Selecting Interpretability Techniques for Healthcare Machine Learning models
2406.10213
0
0
🧠
Abstract
In healthcare there is a pursuit for employing interpretable algorithms to assist healthcare professionals in several decision scenarios. Following the Predictive, Descriptive and Relevant (PDR) framework, the definition of interpretable machine learning as a machine-learning model that explicitly and in a simple frame determines relationships either contained in data or learned by the model that are relevant for its functioning and the categorization of models by post-hoc, acquiring interpretability after training, or model-based, being intrinsically embedded in the algorithm design. We overview a selection of eight algorithms, both post-hoc and model-based, that can be used for such purposes.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Healthcare professionals are seeking interpretable machine learning algorithms to assist in various decision scenarios.
- The Predictive, Descriptive and Relevant (PDR) framework defines interpretable machine learning as a model that explicitly and simply determines relationships relevant to its functioning.
- The paper categorizes models as either post-hoc, acquiring interpretability after training, or model-based, being intrinsically embedded in the algorithm design.
- The paper overviews eight algorithms, both post-hoc and model-based, that can be used for such purposes.
Plain English Explanation
Healthcare professionals are looking for machine learning algorithms that are easy to understand and explain. The Predictive, Descriptive and Relevant (PDR) framework defines interpretable machine learning as a model that can clearly and simply show the relationships in the data or what the model has learned that are important for it to work.
There are two main types of interpretable machine learning models: post-hoc and model-based. Post-hoc models become interpretable after they are trained, while model-based models are designed to be interpretable from the start. The paper looks at eight different algorithms, both post-hoc and model-based, that can be used to build these types of interpretable models.
Technical Explanation
The paper discusses the use of interpretable machine learning algorithms in healthcare to assist professionals in various decision scenarios. It outlines the Predictive, Descriptive and Relevant (PDR) framework, which defines interpretable machine learning as a model that can explicitly and simply determine relationships that are relevant to its functioning.
The paper categorizes interpretable machine learning models into two main types: post-hoc and model-based. Post-hoc models acquire interpretability after the training process, while model-based approaches are designed to be intrinsically interpretable. The paper provides an overview of eight different algorithms, both post-hoc and model-based, that can be used to build interpretable models for healthcare applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive overview of interpretable machine learning approaches, including both post-hoc and model-based techniques. However, it does not delve into the specific strengths, weaknesses, and use cases of each algorithm in depth. Additional research may be needed to fully understand the tradeoffs and appropriate applications of the different interpretable modeling approaches.
Furthermore, the paper does not address the potential challenges or limitations of implementing interpretable machine learning in real-world healthcare settings, such as issues around data privacy, model fairness, and user acceptance. Further work may be needed to investigate these practical considerations.
Overall, the paper serves as a useful introduction to the field of interpretable machine learning in healthcare, but more detailed analysis and evidence-based guidance would be beneficial for healthcare professionals looking to adopt these techniques.
Conclusion
This paper provides an overview of the use of interpretable machine learning algorithms in healthcare, outlining the Predictive, Descriptive and Relevant (PDR) framework and the categorization of models as post-hoc or model-based. By reviewing eight different interpretable algorithms, the paper introduces healthcare professionals to various techniques that can be used to build transparent and explainable models to support decision-making.
While the paper offers a high-level introduction to the topic, further research may be needed to fully understand the practical considerations and tradeoffs of implementing interpretable machine learning in real-world healthcare settings. Nonetheless, this work contributes to the growing body of research on designing interpretable ML systems to enhance trust and principles for interpretable and explainable AI in the medical domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
Designing Interpretable ML System to Enhance Trust in Healthcare: A Systematic Review to Proposed Responsible Clinician-AI-Collaboration Framework
Elham Nasarian, Roohallah Alizadehsani, U. Rajendra Acharya, Kwok-Leung Tsui
0
0
This paper explores the significant impact of AI-based medical devices, including wearables, telemedicine, large language models, and digital twins, on clinical decision support systems. It emphasizes the importance of producing outcomes that are not only accurate but also interpretable and understandable to clinicians, addressing the risk that lack of interpretability poses in terms of mistrust and reluctance to adopt these technologies in healthcare. The paper reviews interpretable AI processes, methods, applications, and the challenges of implementation in healthcare, focusing on quality control to facilitate responsible communication between AI systems and clinicians. It breaks down the interpretability process into data pre-processing, model selection, and post-processing, aiming to foster a comprehensive understanding of the crucial role of a robust interpretability approach in healthcare and to guide future research in this area. with insights for creating responsible clinician-AI tools for healthcare, as well as to offer a deeper understanding of the challenges they might face. Our research questions, eligibility criteria and primary goals were identified using Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guideline and PICO method; PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science databases were systematically searched using sensitive and specific search strings. In the end, 52 publications were selected for data extraction which included 8 existing reviews and 44 related experimental studies. The paper offers general concepts of interpretable AI in healthcare and discuss three-levels interpretability process. Additionally, it provides a comprehensive discussion of evaluating robust interpretability AI in healthcare. Moreover, this survey introduces a step-by-step roadmap for implementing responsible AI in healthcare.
