SEER: Facilitating Structured Reasoning and Explanation via Reinforcement Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents "Seer", a novel reinforcement learning-based approach for facilitating structured reasoning and explanation in question answering tasks.
- Seer aims to address the challenges of black-box neural networks by learning an interpretable structured reasoning process that can generate step-by-step explanations of its decisions.
- The proposed method combines reinforcement learning with a structured reasoning module to learn a reasoning strategy that maximizes performance on the task while also optimizing for the quality of the explanations produced.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new AI system called "Seer" that is designed to not only answer questions accurately, but also explain its reasoning in a clear and understandable way. Many modern AI question-answering systems are essentially "black boxes" - they can provide answers, but it's often unclear how they arrived at those answers. Seer aims to address this by learning an interpretable, step-by-step reasoning process.
At a high level, Seer uses a combination of reinforcement learning and a structured reasoning module to learn an optimal strategy for answering questions and generating meaningful explanations. The reinforcement learning aspect allows Seer to improve its performance over time, while the structured reasoning module ensures that the system's decision-making process is transparent and can be easily communicated to users.
The key idea is to explicitly optimize the AI system not just for question-answering accuracy, but also for the quality and interpretability of the explanations it provides. This helps to make the system's inner workings more accessible and builds trust in its outputs.
Technical Explanation
The core of the Seer system is a structured reasoning module that breaks down the question-answering process into a series of interpretable steps. This module is trained using reinforcement learning, where the agent's actions correspond to the reasoning steps it takes, and the rewards are based on both the final answer accuracy and the quality of the generated explanations.
The structured reasoning module consists of a set of neural network components, including a question encoder, a knowledge base retrieval module, a reasoning step selector, and an explanation generator. During training, the agent learns to select the most relevant reasoning steps to take in order to arrive at the correct answer, while also producing high-quality explanations that justify its decisions.
The reinforcement learning framework allows Seer to explore different reasoning strategies and optimize for the desired trade-off between answer accuracy and explanation quality. This is a key innovation compared to prior work, which often focused solely on maximizing question-answering performance without considering the interpretability of the system's inner workings.
The paper presents experiments on several question-answering benchmarks, where Seer demonstrates strong performance while also generating detailed, step-by-step explanations of its reasoning process. The authors also analyze the learned reasoning strategies and show that they align with human intuitions about how to approach these types of tasks.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of the Seer approach is that it relies on a predefined set of reasoning steps, which may not be flexible enough to handle all types of questions or reasoning patterns. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that future work could explore more dynamic or open-ended reasoning modules.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the computational complexity or inference time of the Seer system, which could be an important consideration for real-world deployment. The authors also do not discuss potential biases or ethical considerations that may arise from the use of such an interpretable AI system in sensitive domains.
Nevertheless, the Seer framework represents an important step towards building AI systems that can not only perform well on tasks, but also provide transparent and interpretable explanations of their decision-making processes. This aligns with the broader trend towards more explainable AI and causal reasoning in machine learning.
Conclusion
The Seer system proposed in this paper demonstrates a novel approach to combining reinforcement learning with structured reasoning to enable both high-performing and interpretable question-answering. By explicitly optimizing for both answer accuracy and explanation quality, Seer represents an important advance in the field of knowledge-graph reasoning with self-supervised reinforcement learning and efficient preference-based reinforcement learning.
The authors' work highlights the value of developing AI systems that can not only solve complex problems, but also provide clear and understandable justifications for their decisions. As AI becomes more ubiquitous in our lives, this type of explainable and transparent reasoning will be crucial for building trust and acceptance of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
SEER: Facilitating Structured Reasoning and Explanation via Reinforcement Learning
Guoxin Chen, Kexin Tang, Chao Yang, Fuying Ye, Yu Qiao, Yiming Qian
Elucidating the reasoning process with structured explanations from question to answer is crucial, as it significantly enhances the interpretability, traceability, and trustworthiness of question-answering (QA) systems. However, structured explanations demand models to perform intricately structured reasoning, which poses great challenges. Most existing methods focus on single-step reasoning through supervised learning, ignoring logical dependencies between steps. Moreover, existing reinforcement learning (RL) based methods overlook the structured relationships, underutilizing the potential of RL in structured reasoning. In this paper, we propose SEER, a novel method that maximizes a structure-based return to facilitate structured reasoning and explanation. Our proposed structure-based return precisely describes the hierarchical and branching structure inherent in structured reasoning, effectively capturing the intricate relationships between different reasoning steps. In addition, we introduce a fine-grained reward function to meticulously delineate diverse reasoning steps. Extensive experiments show that SEER significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods, achieving an absolute improvement of 6.9% over RL-based methods on EntailmentBank, a 4.4% average improvement on STREET benchmark, and exhibiting outstanding efficiency and cross-dataset generalization performance. Our code is available at https://github.com/Chen-GX/SEER.
