ROCAS: Root Cause Analysis of Autonomous Driving Accidents via Cyber-Physical Co-mutation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Provides a root cause analysis of autonomous driving accidents
- Leverages cyber-physical co-mutation to understand complex accident scenarios
- Identifies key factors contributing to accidents and potential mitigation strategies
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a framework called ROCAS that aims to analyze the root causes of accidents in autonomous driving systems. The key idea is to consider the interaction between the cyber (software, algorithms) and physical (sensors, actuators) components of the autonomous driving system, and how these can collectively contribute to accidents.
The ROCAS framework uses a technique called "cyber-physical co-mutation" to simulate and explore complex accident scenarios. This allows researchers to identify the various factors - both cyber and physical - that can lead to accidents, such as sensor failures, software bugs, and environmental conditions.
By understanding these root causes, the researchers hope to develop strategies to mitigate the risk of accidents in autonomous driving systems. This could involve improving sensor reliability, enhancing software testing and validation, or designing more robust decision-making algorithms.
Technical Explanation
The ROCAS framework combines simulation-based techniques with formal methods to analyze the root causes of autonomous driving accidents. The key components include:
-
Cyber-Physical Co-Mutation: The researchers developed a co-mutation approach that allows them to explore the interaction between the cyber (software) and physical (sensor, actuator) components of the autonomous driving system. This enables the simulation of complex accident scenarios involving both types of failures.
-
Accident Scenario Generation: The framework generates a diverse set of accident scenarios by mutating the cyber and physical components of the system. This includes injecting faults, modifying environmental conditions, and altering the behavior of the autonomous driving algorithms.
-
Root Cause Analysis: By analyzing the accident scenarios generated, the researchers are able to identify the key factors - both cyber and physical - that contribute to the accidents. This includes sensor failures, software bugs, and environmental conditions.
-
Mitigation Strategies: Based on the root cause analysis, the researchers propose potential mitigation strategies to reduce the risk of accidents. These may include improving sensor reliability, enhancing software testing and validation, or designing more robust decision-making algorithms.
The ROCAS framework is evaluated using a range of simulated accident scenarios, demonstrating its ability to uncover complex root causes and suggest effective mitigation strategies.
Critical Analysis
The ROCAS framework represents a valuable contribution to the field of autonomous driving safety, as it provides a systematic approach to understanding the complex factors that can lead to accidents. By considering the interaction between cyber and physical components, the researchers are able to uncover root causes that may have been missed by more traditional, siloed approaches.
However, it's important to note that the framework is still primarily based on simulation, and its effectiveness in the real world may be limited by the fidelity of the simulations and the ability to accurately model all relevant factors. Additionally, the researchers acknowledge that the framework may be computationally intensive and may not scale well to large, complex autonomous driving systems.
Further research is needed to validate the ROCAS framework in real-world settings, and to explore ways to make it more efficient and scalable. Additionally, the researchers could investigate the potential for the framework to be integrated with other safety and reliability assessment techniques, such as DANCE-ADS and PORCA, to provide a more comprehensive approach to autonomous driving safety.
Conclusion
The ROCAS framework represents a significant step forward in the quest to understand and mitigate the risks of autonomous driving accidents. By considering the complex interplay between cyber and physical components, the framework provides a powerful tool for identifying and addressing the root causes of accidents.
While there are still some challenges to overcome, the potential benefits of the ROCAS approach are significant. As autonomous driving systems become more sophisticated and ubiquitous, the need for robust safety assessment and mitigation strategies will only continue to grow. The ROCAS framework represents a valuable contribution to this important field of research.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
ROCAS: Root Cause Analysis of Autonomous Driving Accidents via Cyber-Physical Co-mutation
Shiwei Feng, Yapeng Ye, Qingkai Shi, Zhiyuan Cheng, Xiangzhe Xu, Siyuan Cheng, Hongjun Choi, Xiangyu Zhang
As Autonomous driving systems (ADS) have transformed our daily life, safety of ADS is of growing significance. While various testing approaches have emerged to enhance the ADS reliability, a crucial gap remains in understanding the accidents causes. Such post-accident analysis is paramount and beneficial for enhancing ADS safety and reliability. Existing cyber-physical system (CPS) root cause analysis techniques are mainly designed for drones and cannot handle the unique challenges introduced by more complex physical environments and deep learning models deployed in ADS. In this paper, we address the gap by offering a formal definition of ADS root cause analysis problem and introducing ROCAS, a novel ADS root cause analysis framework featuring cyber-physical co-mutation. Our technique uniquely leverages both physical and cyber mutation that can precisely identify the accident-trigger entity and pinpoint the misconfiguration of the target ADS responsible for an accident. We further design a differential analysis to identify the responsible module to reduce search space for the misconfiguration. We study 12 categories of ADS accidents and demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of ROCAS in narrowing down search space and pinpointing the misconfiguration. We also show detailed case studies on how the identified misconfiguration helps understand rationale behind accidents.