4/11/2024
A Framework for Interpretability in Machine Learning for Medical Imaging
Alan Q. Wang, Batuhan K. Karaman, Heejong Kim, Jacob Rosenthal, Rachit Saluja, Sean I. Young, Mert R. Sabuncu
0
0
Interpretability for machine learning models in medical imaging (MLMI) is an important direction of research. However, there is a general sense of murkiness in what interpretability means. Why does the need for interpretability in MLMI arise? What goals does one actually seek to address when interpretability is needed? To answer these questions, we identify a need to formalize the goals and elements of interpretability in MLMI. By reasoning about real-world tasks and goals common in both medical image analysis and its intersection with machine learning, we identify five core elements of interpretability: localization, visual recognizability, physical attribution, model transparency, and actionability. From this, we arrive at a framework for interpretability in MLMI, which serves as a step-by-step guide to approaching interpretability in this context. Overall, this paper formalizes interpretability needs in the context of medical imaging, and our applied perspective clarifies concrete MLMI-specific goals and considerations in order to guide method design and improve real-world usage. Our goal is to provide practical and didactic information for model designers and practitioners, inspire developers of models in the medical imaging field to reason more deeply about what interpretability is achieving, and suggest future directions of interpretability research.
4/17/2024
From Explainable to Interpretable Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing in Healthcare: How Far from Reality?
Guangming Huang, Yingya Li, Shoaib Jameel, Yunfei Long, Giorgos Papanastasiou
0
0
Deep learning (DL) has substantially enhanced natural language processing (NLP) in healthcare research. However, the increasing complexity of DL-based NLP necessitates transparent model interpretability, or at least explainability, for reliable decision-making. This work presents a thorough scoping review of explainable and interpretable DL in healthcare NLP. The term eXplainable and Interpretable Artificial Intelligence (XIAI) is introduced to distinguish XAI from IAI. Different models are further categorized based on their functionality (model-, input-, output-based) and scope (local, global). Our analysis shows that attention mechanisms are the most prevalent emerging IAI technique. The use of IAI is growing, distinguishing it from XAI. The major challenges identified are that most XIAI does not explore global modelling processes, the lack of best practices, and the lack of systematic evaluation and benchmarks. One important opportunity is to use attention mechanisms to enhance multi-modal XIAI for personalized medicine. Additionally, combining DL with causal logic holds promise. Our discussion encourages the integration of XIAI in Large Language Models (LLMs) and domain-specific smaller models. In conclusion, XIAI adoption in healthcare requires dedicated in-house expertise. Collaboration with domain experts, end-users, and policymakers can lead to ready-to-use XIAI methods across NLP and medical tasks. While challenges exist, XIAI techniques offer a valuable foundation for interpretable NLP algorithms in healthcare.
5/13/2024
Data Science Principles for Interpretable and Explainable AI
Kris Sankaran
0
0
Society's capacity for algorithmic problem-solving has never been greater. Artificial Intelligence is now applied across more domains than ever, a consequence of powerful abstractions, abundant data, and accessible software. As capabilities have expanded, so have risks, with models often deployed without fully understanding their potential impacts. Interpretable and interactive machine learning aims to make complex models more transparent and controllable, enhancing user agency. This review synthesizes key principles from the growing literature in this field. We first introduce precise vocabulary for discussing interpretability, like the distinction between glass box and explainable algorithms. We then explore connections to classical statistical and design principles, like parsimony and the gulfs of interaction. Basic explainability techniques -- including learned embeddings, integrated gradients, and concept bottlenecks -- are illustrated with a simple case study. We also review criteria for objectively evaluating interpretability approaches. Throughout, we underscore the importance of considering audience goals when designing interactive algorithmic systems. Finally, we outline open challenges and discuss the potential role of data science in addressing them. Code to reproduce all examples can be found at https://go.wisc.edu/3k1ewe.
5/20/2024