Read more9/30/2024
🏅
0
Knowledge Graph Reasoning with Self-supervised Reinforcement Learning
Ying Ma, Owen Burns, Mingqiu Wang, Gang Li, Nan Du, Laurent El Shafey, Liqiang Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau
Reinforcement learning (RL) is an effective method of finding reasoning pathways in incomplete knowledge graphs (KGs). To overcome the challenges of a large action space, a self-supervised pre-training method is proposed to warm up the policy network before the RL training stage. To alleviate the distributional mismatch issue in general self-supervised RL (SSRL), in our supervised learning (SL) stage, the agent selects actions based on the policy network and learns from generated labels; this self-generation of labels is the intuition behind the name self-supervised. With this training framework, the information density of our SL objective is increased and the agent is prevented from getting stuck with the early rewarded paths. Our self-supervised RL (SSRL) method improves the performance of RL by pairing it with the wide coverage achieved by SL during pretraining, since the breadth of the SL objective makes it infeasible to train an agent with that alone. We show that our SSRL model meets or exceeds current state-of-the-art results on all Hits@k and mean reciprocal rank (MRR) metrics on four large benchmark KG datasets. This SSRL method can be used as a plug-in for any RL architecture for a KGR task. We adopt two RL architectures, i.e., MINERVA and MultiHopKG as our baseline RL models and experimentally show that our SSRL model consistently outperforms both baselines on all of these four KG reasoning tasks. Full code for the paper available at https://github.com/owenonline/Knowledge-Graph-Reasoning-with-Self-supervised-Reinforcement-Learning.
Read more5/24/2024
0
Efficient Preference-based Reinforcement Learning via Aligned Experience Estimation
Fengshuo Bai, Rui Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Sijia Cui, Ying Wen, Yaodong Yang, Bo Xu, Lei Han
Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) has shown impressive capabilities in training agents without reward engineering. However, a notable limitation of PbRL is its dependency on substantial human feedback. This dependency stems from the learning loop, which entails accurate reward learning compounded with value/policy learning, necessitating a considerable number of samples. To boost the learning loop, we propose SEER, an efficient PbRL method that integrates label smoothing and policy regularization techniques. Label smoothing reduces overfitting of the reward model by smoothing human preference labels. Additionally, we bootstrap a conservative estimate $widehat{Q}$ using well-supported state-action pairs from the current replay memory to mitigate overestimation bias and utilize it for policy learning regularization. Our experimental results across a variety of complex tasks, both in online and offline settings, demonstrate that our approach improves feedback efficiency, outperforming state-of-the-art methods by a large margin. Ablation studies further reveal that SEER achieves a more accurate Q-function compared to prior work.
Read more5/30/2024
0
Retrieval-Augmented Natural Language Reasoning for Explainable Visual Question Answering
Su Hyeon Lim, Minkuk Kim, Hyeon Bae Kim, Seong Tae Kim
Visual Question Answering with Natural Language Explanation (VQA-NLE) task is challenging due to its high demand for reasoning-based inference. Recent VQA-NLE studies focus on enhancing model networks to amplify the model's reasoning capability but this approach is resource-consuming and unstable. In this work, we introduce a new VQA-NLE model, ReRe (Retrieval-augmented natural language Reasoning), using leverage retrieval information from the memory to aid in generating accurate answers and persuasive explanations without relying on complex networks and extra datasets. ReRe is an encoder-decoder architecture model using a pre-trained clip vision encoder and a pre-trained GPT-2 language model as a decoder. Cross-attention layers are added in the GPT-2 for processing retrieval features. ReRe outperforms previous methods in VQA accuracy and explanation score and shows improvement in NLE with more persuasive, reliability.
Read more9/2/2024