Semantic Similarity Score for Measuring Visual Similarity at Semantic Level
2406.03865
0
0
Abstract
Semantic communication, as a revolutionary communication architecture, is considered a promising novel communication paradigm. Unlike traditional symbol-based error-free communication systems, semantic-based visual communication systems extract, compress, transmit, and reconstruct images at the semantic level. However, widely used image similarity evaluation metrics, whether pixel-based MSE or PSNR or structure-based MS-SSIM, struggle to accurately measure the loss of semantic-level information of the source during system transmission. This presents challenges in evaluating the performance of visual semantic communication systems, especially when comparing them with traditional communication systems. To address this, we propose a semantic evaluation metric -- SeSS (Semantic Similarity Score), based on Scene Graph Generation and graph matching, which shifts the similarity scores between images into semantic-level graph matching scores. Meanwhile, semantic similarity scores for tens of thousands of image pairs are manually annotated to fine-tune the hyperparameters in the graph matching algorithm, aligning the metric more closely with human semantic perception. The performance of the SeSS is tested on different datasets, including (1)images transmitted by traditional and semantic communication systems at different compression rates, (2)images transmitted by traditional and semantic communication systems at different signal-to-noise ratios, (3)images generated by large-scale model with different noise levels introduced, and (4)cases of images subjected to certain special transformations. The experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of SeSS, indicating that the metric can measure the semantic-level differences in semantic-level information of images and can be used for evaluation in visual semantic communication systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel Semantic Similarity Score (SSS) for measuring visual similarity at the semantic level.
- The SSS aims to quantify the semantic-level similarity between images, going beyond just low-level visual features.
- The authors propose using a dual-stream neural network architecture to extract both visual and semantic representations, which are then combined to compute the final similarity score.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way to measure how similar two images are, based on their underlying meaning or "semantics" rather than just their surface-level visual features. The key idea is that two images can look quite different but still convey a similar high-level concept or meaning.
For example, an image of a dog and an image of a wolf may not have much visual overlap, but they both represent the broad concept of a canine. The authors' Semantic Similarity Score (SSS) is designed to capture this higher-level semantic relationship between images, rather than just looking at low-level visual features like color and texture.
To compute the SSS, the authors use a neural network with two "streams" - one that extracts visual features and one that extracts semantic features. These two representations are then combined to produce the final similarity score. This allows the system to understand the deeper meaning behind the images, not just their surface appearances.
Technical Explanation
The core of the authors' approach is a dual-stream neural network architecture. One stream focuses on extracting visual features from the input images, while the other stream extracts semantic features. These two representations are then fused together to compute the final Semantic Similarity Score (SSS).
The visual stream uses a standard convolutional neural network to capture low-level visual characteristics like shape, color, and texture. The semantic stream, on the other hand, leverages a language model to extract higher-level conceptual information about the image contents. This allows the system to understand the broader meaning and context of the visuals, beyond just their surface appearance.
To train the model, the authors use a contrastive learning objective that encourages the network to map semantically similar images close together in the joint visual-semantic embedding space, while pushing apart images with different meanings. This enables the SSS to quantify the overall semantic-level similarity between the input images.
Critical Analysis
The authors' use of a dual-stream architecture to separately model visual and semantic representations is a key strength of this work. By explicitly disentangling these two modalities, the SSS can better capture the nuanced relationships between images that go beyond just low-level visual similarity.
However, one potential limitation is the reliance on a pre-trained language model for the semantic stream. The performance of this component is heavily dependent on the quality and breadth of the model's underlying knowledge base. If the language model fails to capture certain semantic concepts relevant to the images, the SSS may not fully reflect the true similarity.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the trade-offs between the visual and semantic components when computing the final similarity score. It would be valuable to understand how the system behaves when the visual and semantic signals conflict or diverge, and how the fusion mechanism handles such cases.
Overall, the proposed Semantic Similarity Score is a promising approach for going beyond surface-level visual matching and capturing deeper, more meaningful relationships between images. Further research exploring the robustness and broader applicability of this metric would be valuable.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel Semantic Similarity Score (SSS) that aims to quantify the semantic-level similarity between images, going beyond just low-level visual features. By using a dual-stream neural network architecture to extract both visual and semantic representations, the SSS can capture the deeper meaning and context of the image contents.
The SSS has the potential to enable more intelligent and nuanced image retrieval, recommendation, and comparison systems. Rather than just finding visually similar images, the SSS could help surface conceptually related images that convey a similar high-level idea or meaning. This could have applications in areas like image-to-image translation, scene recognition, and visual search.
Overall, the Semantic Similarity Score represents an intriguing step towards more sophisticated and semantically-aware image understanding capabilities.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
How to Evaluate Semantic Communications for Images with ViTScore Metric?
