Security Assessment of Hierarchical Federated Deep Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the security of hierarchical federated deep learning, which involves training a machine learning model across multiple devices or organizations in a hierarchical structure.
- The researchers investigate the potential for adversarial attacks that can compromise the security and integrity of the model during both the training and inference phases.
- They also explore strategies for defending against these attacks and improving the overall security of hierarchical federated learning systems.
Plain English Explanation
Hierarchical federated deep learning is a way of training an AI model across many different devices or organizations. Instead of everyone sending their data to a central location, the model is trained in a more decentralized way. The devices or organizations are arranged in a hierarchy, with some coordinating the overall training process while others focus on their local data.
This paper looks at the security risks involved with this approach. The researchers investigate how an attacker could try to sabotage the training of the model or trick the final model into making mistakes during real-world use. For example, an attacker might try to send the central coordinator malicious updates to the model that undermine its performance.
The paper also explores potential defenses against these attacks. The goal is to find ways to make hierarchical federated learning more robust and secure, so that the benefits of this decentralized approach can be realized without opening the system up to harmful interference.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing an overview of hierarchical federated learning and the security challenges it faces. The researchers then review prior work on attacks and defenses in federated learning, including both training-time and inference-time attacks.
Building on this foundation, the paper makes the following key contributions:
- It proposes a comprehensive threat model for hierarchical federated learning, considering attacks at both the training and inference stages.
- It develops novel attack strategies tailored to the hierarchical structure, including targeted and untargeted attacks.
- It evaluates the effectiveness of these attacks on several benchmark datasets and federated learning architectures.
- It investigates potential defense mechanisms, such as anomaly detection and model hardening techniques, to mitigate the identified threats.
The experiments demonstrate that the proposed attacks can significantly degrade the performance of hierarchical federated learning models, highlighting the need for robust security measures. The paper concludes by discussing the limitations of the current work and identifying areas for future research.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough security analysis of hierarchical federated learning, addressing important vulnerabilities that could arise in this decentralized setting. By considering both training-time and inference-time attacks, the researchers present a comprehensive threat model that captures a range of potential adversarial strategies.
One limitation of the work is that it focuses on white-box attacks, where the attacker has full knowledge of the model architecture and training process. In practice, a more realistic scenario may involve black-box or limited-information attacks, which could be an interesting avenue for future research.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential societal implications of these security issues. As hierarchical federated learning is increasingly adopted, it will be crucial to understand the broader implications of such vulnerabilities and ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to protect user privacy and data integrity.
Conclusion
This paper makes a significant contribution to the understanding of security challenges in hierarchical federated learning. By identifying and evaluating a range of adversarial attacks, the researchers have highlighted the importance of developing robust defense mechanisms to ensure the reliability and trustworthiness of this emerging paradigm of distributed machine learning.
As the deployment of hierarchical federated learning systems becomes more widespread, continued research in this area will be essential to address the evolving security landscape and maintain the integrity of the models being used in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Security Assessment of Hierarchical Federated Deep Learning
D Alqattan, R Sun, H Liang, G Nicosia, V Snasel, R Ranjan, V Ojha
Hierarchical federated learning (HFL) is a promising distributed deep learning model training paradigm, but it has crucial security concerns arising from adversarial attacks. This research investigates and assesses the security of HFL using a novel methodology by focusing on its resilience against adversarial attacks inference-time and training-time. Through a series of extensive experiments across diverse datasets and attack scenarios, we uncover that HFL demonstrates robustness against untargeted training-time attacks due to its hierarchical structure. However, targeted attacks, particularly backdoor attacks, exploit this architecture, especially when malicious clients are positioned in the overlapping coverage areas of edge servers. Consequently, HFL shows a dual nature in its resilience, showcasing its capability to recover from attacks thanks to its hierarchical aggregation that strengthens its suitability for adversarial training, thereby reinforcing its resistance against inference-time attacks. These insights underscore the necessity for balanced security strategies in HFL systems, leveraging their inherent strengths while effectively mitigating vulnerabilities.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Federated Learning as a Service for Hierarchical Edge Networks with Heterogeneous Models
