrieval Augmented-based (RAG) RE approach to address the challenges of identifying implicit relations at the sentence level, particularly when LLMs act as generators within the RAG framework. Empirical evaluations on the TACRED, TACRED-Revisited (TACREV), Re-TACRED, and SemEVAL datasets show significant performance improvements with fine-tuned LLMs, including Llama2-7B, Mistral-7B, and T5 (Large). Notably, our approach achieves substantial gains on SemEVAL, where implicit relations are common, surpassing previous results on this dataset. Additionally, our method outperforms previous works on TACRED, TACREV, and Re-TACRED, demonstrating exceptional performance across diverse evaluation scenarios.
6/26/2024
Retrieval-Augmented Generation-based Relation Extraction
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
0
0
Information Extraction (IE) is a transformative process that converts unstructured text data into a structured format by employing entity and relation extraction (RE) methodologies. The identification of the relation between a pair of entities plays a crucial role within this framework. Despite the existence of various techniques for relation extraction, their efficacy heavily relies on access to labeled data and substantial computational resources. In addressing these challenges, Large Language Models (LLMs) emerge as promising solutions; however, they might return hallucinating responses due to their own training data. To overcome these limitations, Retrieved-Augmented Generation-based Relation Extraction (RAG4RE) in this work is proposed, offering a pathway to enhance the performance of relation extraction tasks. This work evaluated the effectiveness of our RAG4RE approach utilizing different LLMs. Through the utilization of established benchmarks, such as TACRED, TACREV, Re-TACRED, and SemEval RE datasets, our aim is to comprehensively evaluate the efficacy of our RAG4RE approach. In particularly, we leverage prominent LLMs including Flan T5, Llama2, and Mistral in our investigation. The results of our study demonstrate that our RAG4RE approach surpasses performance of traditional RE approaches based solely on LLMs, particularly evident in the TACRED dataset and its variations. Furthermore, our approach exhibits remarkable performance compared to previous RE methodologies across both TACRED and TACREV datasets, underscoring its efficacy and potential for advancing RE tasks in natural language processing.
4/23/2024