Read more9/17/2024
0
Dance of the ADS: Orchestrating Failures through Historically-Informed Scenario Fuzzing
Tong Wang, Taotao Gu, Huan Deng, Hu Li, Xiaohui Kuang, Gang Zhao
As autonomous driving systems (ADS) advance towards higher levels of autonomy, orchestrating their safety verification becomes increasingly intricate. This paper unveils ScenarioFuzz, a pioneering scenario-based fuzz testing methodology. Designed like a choreographer who understands the past performances, it uncovers vulnerabilities in ADS without the crutch of predefined scenarios. Leveraging map road networks, such as OPENDRIVE, we extract essential data to form a foundational scenario seed corpus. This corpus, enriched with pertinent information, provides the necessary boundaries for fuzz testing in the absence of starting scenarios. Our approach integrates specialized mutators and mutation techniques, combined with a graph neural network model, to predict and filter out high-risk scenario seeds, optimizing the fuzzing process using historical test data. Compared to other methods, our approach reduces the time cost by an average of 60.3%, while the number of error scenarios discovered per unit of time increases by 103%. Furthermore, we propose a self-supervised collision trajectory clustering method, which aids in identifying and summarizing 54 high-risk scenario categories prone to inducing ADS faults. Our experiments have successfully uncovered 58 bugs across six tested systems, emphasizing the critical safety concerns of ADS.
Read more7/8/2024
0
PORCA: Root Cause Analysis with Partially
Chang Gong, Di Yao, Jin Wang, Wenbin Li, Lanting Fang, Yongtao Xie, Kaiyu Feng, Peng Han, Jingping Bi
Root Cause Analysis (RCA) aims at identifying the underlying causes of system faults by uncovering and analyzing the causal structure from complex systems. It has been widely used in many application domains. Reliable diagnostic conclusions are of great importance in mitigating system failures and financial losses. However, previous studies implicitly assume a full observation of the system, which neglect the effect of partial observation (i.e., missing nodes and latent malfunction). As a result, they fail in deriving reliable RCA results. In this paper, we unveil the issues of unobserved confounders and heterogeneity in partial observation and come up with a new problem of root cause analysis with partially observed data. To achieve this, we propose PORCA, a novel RCA framework which can explore reliable root causes under both unobserved confounders and unobserved heterogeneity. PORCA leverages magnified score-based causal discovery to efficiently optimize acyclic directed mixed graph under unobserved confounders. In addition, we also develop a heterogeneity-aware scheduling strategy to provide adaptive sample weights. Extensive experimental results on one synthetic and two real-world datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed framework.
Read more7/15/2024
👁️
0
CRASH: Crash Recognition and Anticipation System Harnessing with Context-Aware and Temporal Focus Attentions
Haicheng Liao, Haoyu Sun, Huanming Shen, Chengyue Wang, Kahou Tam, Chunlin Tian, Li Li, Chengzhong Xu, Zhenning Li
Accurately and promptly predicting accidents among surrounding traffic agents from camera footage is crucial for the safety of autonomous vehicles (AVs). This task presents substantial challenges stemming from the unpredictable nature of traffic accidents, their long-tail distribution, the intricacies of traffic scene dynamics, and the inherently constrained field of vision of onboard cameras. To address these challenges, this study introduces a novel accident anticipation framework for AVs, termed CRASH. It seamlessly integrates five components: object detector, feature extractor, object-aware module, context-aware module, and multi-layer fusion. Specifically, we develop the object-aware module to prioritize high-risk objects in complex and ambiguous environments by calculating the spatial-temporal relationships between traffic agents. In parallel, the context-aware is also devised to extend global visual information from the temporal to the frequency domain using the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) and capture fine-grained visual features of potential objects and broader context cues within traffic scenes. To capture a wider range of visual cues, we further propose a multi-layer fusion that dynamically computes the temporal dependencies between different scenes and iteratively updates the correlations between different visual features for accurate and timely accident prediction. Evaluated on real-world datasets--Dashcam Accident Dataset (DAD), Car Crash Dataset (CCD), and AnAn Accident Detection (A3D) datasets--our model surpasses existing top baselines in critical evaluation metrics like Average Precision (AP) and mean Time-To-Accident (mTTA). Importantly, its robustness and adaptability are particularly evident in challenging driving scenarios with missing or limited training data, demonstrating significant potential for application in real-world autonomous driving systems.
Read more7/26/2024