Wentao Gao, Omid Tavallaie, Shuaijun Chen, Albert Zomaya
Federated learning (FL) is a distributed Machine Learning (ML) framework that is capable of training a new global model by aggregating clients' locally trained models without sharing users' original data. Federated learning as a service (FLaaS) offers a privacy-preserving approach for training machine learning models on devices with various computational resources. Most proposed FL-based methods train the same model in all client devices regardless of their computational resources. However, in practical Internet of Things (IoT) scenarios, IoT devices with limited computational resources may not be capable of training models that client devices with greater hardware performance hosted. Most of the existing FL frameworks that aim to solve the problem of aggregating heterogeneous models are designed for Independent and Identical Distributed (IID) data, which may make it hard to reach the target algorithm performance when encountering non-IID scenarios. To address these problems in hierarchical networks, in this paper, we propose a heterogeneous aggregation framework for hierarchical edge systems called HAF-Edge. In our proposed framework, we introduce a communication-efficient model aggregation method designed for FL systems with two-level model aggregations running at the edge and cloud levels. This approach enhances the convergence rate of the global model by leveraging selective knowledge transfer during the aggregation of heterogeneous models. To the best of our knowledge, this work is pioneering in addressing the problem of aggregating heterogeneous models within hierarchical FL systems spanning IoT, edge, and cloud environments. We conducted extensive experiments to validate the performance of our proposed method. The evaluation results demonstrate that HAF-Edge significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Read more7/31/2024
0
Sequential Federated Learning in Hierarchical Architecture on Non-IID Datasets
Xingrun Yan, Shiyuan Zuo, Rongfei Fan, Han Hu, Li Shen, Puning Zhao, Yong Luo
In a real federated learning (FL) system, communication overhead for passing model parameters between the clients and the parameter server (PS) is often a bottleneck. Hierarchical federated learning (HFL) that poses multiple edge servers (ESs) between clients and the PS can partially alleviate communication pressure but still needs the aggregation of model parameters from multiple ESs at the PS. To further reduce communication overhead, we bring sequential FL (SFL) into HFL for the first time, which removes the central PS and enables the model training to be completed only through passing the global model between two adjacent ESs for each iteration, and propose a novel algorithm adaptive to such a combinational framework, referred to as Fed-CHS. Convergence results are derived for strongly convex and non-convex loss functions under various data heterogeneity setups, which show comparable convergence performance with the algorithms for HFL or SFL solely. Experimental results provide evidence of the superiority of our proposed Fed-CHS on both communication overhead saving and test accuracy over baseline methods.
Read more8/20/2024
⛏️
0
Federated Learning Privacy: Attacks, Defenses, Applications, and Policy Landscape - A Survey
Joshua C. Zhao, Saurabh Bagchi, Salman Avestimehr, Kevin S. Chan, Somali Chaterji, Dimitris Dimitriadis, Jiacheng Li, Ninghui Li, Arash Nourian, Holger R. Roth
Deep learning has shown incredible potential across a vast array of tasks and accompanying this growth has been an insatiable appetite for data. However, a large amount of data needed for enabling deep learning is stored on personal devices and recent concerns on privacy have further highlighted challenges for accessing such data. As a result, federated learning (FL) has emerged as an important privacy-preserving technology enabling collaborative training of machine learning models without the need to send the raw, potentially sensitive, data to a central server. However, the fundamental premise that sending model updates to a server is privacy-preserving only holds if the updates cannot be reverse engineered to infer information about the private training data. It has been shown under a wide variety of settings that this premise for privacy does {em not} hold. In this survey paper, we provide a comprehensive literature review of the different privacy attacks and defense methods in FL. We identify the current limitations of these attacks and highlight the settings in which FL client privacy can be broken. We dissect some of the successful industry applications of FL and draw lessons for future successful adoption. We survey the emerging landscape of privacy regulation for FL. We conclude with future directions for taking FL toward the cherished goal of generating accurate models while preserving the privacy of the data from its participants.
Read more5/7/2024