Tingting Zhu, Bo Peng, Jifan Liang, Tingchen Han, Hai Wan, Jingqiao Fu, Junjie Chen
0
0
Semantic communications (SC) have been expected to be a new paradigm shifting to catalyze the next generation communication, whose main concerns shift from accurate bit transmission to effective semantic information exchange in communications. However, the previous and widely-used metrics for images are not applicable to evaluate the image semantic similarity in SC. Classical metrics to measure the similarity between two images usually rely on the pixel level or the structural level, such as the PSNR and the MS-SSIM. Straightforwardly using some tailored metrics based on deep-learning methods in CV community, such as the LPIPS, is infeasible for SC. To tackle this, inspired by BERTScore in NLP community, we propose a novel metric for evaluating image semantic similarity, named Vision Transformer Score (ViTScore). We prove theoretically that ViTScore has 3 important properties, including symmetry, boundedness, and normalization, which make ViTScore convenient and intuitive for image measurement. To evaluate the performance of ViTScore, we compare ViTScore with 3 typical metrics (PSNR, MS-SSIM, and LPIPS) through 4 classes of experiments: (i) correlation with BERTScore through evaluation of image caption downstream CV task, (ii) evaluation in classical image communications, (iii) evaluation in image semantic communication systems, and (iv) evaluation in image semantic communication systems with semantic attack. Experimental results demonstrate that ViTScore is robust and efficient in evaluating the semantic similarity of images. Particularly, ViTScore outperforms the other 3 typical metrics in evaluating the image semantic changes by semantic attack, such as image inverse with Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs). This indicates that ViTScore is an effective performance metric when deployed in SC scenarios.
4/23/2024
📈
Semantic Approach to Quantifying the Consistency of Diffusion Model Image Generation
Brinnae Bent
0
0
In this study, we identify the need for an interpretable, quantitative score of the repeatability, or consistency, of image generation in diffusion models. We propose a semantic approach, using a pairwise mean CLIP (Contrastive Language-Image Pretraining) score as our semantic consistency score. We applied this metric to compare two state-of-the-art open-source image generation diffusion models, Stable Diffusion XL and PixArt-{alpha}, and we found statistically significant differences between the semantic consistency scores for the models. Agreement between the Semantic Consistency Score selected model and aggregated human annotations was 94%. We also explored the consistency of SDXL and a LoRA-fine-tuned version of SDXL and found that the fine-tuned model had significantly higher semantic consistency in generated images. The Semantic Consistency Score proposed here offers a measure of image generation alignment, facilitating the evaluation of model architectures for specific tasks and aiding in informed decision-making regarding model selection.
4/16/2024
👁️
Semantic-embedded Similarity Prototype for Scene Recognition
Chuanxin Song, Hanbo Wu, Xin Ma, Yibin Li
0
0
Due to the high inter-class similarity caused by the complex composition and the co-existing objects across scenes, numerous studies have explored object semantic knowledge within scenes to improve scene recognition. However, a resulting challenge emerges as object information extraction techniques require heavy computational costs, thereby burdening the network considerably. This limitation often renders object-assisted approaches incompatible with edge devices in practical deployment. In contrast, this paper proposes a semantic knowledge-based similarity prototype, which can help the scene recognition network achieve superior accuracy without increasing the computational cost in practice. It is simple and can be plug-and-played into existing pipelines. More specifically, a statistical strategy is introduced to depict semantic knowledge in scenes as class-level semantic representations. These representations are used to explore correlations between scene classes, ultimately constructing a similarity prototype. Furthermore, we propose to leverage the similarity prototype to support network training from the perspective of Gradient Label Softening and Batch-level Contrastive Loss, respectively. Comprehensive evaluations on multiple benchmarks show that our similarity prototype enhances the performance of existing networks, all while avoiding any additional computational burden in practical deployments. Code and the statistical similarity prototype will be available at https://github.com/ChuanxinSong/SimilarityPrototype
5/21/2024
🧪
Similarity Metrics for MR Image-To-Image Translation
Melanie Dohmen, Mark Klemens, Ivo Baltruschat, Tuan Truong, Matthias Lenga
0
0
Image-to-image translation can create large impact in medical imaging, for instance the possibility to synthetically transform images to other modalities, sequence types, higher resolutions or lower noise levels. In order to assure a high level of patient safety, these methods are mostly validated by human reader studies, which require a considerable amount of time and costs. Quantitative metrics have been used to complement such studies and to provide reproducible and objective assessment of synthetic images. Even though the SSIM and PSNR metrics are extensively used, they do not detect all types of errors in synthetic images as desired. Other metrics could provide additional useful evaluation. In this study, we give an overview and a quantitative analysis of 15 metrics for assessing the quality of synthetically generated images. We include 11 full-reference metrics (SSIM, MS-SSIM, CW-SSIM, PSNR, MSE, NMSE, MAE, LPIPS, DISTS, NMI and PCC), three non-reference metrics (BLUR, MLC, MSLC) and one downstream task segmentation metric (DICE) to detect 11 kinds of typical distortions and artifacts that occur in MR images. In addition, we analyze the influence of four prominent normalization methods (Minmax, cMinmax, Zscore and Quantile) on the different metrics and distortions. Finally, we provide adverse examples to highlight pitfalls in metric assessment and derive recommendations for effective usage of the analyzed similarity metrics for evaluation of image-to-image translation models.
6/19/2024